Retract: Sorry, re-read and think you are advising that other lifestyle changes need to happen in addition to exercise. Got it!
What I am saying is that, in my experience, and the experience of helping others with food/weight problems, that it is more important to get the eating problem behind you first, where you are
contentedly eating a healthy balanced nutrition plan
that will last you the rest of your life, and release most if not all excess weight
before beginning an exercise program. I could write a few pages on the reasons I take this position and why I think its true, but I don't think this is the proper place for it.
I'm also not talking about the casual dieter who has five pounds to lose. I don't care what they do to lose weight. I'm talking about people who have tried and tried and yet are unable to control their eating and weight.
I'm also not talking about going for walks and things like that, I'm talking about things like scheduling 40 minutes a day on the treadmill to "burn calories" or "burn that fat off."
I realize this flies in the face of what society and even medicine pumps into our minds, but I think my reasons are good. I'd be happy to discuss it via PM with anyone who wants me to expand on it.