Why not just make a coffee tincture by soaking decaf 8 o'clock coffee beans in Everclear for a week. Draw off the tincture THEN add it to your VG/PG Mix.
Yuck! IMHO, one should not use such bitter ingredients for a good infusion. Long and slow with high-quality ingredients is the way to go. I've got some ground coffee soaking for 24 hours, just as a test, but also have a batch of crushed beans that will go for a week. Both are in PG, a solvent that is more than sufficient for slow infusions.
What are my options if I can't get Everclear 95% (can only find 75% around here.) Is it legal to buy it via Internet, and have it shipped to a state that I can't seem to find it in?
It depends on which state you live in. Most allow mail order alcohol, many don't.
Here's a list of states that most online liquor stores won't ship to:
[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]
Alabama, Arizona, Georgia,Ohio(ship wine only),Utah, Michigan, New Hampshire, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Tennessee, Texas, Oregon, Washington, Montana, DC, Indiana, Kentucky, Delaware, Florida, Maryland, Virginia, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, North Carolina and South Carolina.[/FONT]
Otherwise, try to find 150-proof vodka, or the strongest vodka you can find.