With all the discussions about which is better;
protected Li-ion cells or unprotected IMR cells
I would like to offer an option for modders to consider.
For Big Battery 3.7 volt mods, incorporate overvoltage, undervoltage, overcurrent, short circuit protection AND the 'Safer' IMR chemistry.
Some modders use PTC fuses which adds some degree of safety, but what about the protection boards that are used on Li-ion cells sold by Ultrafire, Trustfire, and AW?
These boards come in three basic versions based on peak current but the operation is basically the same. A controller chip (6 pin chip in photos) and 1, 2 or 3 dual Mosfets (the 8 pin chips) for a max current of 3amps, 6 amps, or 9 amps (some production variability). This allows the modder to design for a max current (9 to 10 amps isn't always needed).
I use several types of unprotected Li-ion cells from laptop reclaims, cheap Chinese cells, better Japanese cells, and even IMR LiMnNi 'Safer' cells, but ALWAYS include one of these cheap protection boards. The boards do drop a little voltage. The 3 mosfet board drops the least, but even the 2 mosfet board only drops about 0.120 volts @ 3 amps. Wiring these to unprotected cells isn't difficult.
Some folks have had problems with the boards, cutting out on them and disabling the cell. But isn't that a 'Good Thing"?
Just another option for the modder to consider.
protected Li-ion cells or unprotected IMR cells
I would like to offer an option for modders to consider.
For Big Battery 3.7 volt mods, incorporate overvoltage, undervoltage, overcurrent, short circuit protection AND the 'Safer' IMR chemistry.
Some modders use PTC fuses which adds some degree of safety, but what about the protection boards that are used on Li-ion cells sold by Ultrafire, Trustfire, and AW?
These boards come in three basic versions based on peak current but the operation is basically the same. A controller chip (6 pin chip in photos) and 1, 2 or 3 dual Mosfets (the 8 pin chips) for a max current of 3amps, 6 amps, or 9 amps (some production variability). This allows the modder to design for a max current (9 to 10 amps isn't always needed).
I use several types of unprotected Li-ion cells from laptop reclaims, cheap Chinese cells, better Japanese cells, and even IMR LiMnNi 'Safer' cells, but ALWAYS include one of these cheap protection boards. The boards do drop a little voltage. The 3 mosfet board drops the least, but even the 2 mosfet board only drops about 0.120 volts @ 3 amps. Wiring these to unprotected cells isn't difficult.
Some folks have had problems with the boards, cutting out on them and disabling the cell. But isn't that a 'Good Thing"?
Just another option for the modder to consider.
Last edited: