Same recipe... Mostly PG - good ...Mostly VG - BAD

[iuseaspork]

OK... Same ratio of flavoring (2-3% tobacco) I am using 4 drops of vinegar to 10ml of juice.

90% PG the flavor is almost too much!
90% VG the flavor is not even there at all. Actually, it's almost bad!?

I'm using Wilton brand VG.

Do VG recipes need to steep longer? Do I need to up the flavor?

I'm doing this to tell if I have a reaction to PG, but I don't know if I can stand to vape the #$%* I'm making here.

 

[dotma]

lol, thats how i felt about my homemade stuff! I dont know the answers to your questions, but it is very interesting. Curious, what do you put the vinegar in there for?

 

[Hoosier]

Never used Wilton, so I have no idea what effect it would have.

I'm assuming these all steeped a bit? But, yeah, VG mixes usually need a bit more time than PG's to steep and tobaccos always seem to need at least some steeping.

 

[GoodDog]

FYI...Wilton's VG is feed grade and what you want is USP grade VG. I don't know if that's what is causing your problem or not as I've never used Wilton's VG.