E Juice not a tobacco product????

Status
Not open for further replies.

Coastal Cowboy

This aggression will not stand, man!
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 13, 2013
5,975
21,941
63
Alabama Gulf Coast
www.ibleedcrimsonred.com
It's possible you are onto something there.

dr g started this line of thinking. I'm just continuing the thinking out loud process.

But who is going to sue the FDA and make these arguments? It seems the people with the money to do it - big e-cigarette and tobacco companies - are happy with the status quo as a tobacco product. If the FDA issues unreasonable regulations by which those big companies' earnings are negatively impacted, I believe they are far more likely to argue for reasonable regulations as tobacco products (or try to get approved as MRTP) than fight for a whole new, unknown category. (And I still think nicotine is nicotine for regulations, regardless of the source or chemical makeup. But I could be wrong.)

What makes you say that the nicotine in e-cigarettes is something different? From my understanding, the nicotine in e-cigarettes is the same USP grade nicotine the pharmaceutical companies use for their NRT products. At least, that is what many e-cigarette companies claim.

According to the free access portions of the USP that I've looked at, the nicotine used by the pharmaceutical companies is the pure crystalline salt of nicotine. Here's a link to a data sheet on the tartrated nicotine that's used in NRP therapies.

Nicotine Bitartrate Dihydrate | Pharmaceutical Ingredients & Products - Nicobrand

This is different from the free based nicotine that we use, which must be in a liquid suspension. Here's a data sheet on that from the same source.

http://www.nicobrand.com/files/Nicotine_Free_Base_Data_Sheet.pdf

I barely passed Chemistry 201, but if I recall, the free based version of any substance is different from the alkaloid itself.

Kurt, our resident chemist emeritus, would probably be able to tell us whether we're really onto something, or totally full of Sierra.

Edit to add: Even if this path doesn't lead to where we want it to, perhaps it can throw enough noise and uncertainty at FDA that they certainly punt again next month. I still think they will, but giving them a proper shove won't hurt.
 
Last edited:

damthisisfun

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 6, 2012
1,155
551
Katy, TX
Our health insurance company decided to charge a higher premium to Tobacco users - cigs, dip etc. It specifically states "Patches, gum and E Cgis that do not contain TOBACCO and are used to help quit SMOKING are not considered tobacco products. HMMMMMMMM- so are they not kinda saying Nicotine is not a TOBACCO product? Also on a different by important point - they are saying e cigs are similar to the patch/gum- and do assist in quitting smoking - WOW - thgt that could not be said - based on the lawsuit by Njoy or someone a few years back.....BTW - this aint no mom n pop insurance company - one of the big 3.....what yall make of this....
 

Uncle Willie

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 27, 2011
2,395
102,513
Meet Me in St Louie Louie
Our health insurance company decided to charge a higher premium to Tobacco users - cigs, dip etc. It specifically states "Patches, gum and E Cgis that do not contain TOBACCO and are used to help quit SMOKING are not considered tobacco products. HMMMMMMMM- so are they not kinda saying Nicotine is not a TOBACCO product? Also on a different by important point - they are saying e cigs are similar to the patch/gum- and do assist in quitting smoking - WOW - thgt that could not be said - based on the lawsuit by Njoy or someone a few years back.....BTW - this aint no mom n pop insurance company - one of the big 3.....what yall make of this....

Odd since the PV is not to be considered a smoking cessation device .. link to policy .. ??
 

DancingHeretik

Dancing in the Chaos
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 20, 2011
8,837
62,105
San Antonio, TX
Our health insurance company decided to charge a higher premium to Tobacco users - cigs, dip etc. It specifically states "Patches, gum and E Cgis that do not contain TOBACCO and are used to help quit SMOKING are not considered tobacco products. HMMMMMMMM- so are they not kinda saying Nicotine is not a TOBACCO product? Also on a different by important point - they are saying e cigs are similar to the patch/gum- and do assist in quitting smoking - WOW - thgt that could not be said - based on the lawsuit by Njoy or someone a few years back.....BTW - this aint no mom n pop insurance company - one of the big 3.....what yall make of this....

It can't be called a smoking cessation method as a selling point. But, that doesn't mean that an insurance company can't say it.
 

stevegmu

Moved On
ECF Veteran
May 10, 2013
11,630
12,348
6992 kilometers from home...
Really good question. Every year we have to re-do our group insurance at work. Every year until now I put myself in the tobacco user slot. The next insurance update coming up, I am planning on putting myself in non tobacco user. I feel I'm not being dishonest.

Same here. I will check the non-tobacco user box for next year. I don't use tobacco. I do use nicotine extracted from tobacco, but the policy doesn't state whether or not I use tobacco products, just tobacco.
 

DancingHeretik

Dancing in the Chaos
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 20, 2011
8,837
62,105
San Antonio, TX
Are you "vaping" or "smoking"...if vaping, then you HAVE ceased to "smoke"!

Exactly!

Using vaping as a reduced risk alternative (if you use it exclusively instead of smoking) IS smoking cessation.

It's just that it's not all about the nicotine. It's so much more than just the nicotine!
 

Uncle Willie

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 27, 2011
2,395
102,513
Meet Me in St Louie Louie
Unc Willie - don't think it would be appropriate to send a link- don't wanna start anything. Bib Ben - maybe I don't understand ur post - I am using it as a substitute - but the Ins company is treating it like a cessation device......i am fine with it as long as they don't increase my premium....lol

Many insurance co's have sample policies on line .. it's generally public information ..
 

damthisisfun

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 6, 2012
1,155
551
Katy, TX
Many insurance co's have sample policies on line .. it's generally public information ..

Well mine is a little different - we are self insured but managed by United HC - also we have minor union and a retirement division - the policy abt smoking etc are made in conjunction with the big wigs/HR/United/retirement folks and Union......so not sure if this is United HCs position on E cigs. The email we got was from HR......I didnt give all this info in my earlier post - thgt it would confuse things -now it is all posted
 

zoiDman

My -0^10 = Nothing at All*
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 16, 2010
41,618
1
84,742
So-Cal
Click my sig, pop over and take a look :D

I'm not allowed to discuss our product or business interests in the general forum, per the supplier's rules as I have been reminded on numerous occasions..... :D

Are you concerned that People selling e-Liquids May/Will have to conform to Fed and State and County requirements to sell a Tobacco Product?

Or that Liquid Flavored e-Liquid Sale may be Drastically Restricted?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread