John, in all those examples you gave, you were engaging in a level of personal mentoring that just can't be done on a message board unless you develop some kind of prolonged and personal one-on-one rapport with a faceless newbie. That's the problem. It's perfectly fine to demonstrate, tutor and recommend an APV to a newbie when you have the opportunity to get their undivided attention for a while, and even give them some hands-on experience. When you attempt to achieve the same thing without the huge factor of mentoring, most times you'll fall flat, confusing the hell out of them and sending them packing with their arms thrown up in frustration.
So, I'm going to modify, really clarify, my opinion a little. The Vmax is a fine recommendation for a newbie when the opportunity exists for some one-on-one mentoring. There is nothing inherently wrong with the device that would preclude its use by a new vaper. But when the information necessary to appreciate the device is mixed in with all the other recommendations for everything from a Blu to a Darwin, it becomes a confusing jumble that has almost no chance of success and is more likely to be counter-productive. Newbs just don't have the knowledge, and most lack the inclination, to sort out the wheat from the chaff in that type of environment.
"Newbs just don't have the knowledge"
Then we have a basic disagreement about whether or not a person of average intelligence can read everything I said in the "TMI" thread, over and over if necessary, until they can fully understand and appreciate the clear and significant advantages to vaping with VV.
And did you ever address why you were slamming me for recommending a non-ciggie-lookalike to the OP in that thread, who had expressed a passing interest in the Volt, while you recommended the e-Power 14650 over and over? That still has me thoroughly confused.
http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/new-members-forum/291542-way-too-much-info.html