Protank 2 vs Aro Pyrex Tank

Status
Not open for further replies.

Trayce

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 28, 2013
830
495
Multiversal
After using a PT2 for a week, my Aro tanks arrived. Compared to the PT2 there is a lot to like about the Aro, but this is all JMO, and YMMV. (Using this on a Vamo V3.)

The PT2 hits great but it had a nasty metallic taste that even washing with Dawn and vinegar was hard pressed to remove. Finally after 30ml or so of juice that's mostly gone, but ...

...my biggest gripe with the PT2 is that I can't taste anything in it except the Captain Black N.E.T. I made. And even then, it's just the tobacco flavor I get. I added innumerable drops of TFA DIY vanilla cupcake directly to the PT2 tank and could not taste anything but the NET. I tried more power, less power...

Emptied the NET, washed the PT2 and made fresh VG/vanilla juice, and could not taste a thing. Again vaped up and down the power grid looking for more flavor. (2.0 ohm @ 7.5 - 8.5 watts, but dropped down as low as 5w and as high as 9.5w taking hits at each step.) Added 50% PG and more vanilla and still could not taste a thing. So added even more vanilla from another vendor (also DIY concentrated drops) and the vape actually started to burn my throat not because of the TH or watts, but because of all the food flavoring in it... and STILL I could not taste any vanilla! And it's the same with my DIY Jolly Ranger Grape juice. Tastes great in cartos on the cigalike, but cannot taste a thing in the PT2.

All to say, because of the flavors of juice I personally vape, the PT2 is only good for my NETs. And I will enjoy those in it, but not much else from the looks of it. I am hoping this changes when I re-wick with cotton, which I have yet to do.

What I love about the PT2, though, is 1) being able to take it completely apart to clean it, 2) using my own rubber drip tip, and 3) it is easy to fill. You can take off the base and direct drops from an eye dropper between the center air shaft threads. It also looks good on the Vamo.

Overall the PT2 is a very appealing device but falls way short (for me) in the flavor department. But again, cotton wicking might change all that.

The Aro, OTOH, has GREAT flavor compared to the PT2! Been vaping my DIY vanilla/caramel/chocolate juice all day. It hits nice too, tighter than the PT2 [although both are still too airy for my liking and I have an air flow controller on the way]. But the immediate impression, is "YAY! Hits good and tastes great!" (I did wash it with hot water before using but did not use soap, and I detected no metal or other odd tastes.)

The tank on the Aro is big enough and it has a nice build quality. It is thinner than the Vamo so doesn't look quite as nice sitting on it as the PT2 and the windows don't line up with the face of the Vamo, for those who like symmetry.

The metal drip tip is not removable but is comfortable. However the biggest gripe I have with the Aro is that the air shaft is very much receded into the tank when you remove the base, so there is no way to fill the tank except via needle-tip bottle or syringe. That's a drag because it is very convenient to be able to just drip juice into a tank, like you can with the PT2.

So overall there are things to like and dislike about each of them. I am glad I have a PT2 because it's perfect for NETs. And I'm glad to have the Aros for my other juices. I do wish they came apart like the PT2.

The other huge advantage of the Aro is that it's cheap. It does require its own Aro heads though.

While both these clearos are nice, I hate to say I still feel a lack compared to cartos. When I hit a carto the vapor somehow feels like it has "body"... almost like smoke. Like it has heft and feel... Hits off clearos - even big fat monster hits - feel 'thin'. Like the quality of the vapor is not the same.

I hope (again) cotton wicking might make a difference because I really want to be satisfied with clearos. I stopped vaping b/c I got so tired of dealing with cartos on the cigalike... having to boil them when they got gunky or started tasting weird or hitting bad, etc. I don't want to start that over with a carto tank now. It's also too expensive buying cartos all the time. At least clearo heads can be rebuilt. Much more economic!

So I haven't exactly found Nirvana, but ...



Aro above on Vamo 3 and Aro tank below:



The PT2 on the Vamo V3:



And filling the PT2 below:
 

roasted

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
May 22, 2013
180
52
USA
I have similar experiences. The ARO is definitely a step up over the Protank. It's cheaper and wrapped in metal. The taste of the Protank is the ultimate bummer and something I've been unable to get rid of. Filling the ARO is a bit more difficult than the Protank, but far from impossible. To date I've ran about 10 tanks through my AROs, yet I've never used a syringe or a special dripper tip. I just tilt the tank and let it dribble slowly down the side of the tank.

The heads are equally as easy to rebuild vs the Protank. Right now I'm experimenting with other types of wicks to see which I like best. Currently vaping with peaches and cream yarn from walmart. So far, so good.
 

Trayce

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 28, 2013
830
495
Multiversal
I have similar experiences. The ARO is definitely a step up over the Protank. It's cheaper and wrapped in metal. The taste of the Protank is the ultimate bummer and something I've been unable to get rid of. Filling the ARO is a bit more difficult than the Protank, but far from impossible. To date I've ran about 10 tanks through my AROs, yet I've never used a syringe or a special dripper tip. I just tilt the tank and let it dribble slowly down the side of the tank.

WOW! I'm going to try that. It looked impossible to me. :)

The heads are equally as easy to rebuild vs the Protank. Right now I'm experimenting with other types of wicks to see which I like best. Currently vaping with peaches and cream yarn from walmart. So far, so good.

Good to know! I'm also looking to get P&C yarn but the local Walmart is out of stock. Bummer!
 

roasted

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
May 22, 2013
180
52
USA
How the the peaches and cream mix with the other flavors? :D

Looks like I've got to try the ARO also, I've been eying it, but couldn't put my finger on it through the sceen. I got to get a touch screen now.

Thanks for the heads up..:2cool:

Peaches and Cream is the brand, not a flavor of the yarn. I only just learned this about 5 hours ago. :p
 

ScottP

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 9, 2013
6,392
18,809
Houston, TX
The other huge advantage of the Aro is that it's cheap. It does require its own Aro heads though.

Sort of true. While the Pro Tank heads will not work on the ARO, the ARO head SHOULD work on the PT. I know the ARO heads work on my EVOD but not vise-verse. Maybe try an ARO head on the PT and see if that improves the taste some.
 

Trayce

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 28, 2013
830
495
Multiversal
Sort of true. While the Pro Tank heads will not work on the ARO, the ARO head SHOULD work on the PT. I know the ARO heads work on my EVOD but not vise-verse. Maybe try an ARO head on the PT and see if that improves the taste some.


Wow, good to know but I'm surprised since the Aro heads are quite different with their double gaskets and "telescoping" type configuration. I'll have to try that! (Just got back online after 2 days of the modem/router dying and waiting for a replacement so am catching up, but I will DEF try putting an Aro head on PT2 and reporting back!!)
 

Trayce

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 28, 2013
830
495
Multiversal
How the the peaches and cream mix with the other flavors? :D

:D I'd love to extoll the virtues of cotton yarn but all the local Walmarts are out of Ecru P&C!!! Too many darn vapers in L.A.! I really want to see if it improves the flavor of the PT2, and now I'm anxious to try the Aro head on the PT2 too, as Scott P suggested! Hope to get around to that tonight!
 

Trayce

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 28, 2013
830
495
Multiversal
I have similar experiences. [...] To date I've ran about 10 tanks through my AROs, yet I've never used a syringe or a special dripper tip. I just tilt the tank and let it dribble slowly down the side of the tank.

Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!! Yes, it IS easy and almost even easier than the PT2. That's a huge convenience and I thought of you every time I filled the tank after I read this! :D
 

Trayce

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 28, 2013
830
495
Multiversal
Sort of true. While the Pro Tank heads will not work on the ARO, the ARO head SHOULD work on the PT. I know the ARO heads work on my EVOD but not vise-verse. Maybe try an ARO head on the PT and see if that improves the taste some.

You were exactly right. The Aro heads DO work on the PT2!! The pin nearly exits the base and definitely sits lower than the stock Kanger head, so when the tank is fully seated finger tight, it's maybe 1/2 a turn higher than the stock (at least in this case with this one head I've just tried). But I have an air flow controller on, so I just rotate the top portion up to meet the base of the tank.

And YES it delivers much more flavor and hits great! [I do have an issue with the taste of silica, especially in new heads, Aro included, but that's a separate thing and I'm working on switching wicking materials]. But yes, imho the Aro head in the PT2 is a GIANT improvement. If it wasn't for the taste of silica I'd feel 'done.'

One note: after vaping 80% VG for 30 min or so I did check for leaks and there was a small amount of liquid (very small) on the pin of the Vamo. However these Aro heads leak on to the pin when used on the Aro tanks too. Mine do, anyway. But the PT2 tank itself was perfectly fine.

Thanks so much for pointing this out... now I only have to get Aro heads! (Don't own an EVOD.) :D
 

Zod

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 4, 2010
182
69
Salt Lake
Just an FYI, if you want the fatter Aro tank akin to the ProTank, Smok's version is called the Trophy. I have a v1 & V2 and yeah, they look better on a Vamo style fat mod. Exact same guts as an Aro, so I only need to buy one head for all my tanks. These also fit their teardrop shaped tank (can't remember it's name) but that thing just looks doofy to me.
 

hurricanegirl100

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 29, 2012
1,035
1,310
The burbies of Cleveland
SmokTech has a BCC tank out that some sites call the Leader. I've got one here right now, and it's lableled "SMOK PBCV2" - uses the same heads as the Aro (I've got a pile of those, too) and is really similar to the Kanger Pro II. SmokTech's PBC is a glass BCC clearo that's encased in plastic, removeable drip tip, both ends come off for easy cleaning. Best part is that the PBCV2 isn't naked, unprotected glass and it's almost half the price (at 10.50 each) as the Protank II (at 18.99). Also available as the PBCV1, which is the same clearo with a larger juice capacity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread