RDA Rust on my RDA turning my entire cotton red (see pic )

Status
Not open for further replies.

beckdg

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 1, 2013
11,018
35,706
TN
Not entirely true. Stainless steal can rust. And one of the places it likes to rust is the threading of two metal parts. If it was my atty, I'd check the screws and post holes just to be safe.

Now, I have had juices do this if left in a wetted\juiced up atty for a week or two... so that's most likely the issue. But if your seeing the color creeping from the posts down the cotton while in normal use, I'd looking into things just to be safe. Or change juices and coil to see if it still happens. If I took the whole atty apart and inspected it and didn't see any signs of rust, I wouldn't worry about it.
This.

I guess I'm just a screw snob. I get discoloration from cheap screws on plenty of atties before I swap them out for quality screws.

Though, usually it's a gray disintegration of metal. Haven't had red yet.

And that really does just look like oxidized joose.

But if it's coming from the posts where the coil is captured, I'd find out the screw size and replace them with quality SS screws.

Tapatyped
 

beckdg

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 1, 2013
11,018
35,706
TN
Your juice may make that fry just a lil too soggy! May even cause it to break apart in your juice leaving you with the unannounced, unexpected & uninvited dry I-died-and-went-to-hell hit...............go for it!!! [emoji14]
Pffft...

Throw a coil around that bad boy and quit whining. [emoji14]

Tapatyped
 

beckdg

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 1, 2013
11,018
35,706
TN
My atty screw collection...

3d611f7316de22e69be3094b446f5351.jpg


McMaster Carr has been a god sent.

Tapatyped
 

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,623
1
84,752
So-Cal
There is no steel best for everything. The same true for atties.

Cannot agree here. 440 is a great choice for surgical (and other) blades, it is even called "surgical steel". High carbon helps it to be a good martensitic steel.

...

For the Knife conversation, I can go with this. But I don't think I would Extend this to Atomizers.

Sure, 440C is a Good Choice for a Surgical Scalpel. It has a One Time Use. Can be made Sterile thru Passivation. Cost of Material or Manufacturing is Not Relevant. And the demands that will be Placed on the Blade are pretty much Defined and Narrow.

But can the Same thing can be Said for a Everyday Carry or a Kitchen Knife? Trade Offs might be made say for Sharpness for Corrosion Resistance. Durability/Flexibility for Hardness. Cost verses Lifespan.

The are a Lot of Factors that go into the Choice of a Blade Material for a EDC or a Kitchen Knife. And people/OEM's Don't always Prioritize them in the Same Way.

But what about an Atomizer? What is the Single Greatest Factor that goes into the Choice of a Metallic Alloy? I would think it would be that it Doesn't "Rust" of exhibited Corrosion/Decomposition while in contact with e-Liquids.

Most (just about All) Stainless Steels with satisfy the Requirements of an Atomizer with regards to Physical Durability, Appearance, Fabrication, Cost, Electrical/Magnetic Properties, etc. But some Stainless Steels have Superior "Rust" and Corrosion properties.

So to me, those Stainless Steels would be considered the "Best".

...

Do I see a fellow metallurgist here?
I've been a metallurgist for more than 10 years (research, manufacture, failure analysis), but now I am in a biomedical field (life can make surprises...)

I not sure I would call myself a Metallurgist. Because it wasn't a Primary area of Expertise. But I do have a Background in Physical Manufacturing. And although it was Not the my Main area of Instruction, I did teach Metallurgy Courses on the College level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: beckdg

USMCotaku

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 25, 2014
11,877
45,735
California
But what about an Atomizer? What is the Single Greatest Factor that goes into the Choice of a Metallic Alloy? I would think it would be that it Doesn't "Rust" of exhibited Corrosion/Decomposition while in contact with e-Liquids.

Most (just about All) Stainless Steels with satisfy the Requirements of an Atomizer with regards to Physical Durability, Appearance, Fabrication, Cost, Electrical/Magnetic Properties, etc. But some Stainless Steels have Superior "Rust" and Corrosion properties.

Don't forget heat resistance, that's important also :p
 

Gummy Bare

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 2, 2012
2,244
1,867
46
San Diego, California
Kanthal has some iron so it could rust actually. Just change the coil and clean the whole thing. It could just be the juice too though
You could get some g-plat wire... it's supposed to be 317L stainless steel annealed welding wire.

But I'm sure that could rust in the right conditions as well.
 

jrlakeman

Senior Member
Mar 25, 2015
267
156
this has been sitting for 1 week untouched because i noticed my cotton was turning red even though my juice was transparent . Is there anything i can do about it or throw it in the garbage ?
Clean it out and inspect it if its rusting you will see the stains in the grains of metal. Stainless does get surface rust if its poor quality but i doubt its that. If nothing there then its prolly just the juice doing its thing as it sits.
 

SissySpike

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 1, 2012
6,926
12,310
San Diego CA
I wonder how much a nice RDA made from Ti6Al4V would cost.... it's a titanium alloy that far more stronger and rust resistant. But it's pricey, not sure how pricey. But I'd love to have a few attys made of it. Not sure how well it conducts compared to something like 316L.
My wand from Mark buggs is Titanium It works well but Ti transfers heat pretty quickly
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread