No, I was confused. Got out the instructions, the 4.2 is a charging voltage.You're saying that the voltages listed on that switch are the nominal voltages, not the charging voltages?
I'm confused because you said the two choices were 3.7V and 4.2V earlier. That 4.2V selection is definitely not a nominal voltage, it's a charging voltage.
Says it's compatible with a nominal 3.7v and 3.8v Li-ion
Charging outputs 4.35v, 4.2v, 3.7v, 1.48v
Not sure the OP even has a Nitecore i2 ?
Back to lurkin and learnin....