DIY Serious Help! Help A Poor DIY:er In Need

Status
Not open for further replies.

go_player

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 2, 2012
501
1,287
USA
My theory is if someone Posts saying that they Don't Like a Recipe, then something in the Recipe needs to change. Or be Removed. Or Added.

Yep- but palates differ, and what needs to be changed can be kind of subtle. Or it can be very in-your-face, if you know your flavors.

Here's an example: atm the third most-popular recipe on allTheFlavors is this one: https://alltheflavors.com/recipes/7775#sugar_cookies_and_cream_by_chrisdvr1

I've mixed this and... 0.5% TPA Butter is pure margarine for me. And not in a good way. I don't regret owning the flavor, cause I can see it being useful to add a bit of AAP to otherwise AAP-free flavors (I keep meaning to test FA custard with like 0.05% TPA Butter, etc.)

So yeah, if I see a recipe with TPA Butter at 0.5% I just _know_ I don't want to vape it as written. But if I otherwise like the profile... well that's where knowing your flavors comes in. There's usually something you can add to bring in some of the richness that losing Butter loses. But it's also important that it not just stack AAP, cause then you're right back where you started- margarine.
 

IDJoel

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 20, 2015
3,459
11,932
63
Boise, ID
Lots of good advice regarding mixing so far; and I don't have anything to add on that front. What I haven't seen discussed yet is your hardware. Good flavor is also a product of vaping at the optimal temperature. And, different recipes can taste "best," at different temperatures. Also, temperatures that might be good for chucking clouds, are often not the best for flavor.

You list your hardware as:
To clear things up this is my current setup I'm using:
Aspire nautilus 2
ELeaf iStick TC60W Mod
But, you do not mention which coils (resistance) you use, or what wattage you are vaping at. I have never used the Nautilus 2, so I have no idea what sort of a flavor device it is; but I would assume if you can get flavor out of retail juice, you ought to be able to get flavor out of your DIY.

My brief search only revealed kanthol coils so I imagine you are using your iStick in power (wattage) mode. In the following table, you will notice each resistance level has a different recommended range:
upload_2017-12-20_22-25-28.png

It is important to note that these recommendations are just that... recommendations. I would suggest starting at least a couple of watts below the minimum recommended wattage, and work your way up one or two watts at a time; until you find that liquid's "best flavor" sweet spot, or it becomes too uncomfortable/unpleasant to vape. Remember to ignore cloud production while you are focusing on flavor production.

The Nautilus 2 has adjustable airflow. Airflow also has an affect on flavor. Too much air, and the vapor can become too thin or "diluted," and the flavor will be weak. Too little air, and the vapor can become over-saturated and muddled, and the more subtle nuances of the flavor profile can become lost. So, as you are working at finding the optimal power setting, don't forget about adjusting airflow as well.

Airflow also affects temperature. The more air, and the faster it travels across the coils, the cooler the coil will become. So there is a bit of a balancing act you will want to be aware of. If you need to restrict the airflow a bit; you may also need to reduce the wattage a touch as well. Need to open the airflow up some? You might need to bump the power up a little too.

While experimenting, remember you are vaping new creations, so the recipe might not be perfect to begin with... but there should still be some wattage/airflow combination where the flavor is "as good as it's gonna get." Note that for the recipe you are working on; and then, as you make adjustments to your recipe, return to that wattage/airflow as your starting point. As the recipe evolves, you may need to adjust the wattage a couple of tenths one way or another, and/or open or close you airflow a little, but you should be right in the ballpark.

Also, when testing new (to you at least) recipes, it is best to start with a fresh clean coil. Older gunky coils can cause the flavor to be muted and/or off-tasting. Having a clean coil assures you can taste whatever flavor that particular atomizer is able to produce.

Finally, changing recipes? Going to a different flavor profile? This may need different power and airflow settings. Don't be afraid to go through the process again. ;)

As others have already said; don't get discouraged. Learning to DIY successfully, and getting the most flavor out of your equipment, both take patience, and practice. Try to change as few variables at once; so you can more easily identify what works and what doesn't.

Best wishes and welcome to ECF!:D
 

sofarsogood

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Oct 12, 2014
5,553
14,168
Hello everyone out there that actually knows how to make DIY E juice. I need some serious help from you guys!

Long story short, I am a fan of DIY and e juice is not an exception. I have been mixing my own stuff since May/June. But even now to this day I couldn't be more dissapointed in my results. They have all been bland, tasteless and just plain horrible.

To clear things up this is my current setup I'm using:
Aspire Nautilus 2
ELeaf iStick TC60W Mod

And I am mixing with these liquids:
Capella Falvourings
NicBase PG-32 Diluted Nicotine
NicBase VG
GreenLabel PG

Now to some recipes I have been trying recently without any pleasing results:
Nicotine juice 32 mg (100% PG) : 1.88ml
PG dilutant : 1.25ml
VG dilutant : 6.00ml
Double Watermelon (CAP) 0.50ml
Dragon Fruit (CAP) : 0.37ml

Total : 10ml 6mg Nic

Nicotine juice 32 mg (100% PG) : 1.88ml
PG dilutant : 1.25ml
VG dilutant : 6.00ml
Vanilla Custard v2 (Cap) 0.40ml
Yellow Peach (Cap) : 0.70ml

Total : 10ml 6mg Nic

These are just two examples of some versions I've tested, from 70/30 VG/PG ratio to 50/50 VG/PG Ratio. I've tested from 5-15% flavouring and dosens of steeping methods. Some are just plain waiting, warm water bath and breathing. Some combinded and some not.

Now what I am wondering from you guys who can do this properly, what am I doing wrong? Am I using bad flavourings? Bad combinations or is Capella just not too good? Is my setup not good enough? Are there any special processes that need to be done to succeed? Larger badges of juice when you mix?

As you can see I am completely lost and my hope is starting to fade when it comes to DIY. If I don't get this to work soon imma start going back to buying jucie :(

Thanks for any help you can give! It's really appreciated :)
I use 1% flavoring, an all-in-one made by Capella. I mix exactly the same for a brother of mine. We've been vaping it for years with no need for even a second flavor. Cost is 1.2 cents per ml which is about 8 cents a day for me, a bit less for him. Using too much flavoring or too many flavors are common mistakes. If your food had too much flavoring you wouldn't like that either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: stols001
Wow thank you all for your great tips and suggestions!! Now I have alot of things to try out.

To clear some things up you guys where wondering. My hardware is as one said the standard kanthal coils for the Nautilius 2. At 1.7 ohms if im not correct. I vape at around 20-23 watts with those coils. I have not adjusted the airflow that much so I’ll give that a try.

To the main subject. So I should invest in some sort of sweetener for my fruity recipes as many of you suggested. I should stop trying to speed up the steeping process and just let nature do it’s thing. One thing is tho, how often should I shake my bottles when they are steeping? And how much sweetener is a good reference point? As I’ve never used that before.

And to reply to some others, no I dont smoke anymore. I can take one from time to time but that is very seldom as I dont like cigarettes anymore My sense of smell I would say is about as avarage as it can get. So no special snowflake here.

So thank you all for your tips! Really appreciated. One last thing I would like to ask before you go heywild again with awesome replys, what is you favourite flavour brand? And your favourite flavor of that brand? Need suggestions for my collection

You guys rock!
 

wheelie

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 12, 2014
2,161
2,811
Ont. Canada
www.independentont.com
I go to ( eliquid- recipes dot com) and it used to be daily and check all the new listing till I found something that I had the flavorings for. If it appealed to me and I was short a flavor or two I would order the new flavors. A lot of times I would substitute some for flavor I have already. Search box and you can type in a flavor you have and it will list all the mixes that have that flavoring. I would write down flavors and percentage then go to my ejuice calculator and put in the numbers. Good luck to you.
 

IDJoel

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 20, 2015
3,459
11,932
63
Boise, ID
My hardware is as one said the standard kanthal coils for the Nautilius 2. At 1.7 ohms if im not correct. I vape at around 20-23 watts with those coils. I have not adjusted the airflow that much so I’ll give that a try.
I would definitely back your wattage down to 8 or 10 watts and SLOWLY start increasing in 1 or 2 watt increments... until you find your "flavor sweet spot. You may have less clouds; but you should find your flavor improves.
One thing is tho, how often should I shake my bottles when they are steeping? And how much sweetener is a good reference point? As I’ve never used that before.
Try to give them a shake at least once a day for the first week; then whenever you think about it, after that. Or, if you have any electronics that are on regularly, and emit vibrations (like a washer, dryer, stereo speakers, or an older refrigerator); you could put your fresh mixes in a small box (to keep them from falling off/getting lost/breaking) and leave them on the makeshift mixer. Just be safe/smart as far as children and pets are concerned.

How much sweetener you use, will depend on which one you choose, but I would start low (0.25%-0.50%?) and move up slowly. Sweeteners often gunk up coils faster, and can mute flavors if used in to high a percentage, so it is always best to begin low (and only add more until it is sweet enough for you; or the flavor starts to suffer).
One last thing I would like to ask before you go heywild again with awesome replys, what is you favourite flavour brand? And your favourite flavor of that brand? Need suggestions for my collection
I think most of us would tell you we don't have a favorite flavor brand/manufacturer; but that we have favorite flavors of different brands.

When I first started DIY mixing, I used all TFA, because that was all I could buy at my local vape shop. It wasn't until I began to get frustrated with more than a few of my mixes, and got involved here on ECF, that I learned that most flavor manufacturers did some flavors well and others not so well. Then I had to learn which manufacturers had the best reputation for a particular flavor, try the top 3 or 4, and find the one that worked best for me. I now have favorites from TFA, CAP, INW, FA, FW, HS, and SC... and that list changes on a regular basis.

If you want to ask about particular flavors; we might be able to share our own preferences.
 

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,617
1
84,730
So-Cal
...

To the main subject. So I should invest in some sort of sweetener for my fruity recipes as many of you suggested. I should stop trying to speed up the steeping process and just let nature do it’s thing. One thing is tho, how often should I shake my bottles when they are steeping? And how much sweetener is a good reference point? As I’ve never used that before.

...

I would give it a try and See what happens.

How much Sweetener to use? Hard to say. If you go with the TFA Sweetener, maybe 1 or 2 Drops in 10ml.

BTW - There is No Steeping Needed if you use TFA Sweetener. Just Shake n' Vape. So you can add a Drop and try it. And if it Isn't enough, add another.
 

BrotherBob

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Dec 24, 2014
14,118
12,449
Sunnyvale,CA,USA
I have been mixing my own stuff since May/June.
Welcome and glad you joined.
Your doing just fine. Out of every 100 recipes I'm lucky to get 2 or 3 that I consider an ADV. I'm still not satisfied with some common flavor mixes.
what am I doing wrong?
Nicotine juice 32 mg (100% PG) : 1.88ml
PG dilutant : 1.25ml
VG dilutant : 6.00ml
Vanilla Custard v2 (Cap) 0.40ml
Yellow Peach (Cap) : 0.70ml

Total : 10ml 6mg Nic
The recipe above is not correct as written, add up the figures.
As you can see I am completely lost and my hope is starting to fade when it comes to DIY.
Suggest keep mixing recipes that are highly rated and if need be, adjust them to what you think the recipe may lack to make them your own.
 

tazzle

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 5, 2014
1,253
3,784
Athens, Greece
(oops! I wrote this about 12 hours ago, and thought I posted it, but I hadn't! Rather than try to update, I'll just post now. doh!)

@ILoveDIYEvenThoICantMixIt, don't give up! The important thing is to get one or two recipes you love to vape under your belt, which will give you some breathing room to experiment while still having juice you can enjoy every day! If you tell us what commercial juices you like, we might be able to offer some ideas!

Here are a few thoughts that might help:

Just like cooking in a kitchen, some people create their own recipes, some use recipes that others have developed, and many do both. I use a lot of recipes that other people have created, and that helps me with foundations to come up with ideas for juices perfect for me. If you search online for "e-liquid recipes" you will find sites that specialize in this, with lots of helpful tools to adapt recipes to your own needs (amount of nicotine, amount of pg/vg, etc), and even store and rate your recipes, keep track of flavorings, and search recipes by flavor(s) and popularity. There is a LOT of help and info out there.

It's a bit unusual to use only one brand of flavoring. Different brands are more well known for different flavors, so people tend to mix and match the best of each. The most widely used brands are probably The Flavor/Perfumer's Apprentice, FlavourArt, and Capella, of which the first two would be more likely to have recipes that use *only* that brand. I think I have only one regular all-Capella recipe, but it is one of my top favorites that I vape every day. I describe it a bit and give the recipe here.

While there are some recipes that use only one or two flavors, it's more common to see more ingredients since fewer flavors tend to taste "flatter" (though not always!) and layering different flavors can create a more nuanced taste. For example, looking at recipes that include Capella's Sweet Watermelon, here's one that looks like something I'd like to try:

Tiger's Blood (Artisan Clone) by Bearkat at ELR

0.50% Banana Cream (TPA)
7.50% Coconut Candy (TPA)
2.50% Sweet Mango (CAP)
7.50% Sweet Strawberry (CAP)
1.50% Sweet Watermelon (CAP)
0.50% Whipped Cream (TPA)

For browsing some recipes that ECF members enjoy that call for fewer ingredients, you should have a look at the great Recipes For Dummies thread (definitely not just for dummies :p!).

For a great Capella single flavor mix, I agree with @Sugar_and_Spice about CAP Blueberry Jam at 8%. That's my husband's current favorite all-day vape. I also agree with s_and_s about using one-shot concentrates!

Regarding the Capella custard, most people seem to use V1, which is what I use. I haven't tried V2, so can't say how different they are.

Again, let us know what retail juices you've enjoyed, and we may have some DIY mixing ideas. If you want to share what other flavors you already have, that would be useful too!

Hang in there!
 
Last edited:
(oops! I wrote this about 12 hours ago, and thought I posted it, but I hadn't! Rather than try to update, I'll just post now. doh!)

@ILoveDIYEvenThoICantMixIt, don't give up! The important thing is to get one or two recipes you love to vape under your belt, which will give you some breathing room to experiment while still having juice you can enjoy every day! If you tell us what commercial juices you like, we might be able to offer some ideas!

Here are a few thoughts that might help:

Just like cooking in a kitchen, some people create their own recipes, some use recipes that others have developed, and many do both. I use a lot of recipes that other people have created, and that helps me with foundations to come up with ideas for juices perfect for me. If you search online for "e-liquid recipes" you will find sites that specialize in this, with lots of helpful tools to adapt recipes to your own needs (amount of nicotine, amount of pg/vg, etc), and even store and rate your recipes, keep track of flavorings, and search recipes by flavor(s) and popularity. There is a LOT of help and info out there.

It's a bit unusual to use only one brand of flavoring. Different brands are more well known for different flavors, so people tend to mix and match the best of each. The most widely used brands are probably The Flavor/Perfumer's Apprentice, FlavourArt, and Capella, of which the first two would be more likely to have recipes that use *only* that brand. I think I have only one regular all-Capella recipe, but it is one of my top favorites that I vape every day. I describe it a bit and give the recipe here.

While there are some recipes that use only one or two flavors, it's more common to see more ingredients since fewer flavors tend to taste "flatter" (though not always!) and layering different flavors can create a more nuanced taste. For example, looking at recipes that include Capella's Sweet Watermelon, here's one that looks like something I'd like to try:

Tiger's Blood (Artisan Clone) by Bearkat at ELR

0.50% Banana Cream (TPA)
7.50% Coconut Candy (TPA)
2.50% Sweet Mango (CAP)
7.50% Sweet Strawberry (CAP)
1.50% Sweet Watermelon (CAP)
0.50% Whipped Cream (TPA)

For browsing some recipes that ECF members enjoy that call for fewer ingredients, you should have a look at the great Recipes For Dummies thread (definitely not just for dummies :p!).

For a great Capella single flavor mix, I agree with @Sugar_and_Spice about CAP Blueberry Jam at 8%. That's my husband's current favorite all-day vape. I also agree with s_and_s about using one-shot concentrates!

Regarding the Capella custard, most people seem to use V1, which is what I use. I haven't tried V2, so can't say how different they are.

Again, let us know what retail juices you've enjoyed, and we may have some DIY mixing ideas. If you want to share what other flavors you already have, that would be useful too!

Hang in there!
Hey there. Let me just mention some retail flavours I've tried, mostly are liquid voyage tho :p

Strawpear Dew (Liquid Voyage), Peaches And Cream (Liquid Voyage), Apricots Passion (Liquid Voyage), Pink Custard (Liquid Voyage), Cookie Custard (Liquid Voyage.) and then one called Water Dragon but I dont know the brand, that is my inspiration for my watermelon and dragonfruit recipe. Then some simple juices like a pure vanilla one from Liquia and starwberry from Liqua.

Out of all these my favourites are Starwpeardew, Peaches And Cream, Apricots Passion and the Water Dragon juice. I would kill to be able to make some of those for myself. The custard one where ok, definetly the Pink Custard but the Cookie one where waaaay to custardy for my taste xD

So these can be a inspiration to me, but since my flavour collection only is one brand for now and limited to maybe 15+. I can't really do much. So I would love some flavour tips for my next purchase.

Thanks alot guys! ♥
 

Sugar_and_Spice

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 11, 2010
13,663
35,225
between here and there
Yeah... Like you also, I was into DIY since about the time I got here to the ECF. And was buying Flavorings from Linda even before TFA was called TFA.

Check out the Date on this Thread...

Pizza Flavored e-Juice

LOL
Great thread. Wonder what ever happened to a lot of those members?

:)
 

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,617
1
84,730
So-Cal
Great thread. Wonder what ever happened to a lot of those members?

:)

Yeah I wonder that Myself sometimes when I come across an Old Thread.

About the Only person in that thread that I have seen lately is pianoguy. Bassnut posts a lot. But only in the OUTSIDE.
 

go_player

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 2, 2012
501
1,287
USA
I would definitely back your wattage down to 8 or 10 watts and SLOWLY start increasing in 1 or 2 watt increments... until you find your "flavor sweet spot. You may have less clouds; but you should find your flavor improves.

I have and for a while used a Nautilus 2, and I've tried all three of the coils you listed above, though it has been a while. I'm not that much of a hardware geek, so grain of salt, but I think it's a pretty solid MTL tank that uses factory coils. It doesn't have the flavor you're going to get from a flavor RDA, but it's pretty good. The airflow is pretty tight- IIRC you _could_ do a very restricted DL with it all the way open, but even then it was still pretty much better suited to MTL.

Your advice about starting low and ramping up is good general advice, and I always do that when breaking in a new coil/wick anyway. But, again from what I recall, the recommendations in that table seem pretty conservative to me. I'm not sure which coil @ILoveDIYEvenThoICantMixIt is using- @ILoveDIYEvenThoICantMixIt says 1.7, and there are a 1.6, a 1.8, and a 0.7, but no 1.7 that I know of (though maybe I'm just unaware of one, but that would raise other questions.) I'm going to guess that it's a 0.7, since that's what the tank comes with, but if reading the ohms off a device it could be either of the other two, one of which is a Clapton, so... I don't think 8-10 watts will do much using the 0.7 coil, and 20-23 sounds pretty legit even with the higher ohm Clapton.

I think most of us would tell you we don't have a favorite flavor brand/manufacturer; but that we have favorite flavors of different brands.

When I first started DIY mixing, I used all TFA, because that was all I could buy at my local vape shop. It wasn't until I began to get frustrated with more than a few of my mixes, and got involved here on ECF, that I learned that most flavor manufacturers did some flavors well and others not so well. Then I had to learn which manufacturers had the best reputation for a particular flavor, try the top 3 or 4, and find the one that worked best for me. I now have favorites from TFA, CAP, INW, FA, FW, HS, and SC... and that list changes on a regular basis.

If you want to ask about particular flavors; we might be able to share our own preferences.

This is a question that comes up a lot. I kind of consider there to be a "Big 7" list of brands that North American mixers have traditionally used, and that are used in a lot of published recipes (LA, FW, TFA, CAP, FA, INW, and FLV.) Then there are a number of newer brands like PUR, FE, JF, etc. that don't have the historical traction of the Big 7, but which might well have a lot more good for the average vaper flavors than, say LA (I kind of think LA gets into the Big 7 more for historical reasons than anything else.) And then there are the brands that are hard to get here, but are used a lot in Europe. And the niche brands (one of which, MF, has IMHO the best versions of a lot of flavors, but hates vapers and is difficult to work with both as a company and as an ingredient.)

Every one of the Big 7 has some _great_ flavors. If I had to do without one brand I guess I'd drop LA, but... I would be pretty unhappy to lose LA Cream Cheese Icing. So yeah, it's about individual flavorings more than about brands.

That said, I do think that the different brands have different characters, and flavors within a family are often similar within a brand. And I'd go so far as to say that some brands seem higher-quality _across their line_ than others to me. TFA has lots of great flavors, but they're just so hit and miss compared to FA... the strength of their concentrates is generally weaker, but wildly inconsistent, and there are so many TFA flavors that _almost_ everyone agrees should never be vaped. FA has less of those.

And, more subtly, there are a fair number of TFA flavors that hit an interesting and useful note, but not a very good main note. I mentioned TFA Pear vs FA Pear in a thread devoted to exactly this question and... of course we all differ, but I think most people agree with me that the FA is a really enjoyable Pear that doesn't scream out Pear (and also a very useful additive at low percentages) while TFA Pear, at least without a steep, does scream out Pear, but in a harsh and unenjoyable fashion (again, for most people- and I'll note that steeping TFA Pear yields interesting results, but I mean a long steep.)

So if you want a great Pear one answer is to use mostly FA Pear, with a bit of TFA to add realism. Ideally you want both. But I think as a main Pear flavor the FA is in some real sense a higher quality flavoring, and I think the FA flavors are on average higher quality than TFA, in that sense. But FA has some mediocre flavors, and TFA has some brilliant flavors, and there are _many_ cases where they both have very good flavors in a profile that complement each other such that you really want both.

So I kind of do think that some brands are of higher average quality than others, but I also think you are right that it' all about the individual flavors.
 

go_player

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 2, 2012
501
1,287
USA
I responded to you indirectly through my response to @IDJoel above, so I won't hit those points again, much...

To clear some things up you guys where wondering. My hardware is as one said the standard kanthal coils for the Nautilius 2. At 1.7 ohms if im not correct. I vape at around 20-23 watts with those coils. I have not adjusted the airflow that much so I’ll give that a try.

Which coil is this again? I might be wrong but I didn't think there was a 1.7 for the Nautilus mini family. I'm guessing you are using the 0.7, but.. well, it makes a difference though I doubt it is your problem.

To the main subject. So I should invest in some sort of sweetener for my fruity recipes as many of you suggested.

It's hard to say why you don't like the juice you're mixing. Using a couple of good bright fruits with some sweetener is one thing you can try (though saying "a couple of good bright fruits" is a bit vague.) It might be that that's what your palate is looking for. It might not be though. And if not, you'll have to try something else, until you find what works for you (and what works for you might change significantly over time.)

The thing is, 99% of commercial juice makers are using exactly the same ingredients that are available to you (a very small number might be using some secret ingredients of their own, but that's not the norm.) So if you keep experimenting until you find what works for you, you will find things that you like _at least_ as much as commercial juice, and probably a lot better, since you'll be able to tailor recipes for your tastes.

It might take a fair bit of experimenting and research, and some initial expense. I didn't like the first things I mixed very much myself (partially due to some unpleasant nic, but also because I started with some highly rated recipes that didn't suit my tastes or equipment.) And that was very discouraging.

But I kept going, and honestly some of the juice I mix for myself now just _blows all commercial juice I've tried out of the water_, at least for my tastes and palate. And it would cost _very_ little if I were better at restraining my greed for new flavors... even so it costs a lot less than buying premium juice (let alone cigarettes) would, over time.

I can't magically give you the answer here. If I could mix a few small batches of things for you to try I could probably narrow your problem down pretty quickly, because how to do that sort of narrowing is part of what you learn over time when you mix for yourself. But, since the Internet is not yet capable of transmitting actual juice, you're going to have to do the narrowing yourself. The good news is that you'll learn how to do that by doing it. The bad news is that it's going to involve some trial and error, and possibly more failure than success at first.

But I want to go back a couple of paragraphs and re-iterate what I said there. You have access to all the tools you need to make juice that is better, for you, than any commercial juice. This is why people are telling you not to give up. A lot of us had a bad time when we started mixing. We all pushed through it, and I think we're all happy that we did. So we know that you can too, and that you'll be happy you did so. We've been there. Our palates and equipment might differ, but I'm going to guess that we had a lot of the same ups and downs. And that you will have similar ones.

At any rate, I'd be happy to suggest some trials that might help narrow things down for you, and I'm sure others will be as well- shipping costs of flavors are a pain in this regard, but maybe we can figure out a couple of batched orders that will be most efficient in this regard.

I should stop trying to speed up the steeping process and just let nature do it’s thing. One thing is tho, how often should I shake my bottles when they are steeping? And how much sweetener is a good reference point? As I’ve never used that before.

At least while you're trying to track down why you don't like the juice you mix, I'd stay away from all methods of speeding up steeping aside from a good shake. They are extra variables you don't want to have to account for. Once you are mixing juice you like you can experiment with them if you want. I generally disapprove of them, but many swear by their magnetic stirrers, hot water baths, and ultrasonic cleaners.

Shaking is like saving for retirement- its yields compound over time, so ideally you'd do it all at once, at the very beginning. But you might not have the resources to do that, at that time (in this case your arm might fall off.) So go ahead and shake regularly. But it's the initial shake that kicks the steeping process off, so make it a good one.

How much sweetener to use depends on your tastes and the sweetener (for instance CAP super sweet seems to have at least 4 times as much Sucralose as TFA sweetener,) so you'll just have to play with it till you get it right. As @zoiDman points out Sucralose does not seem to need a steep, so play with that to your heart's content. FLV Sweetness, OTOH, seems to develop over long periods- it's a Stevia-based sweetener, but they claim to have formulated it so that it has less aftertaste than Stevia normally would in a vape. I'm not sure if Stevia in general needs to steep. I don't use it.

I don't usually add things specifically labelled as sweeteners to my juice (aside from mixing other people's recipes, 'cause I tend to follow them religiously, the first time.) But I do use flavors that _should_ be labelled as sweeteners, because they mainly consist of some combination of ethyl maltol, methyl maltol, vanillin, or ethyl vanillin, in varying ratios. Examples include TFA Marshmallow, FA Marshmallow, and my favorite, FA Meringue. FA is not as transparent as TFA about their components, but if I had to guess I'd guess that FA Meringue is mainly a maltol and a vanillin. I prefer the mild sweetness of vanillin, maltol, and VG to Sucralose, but YMMV. So many flavors already include some maltol/vanillin that I often find mixes sweet enough without adding more, but again, YMMV.

And to reply to some others, no I dont smoke anymore. I can take one from time to time but that is very seldom as I dont like cigarettes anymore My sense of smell I would say is about as avarage as it can get. So no special snowflake here.

I didn't mean to offend by asking, but... smoking just kills your sense of smell. And commercial juice is formulated to appeal to dual-users, so it's _strongly_ flavored, and highly sweetened. This can lead to a situation where you haven't smoked recently, but the commercial juice you've been vaping has killed your sense of smell almost as effectively as smoking would.

So thank you all for your tips! Really appreciated. One last thing I would like to ask before you go heywild again with awesome replys, what is you favourite flavour brand? And your favourite flavor of that brand? Need suggestions for my collection

I'd be really interested to hear what you thought of just FA Fuji at 2 and 4 and 6 percent, the same with 1% FA Meringue, and then the same with 0.25-1% Cap Super Sweet (all after about 3 days, cause Fuji has a bit of an alcohol taste that steeps out.) If I were trying to figure out your palate that's where I'd start. There are a lot of similar experiments you could try with bakeries, creams, custards, etc., but they would take longer because of steep times.
 

DaveP

PV Master & Musician
ECF Veteran
May 22, 2010
16,733
42,646
Central GA
Anyone starting out in DIY would probably be better off to start in the middle of the flavor manufacturer's recommend mix percentage and go from there. As someone mentioned, wattage and temperature also affect flavor.

Single flavor recipes are easier to get right at first. Once you know the percentage you like for one flavor, write it down, experiment by adding additional flavors in small percentages (in small batches). and develop a list of flavors and their respective percentages for future reference.

2 or 3 ingredient recipes are usually mixed with a main flavor at a higher percentage than the 2nd or 3rd ingredients, which are usually enhancers for the main flavor. Think of a big glass of iced Tea with a squirt of Lemon and a spoonful of sugar. Lemon and sugar don't dominate, they enhance the taste of the main ingredient.

We all went through the experimental stage before we discovered what it took to make juice we actually enjoyed.

And above all, SHAKE YOUR FLAVOR BOTTLES before mixing! They might not look like they settled and separated, but they frequently do.
 
Last edited:

Foggyroomz

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 14, 2014
561
403
Indiana
Hello everyone out there that actually knows how to make DIY E juice. I need some serious help from you guys!

Long story short, I am a fan of DIY and e juice is not an exception. I have been mixing my own stuff since May/June. But even now to this day I couldn't be more dissapointed in my results. They have all been bland, tasteless and just plain horrible.

To clear things up this is my current setup I'm using:
Aspire Nautilus 2
ELeaf iStick TC60W Mod

And I am mixing with these liquids:
Capella Falvourings
NicBase PG-32 Diluted Nicotine
NicBase VG
GreenLabel PG

Now to some recipes I have been trying recently without any pleasing results:
Nicotine juice 32 mg (100% PG) : 1.88ml
PG dilutant : 1.25ml
VG dilutant : 6.00ml
Double Watermelon (CAP) 0.50ml
Dragon Fruit (CAP) : 0.37ml

Total : 10ml 6mg Nic

Nicotine juice 32 mg (100% PG) : 1.88ml
PG dilutant : 1.25ml
VG dilutant : 6.00ml
Vanilla Custard v2 (Cap) 0.40ml
Yellow Peach (Cap) : 0.70ml

Total : 10ml 6mg Nic

These are just two examples of some versions I've tested, from 70/30 VG/PG ratio to 50/50 VG/PG Ratio. I've tested from 5-15% flavouring and dosens of steeping methods. Some are just plain waiting, warm water bath and breathing. Some combinded and some not.

Now what I am wondering from you guys who can do this properly, what am I doing wrong? Am I using bad flavourings? Bad combinations or is Capella just not too good? Is my setup not good enough? Are there any special processes that need to be done to succeed? Larger badges of juice when you mix?

As you can see I am completely lost and my hope is starting to fade when it comes to DIY. If I don't get this to work soon imma start going back to buying jucie :(

Thanks for any help you can give! It's really appreciated :)
I use a forced steep method in which I boil water poor it into a cup at a level that is 3/4 the height of the juice bottle and with the covery off let it heat up (about 10 min) then I cap it shake it really good and then let it cool to room temp and then repeat the process 2 more times in immediate succession of each cycle, this puts roughly a 2.5 to 3 week steep on your juice and helps the different weight chemicals to blend thoroughly. I find my flavors are crisper and more consistent from start of the bottle to finish. I use capella flavors, The Flavor Apprentice, Flavor West, and Flavour Art, you have to decide which flavors you want to be dominant and which ones you want to have be subliminal accents to the dominant flavor and plan your ratios accordingly. You also need to learn what flavors are more potent as they can easily mask a weaker flavor. Mango for instance is a very potent flavor as is citrus flavors so you want to back them down when mixing with a weaker flavor so that you aren't overpowering them. The other thing you want to do is use your flavoring to count for your PG content in the recipe and only add PG if you want to cut your VG ratio to a certain percentage in your recipe without increasing the flavor profile. As a rule of thumb I make sure that all my flavors combined make up 20%of my recipe and then if I need to thin the recipe to a 30/70 add PG to make the difference.
 

englishmick

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 25, 2014
6,564
35,706
Naptown, Indiana
I had a lot of trouble getting recipes that worked for me. But I started with single flavor mixes. A couple I remember are TFA Banana Nut Bread and Crème De Menthe. I use them both in recipes now but they are OK on their own.

At least that way you have something decent to vape while you experiment with mixing.
 

go_player

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 2, 2012
501
1,287
USA
Anyone starting out in DIY would probably be better off to start in the middle of the flavor manufacturer's recommend mix percentage and go from there.

I wish this were true, but I'm going to have to very strongly disagree with you on this subject. Manufacturer recommendations tend to be off, sometimes by an order of magnitude.

Look at how people actually use the flavor. For instance, for FA Fuji: (FA) Fuji . Or the equivalent on ELR.
 

DaveP

PV Master & Musician
ECF Veteran
May 22, 2010
16,733
42,646
Central GA
I wish this were true, but I'm going to have to very strongly disagree with you on this subject. Manufacturer recommendations tend to be off, sometimes by an order of magnitude.

Look at how people actually use the flavor. For instance, for FA Fuji: (FA) Fuji . Or the equivalent on ELR.

Most of the time the flavor manufacturer's recommendation is a good starting point.

Even the seller's website recommendations and the percentages in the user reviews below the actual flavor are all over the place.

If you look at all that info you'll likely end up liking a different mix percentage. Trial and error is probably the right way to figure out the mix you like. Having a starting point helps to shorten the trial with a new juice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread