I am on day 3 of vaping only. Have only had one analog in those 3 days. Which for me is a miracle! Honestly, it didn't taste so great so I'm pretty confident in giving them up for good. Finally! The cravings are still there of course but getting better and easier to deal with. I have found my cravings are at their worst in the evening. I'm wondering how long it took for your cravings to go away if at all.