I also wrote Wayne on this matter. It's definitely pina colada. I like it though, and I kept mine. Drip a couple of drops of rum
juice in with it, and it's fantastic!
Here's the reply from Wayne:
We are very sorry to know you have that problem with the 'caramel' e-
juice you bought from us. Thanks for contacting us for it.
We got the similar reports from another two customers. It must have been the factory who made the mistake. But We are very sorry that none of us knew the correct taste of either caramel or Pina Colada, so we didn't find out the problem by ourselves. We already contacted the factory and required them to figure out the reason.
Thank you very much for your generosity to the mistake.
Yours sincerely,
Heaven Gifts
Weirder still, I got my "caramel" from Eastmall, and got the exact same thing. Same color, same flavor. Which makes me wonder how much of our Chinese juice comes out of the same gigantic vat.
If anyone knows of a good actual caramel, I'd love to know.