So I thought I'd come back to this with what I've been doing lately. Other broke people, or anyone, may like this...
So as I said, I stopped the gel I was originally using with BP in it. It was just too drying, and I didn't seem to ever get used to it.
I hit the 4-month mark, still having acne, and just got tired of it. I'm not that vain, but c'mon. 4 straight months? Getting really tired of it. Started reading.
Stopped exfoliating so much. Apparently that's not good for your skin.
And I started looking at products. I didn't want to have to buy stuff, but I was getting sick of it. I don't ever wear make-up, I wash my face twice a day, I stopped scrubbing it to death... what else was I doing wrong? Ugh.
What I found is that reviews were all over the place. It didn't seem like anything had consistent good marks.
Except, surprisingly, the cheapest 2 things of all, which you probably have in your fridge and medicine cabinet right now.
Asprin facial masks, and egg masks (as per Panini

).
The asprin facial mask is just 2 or 3 tabs crushed or dissolved in a tablespoon of water (some people also add honey). Put it all over your face - looks weird, but whatever. Wait 10 or 20 minutes, and rinse it off. It kind of exfoliates since it's a bit gritty. It's not recommended to do this more than twice a week, as your skin will adjust to it and it may stop working.
It's fairly strong, and for people who have break-outs with periods of clear skin in between, you can apparently try asprin dissolved in vodka as a very strong spot treatment - but this is NOT recommended for your whole face!
My skin feels a lot better after doing that, and zits that were getting ready to form seem smaller. It's a tiny bit drying, but not bad. It's actually less drying for me than the Neutrogena acne wash was.
The egg mask also had consistent high marks. Once I realized I could just eat the left over egg (egg and toast makes a great snack), I realized it really isn't expensive - it's actually pretty close to free!
So I'm going to try doing that as well. You can also apparently use the yolk of the egg as a natural moisturizer, after doing the egg white mask. 2-in-1!
...And just make some scrambled eggs with the left-overs after. Waste not, want not.