Respiratory infections and vaping.

Status
Not open for further replies.

ScottP

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 9, 2013
6,393
18,809
Houston, TX
I thought to myself something must have prevented me from getting the strep part.

Awesome. As I link above PG is proven to kill Strep so I have little doubt that it played at least some part in your not getting it. Apparently whatever caused the actual cold part was not stopped, but hey no Strep is still a + in my book.
 

Barbara21

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 21, 2013
1,055
1,443
Greenville, SC, USA
I am unable to find any direct links to this study, which was done back in the 1940's ...

The report of the 3 years' study of the clinical application of the disinfection of air by glycol vapors in a children's convalescent home showed a marked reduction in the number of acute respiratory infections occurring in the wards treated with both propylene and triethylene glycols. Whereas in the control wards 132 infections occurred during the course of the three winters, there were only 13 such instances in the glycol wards during the same period.

Yeah, that was the study! I remembered that it involved children but I thought it was in a hospital.

Pretty interesting. Sounds like it should be investigated further.
 

ScottP

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 9, 2013
6,393
18,809
Houston, TX
Since the wife and I started vaping in January neither of us has gotten sick at all. My wife has MS and her medications can cause her to be more susceptible to getting sick anyway, so she is usually sick a few times per year. Especially since she works in a Middle School. It will be VERY interesting if she doesn't get sick at all this winter.
 

candimccann

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 15, 2012
624
693
Lenexa, KS, US
www.youtube.com
I'm 40 years old and have had at least 2 bouts of bronchitis every year for the last 20 years...until I quit smoking and started vaping. I have not had bronchitis in a year and half. That's all the proof I need and enough proof to convince my doctor that my switch was for the better.
 

supermarket

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 2, 2010
1,401
1,852
Near Atlanta, Georgia, US of A
Ditto what Barbara said above.

Wanna hear gross? Know how norovirus is spread? People who have Noro vomit or have ......... Then do not wash their hands. You touch something they touched after being in the bathroom. You put your fingers in your mouth. VOILA!

Biggest cold/flu/sniffling/sneezing/coughing/aching/puking/pooping/snotting preventative measure? WASH your HANDS!

Public service announcement brought to you by your friendly vape nurse. :)




That is a common misconception, though. It CAN BE spread through the air.

What people don't realize, is when a person is sick enough and has norovirus, you can actually breath it in and get sick, because tiny particles (yes, human waste particles if you want to get specific) actually go into the environment.


Also, norovirus is EXTREMELY resilent. No, washing your hands isn't a guaranteed prevention technique. Nothing is.



Anyway, many people come to this website for information, and I think spreading false information, regardless of the motives, does more harm than good.

While it is certainly a novel idea that vaping somehow increases your chances of not getting sick, there is not a shred of evidence to back up that claim.

I'm not trying to be a party pooper, nor say it is impossible. I just don't want people to get the wrong idea from reading this thread.
 
Last edited:

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego
While it is certainly a novel idea that vaping somehow increases your chances of not getting sick, there is not a shred of evidence to back up that claim.
There may not be very much evidence, other than anecdotal, which is something we vapers know all about.
However, I would disagree that there is not a shred of evidence, since I already posted that shred of evidence earlier.

The report of the 3 years' study of the clinical application of the disinfection of air by glycol vapors in a children's convalescent home showed a marked reduction in the number of acute respiratory infections occurring in the wards treated with both propylene and triethylene glycols. Whereas in the control wards 132 infections occurred during the course of the three winters, there were only 13 such instances in the glycol wards during the same period.
 

Feisty

Full Member
Aug 23, 2013
61
33
Illinois
hi feisty, did you get the cold after you started vaping? Just curious because most people who quit cigarettes get "cold like" symptoms when they stop smoking. Its a common side effect. All the stuff that has built up in the respiratory system are now clearing out and you will get a lot of phlegm and coughing. You might feel depressed and even tired for a bit. Its withdrawals.

SOme people get it more severely than others. Give it a few weeks and you will start to feel really good.

PG is pumped in many hospitals and ORs as it does have antibacterial properties.

PS, just saw that someone else already said this.:)

Yes, I am 11 weeks free and I just got the cold on Monday night. I'm pretty sure it was a regular cold. It had all the same symptoms as a cold. Very tired, slept a lot, blowing my nose like crazy, not much of a cough but it left me without a voice for a day. Feeling better now but still have the leftover nasal sound of a cold. I never had a cough when I smoked and never experienced one when I stopped smoking.
 

NICnurse

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 18, 2010
509
775
Kansas City, MO
That is a common misconception, though. It CAN BE spread through the air.

What people don't realize, is when a person is sick enough and has norovirus, you can actually breath it in and get sick, because tiny particles (yes, human waste particles if you want to get specific) actually go into the environment.


Also, norovirus is EXTREMELY resilent. No, washing your hands isn't a guaranteed prevention technique. Nothing is.



Anyway, many people come to this website for information, and I think spreading false information, regardless of the motives, does more harm than good.

While it is certainly a novel idea that vaping somehow increases your chances of not getting sick, there is not a shred of evidence to back up that claim.

I'm not trying to be a party pooper, nor say it is impossible. I just don't want people to get the wrong idea from reading this thread.

Nothing is a 100% guarantee....But hand washing remains the first line of prevention against catching any illness.
And yes, you can breathe in noro particles, but it is a very short window of time. If you are sitting next to the person expelling *whatever* is flying out of them, you can breathe them in. After a few minutes, those particles merely settle onto objects to be picked up by your HANDS to further spread it. Handwashing does not kill noro virus, but it washes it off your hands and sends the virus down the drain. Bleach does kill Norovirus.

If I am around someone who is sick with the GI bug or I have it, I wash my hands after touching anything that is community property. And bleach the heck out of everything that I can.

Please do not be dismissive of handwashing. That is sending a false message around here as well.
 

Barbara21

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 21, 2013
1,055
1,443
Greenville, SC, USA
Nothing is a 100% guarantee....But hand washing remains the first line of prevention against catching any illness.
And yes, you can breathe in noro particles, but it is a very short window of time. If you are sitting next to the person expelling *whatever* is flying out of them, you can breathe them in. After a few minutes, those particles merely settle onto objects to be picked up by your HANDS to further spread it. Handwashing does not kill noro virus, but it washes it off your hands and sends the virus down the drain. Bleach does kill Norovirus.

If I am around someone who is sick with the GI bug or I have it, I wash my hands after touching anything that is community property. And bleach the heck out of everything that I can.

Please do not be dismissive of handwashing. That is sending a false message around here as well.

(Bolding mine...)

To add to what NICNurse said, anytime you smell anything, you are actually inhaling tiny little particles (molecule size) of whatever you are smelling. How do you think the sense of smell works? If you smell fresh chocolate-chip cookies, great! If you smell xxxx, well....

NICNurse - I give you credit. I did some clinical work in a NICU and positively know I wouldn't be able to handle it. On a totally unrelated note, having survived working as a nurse in a nurse home during an outbreak of norovirus, it takes a lot to gross me out.

Getting back to the original subject - if vapers are actually getting fewer colds, etc. than they used to, it doesn't necessarily mean that the PG in e-juice is doing anything. That could just be a benefit of no longer smoking. So it really doesn't mean anything on an individual level. But if vapers as a whole get fewer respiratory illnesses than the general population, that could point to beneficial effects of PG. In any case, it should be worthy of further research.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread