Banning menthol cigarettes

Status
Not open for further replies.

mzkitty

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 28, 2011
131
0
MD
The claim is based in the fact that a disproportionate amount of African Americans and underaged smokers smoke menthol cigarettes, thus they should be banned. The claim is the flavoring makes them more palatable.

I disagree. The kids I see smoking are smoking Marlboros and Camels. However, my black friends who smoke, do smoke menthols. Then again, so do I, and I am not African American nor am I under aged. Take from that what you will. Something is not right here.

Menthol is a natural pain killer. When I was young my step-father gave me menthol cigarettes to "cure" my asthma because that is what they "cured" his asthma with in 1940's England. Menthol has a lot of uses.

I don't believe they are going to ban them, then again I never believed they would make smoking in bars illegal....
 

DawnsFolly

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 24, 2010
807
171
Saint Petersburg, Florida
... The kids I see smoking are smoking Marlboros and Camels. However, my black friends who smoke, do smoke menthols. Then again, so do I, and I am not African American nor am I under aged. ... I don't believe they are going to ban them, then again I never believed they would make smoking in bars illegal....

Right there with ya. Menthol was all I smoked for years & noticed it was getting hard to find them around here - even at the military base. I live very close to the beaches and many places closed when they banned smoking in public places. Then they decided that you can smoke in a bar if it doesn't serve food? I saw the comments & didn't see where hardly anyone believed the claims, but it will probably happen since it seems that stupidity reigns supreme these days.
 

Mary Kay

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 3, 2009
12,873
2,328
West Tampa Fl.
My Mother overdosed on Salem cigarettes in the early 60's..so her Dr. told her to switch to a non-menthol brand!
You would have thought he would tell her to quit.
The FDA knows they can't just ban cigarettes..but they have to be seen to be doing something. So it's chip chip chip away.
THis is the same tactic they are trying to do with us.
 

Joyce

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 7, 2010
1,543
333
West Virginia
My Mother overdosed on Salem cigarettes in the early 60's..so her Dr. told her to switch to a non-menthol brand!
You would have thought he would tell her to quit.
The FDA knows they can't just ban cigarettes..but they have to be seen to be doing something. So it's chip chip chip away.
THis is the same tactic they are trying to do with us.

I read an article/advertisement in TV Guide 30+ years ago, outlining a plan to outlaw cigarettes. It stated that an outright ban that early would create too much of a public outcry, and that the only way to accomplish this would be to make smoking socially unacceptable. Therefore, it must be done in small increments, first with the "you mind very much if they smoke" campaign, then banning indoor smoking, next going after outdoors, and so on. Little by little, I've watched every detail happen. The advertisement was a call for smokers to exercise their rights before it was too late.

I also watched smokers capitulate at every turn, and even apologize for their filthy habits. No one believed it would go as far as it has. I lived in Virginia at the time, and all of the smokers I tried to alert said there was too much money behind tobacco for it to go too far. I don't believe for a minute that the FDA won't attempt to ban cigarettes. Every other step has been accomplished. It's just a matter of time, maybe even years. This menthol thing is just another step. I wish I had saved that article.

They're attempting to nip vaping in the bud. It's a minor annoyance in a much larger campaign.

EDIT: I know I sound like a conspiracy nut, but I swear it is true. Once I read something, it stays with me. This article has haunted me every time another ban comes down...
 
Last edited:

Mary Kay

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 3, 2009
12,873
2,328
West Tampa Fl.
Yes Joyce, That's the plan! I meant to say they couldn't just ban cigarettes outright. I don't think they understood that with E-Cigs just emerging that everytime they chip away at something..more people turn to the alternitive. With luck we will be a bit more proactive then smokers.
My dad's "Stith" family were some of the first to export tobacco in the 1700's to England, for use as a smoking product. I guess we can blame me...lol
 

Joyce

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 7, 2010
1,543
333
West Virginia
Yes Joyce, That's the plan! I meant to say they couldn't just ban cigarettes outright. I don't think they understood that with E-Cigs just emerging that everytime they chip away at something..more people turn to the alternitive. With luck we will be a bit more proactive then smokers.
My dad's "Stith" family were some of the first to export tobacco in the 1700's to England, for use as a smoking product. I guess we can blame me...lol

Yes, MK, I think I misread you. On second read it's pretty clear that's what you said. :lol:

I guess I just had to get that out of my system. :)
 
I can't imagine a full ban ever going into effect. They'll enact a law forcing doubly large "super addictive" labels on all menthol packs or something like that. There's too much at stake, otherwise they would have banned it at the same time as vanilla, cherry, etc (I have to think there was far less research that went into that decision, but I haven't looked it up).
 

sqirl1

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 10, 2011
823
328
St. Louis, MO
^ this. I don't know ANY kids who smoke menthols regularly. it's all about the camel blues today. yeah the argument is that menthol "makes smoking harder to quit" and they want to ban it for the same reasons flavored cigs are banned (not cigars or chewin' tabaker of course) . the FDA even concluded that banning menthol cigs is a HORRIBLE idea because at that point there would just be a black market for them. that and can't you just buy menthol by itself and dip the cigs in the menthol for a while and let them dry out? what would be the point?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread