I think one of the things people were upset about was that in Spikey's first thread a mod (i think it was epipeman) came in and said the thread would stay open as long as it stayed civil. I missed the last couple of posts in that thread, but up until that point there was nothing overly inflammatory imo. But I tried to look again and bam it was gone and a new thread was started that got ugly fast.
It did stay open for as long as it was civil.
I've read the entire thread and it went something like this;
Spikey's first post.
Debate over rules / thread deletions / bans
Support for Spikey
Support for the mods
Calm banter
(meanwhile, other threads are being made)
Spikey = banned

Thread deleted.