Electronic cigarettes under fire for targeting Arizona kids

Status
Not open for further replies.

VictoryNotVengence

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 27, 2009
1,242
232
USA
are these guys so hard up for commission on a sale that they are actually reaching out to the teens to have them buy the smokeanywhere ciggs? I bet these are the same guys that in a few months push the handcream/nailcare stands. They are so pushy they will walk away from there stand to get you to come over and hear their pitch, get physical and everything. I could just imagine how they are acting with this ecigg, activly bringing product to the people even if they are underage. Cause they need that commision so bad...the flying carpet must need a repair (sorry :()
 

Walrus

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 3, 2009
2,244
15
Baton Rouge, LA
He said the e-cigarette helps people kick the real habit.

“It is the same as the patch or the gum. Actually, we add the vapor to it. The smoker gets the sensation, you feel you smoke; you trick the mind,” said Hakak.


Not only did the salesman make health claims saying the E-cigarette helps with influenza and pneumonia, but he sold it to our underage shopper.

Lovely. Just lovely.
 

Angela

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 20, 2009
1,219
26
58
Hertfordshire, England
There is one sentence that leapt out at me in that article:-

"Today, Salmon leads the Electronic Cigarette Association with very specific rules: they don't make health claims, don't sell to minors, and say they shouldn't be sold at kiosks in the mall. And just like real cigarettes, they should not sell flavors targeting children."

When did this turnaround happen? Is it a misquote? Or has the ECA changed it's views and are now backing the "flavours are for children" argument? :confused:
 

Vocalek

CASAA Activist
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Left this comment:
Hmm. If a 16-year old managed to purchase tobacco cigarettes without being asked for ID, would you say that the store was "targeting" kids? The title is misleading. It would be more accurate in that case (and in this case) to say that the 16-year old took advantage of the salesperson's lack of concientiousness.

Did the 16-year old represent himself as a tobacco smoker who wanted to quit? Because tobacco smokers are the true target market for this product. I smoked for 45 years and tried everything to quit. On March 27, 2009 I began using an electronic cigarette and have comepletely stopped smoking tobacco. Many people erroneously believe that nicotine is the harmful ingredient in tobacco smoke. It isn't.

I am getting sufficient amounts of nicotine from my electronic cigarette so that I have no desire to smoke tobacco. A couple of weeks after I switched, I tried to smoke a tobacco cigarette and couldn't do it. They taste awful to me now.

About my health? Well, my wheezing has disappeared. I can laugh now without going into a coughing jag. I was diagnosed with prehypertension before. Now my blood pressure is 117/79 and I am not on medication.

Why don't you try doing a story on how well this product works for Mommy, Daddy, Grandma, and Grandpa who would like to live a little longer and breathe easier? Two surveys of electronic cigarette users have found that 79 - 80% of regular users are able to completely stop smoking tobacco. Compare that with the 10% success rate of the FDA-approved smoking cessation product.

A product that works 800% better than the recommended treatments? Now that's a news story.
 

TheIllustratedMan

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 12, 2009
442
12
Upstate, NY
There is one sentence that leapt out at me in that article:-

"Today, Salmon leads the Electronic Cigarette Association with very specific rules: they don't make health claims, don't sell to minors, and say they shouldn't be sold at kiosks in the mall. And just like real cigarettes, they should not sell flavors targeting children."

When did this turnaround happen? Is it a misquote? Or has the ECA changed it's views and are now backing the "flavours are for children" argument? :confused:

I believe that this has become Mr. Salmon's viewpoint. He said in the Vaper's Place chat that he thinks that it would be a good move to stop producing non-tobacco flavored e-liquid. I do not believe that that is official ECA policy.
If you notice, the way that's worded (albeit poorly) it makes a distinction between policy and opinion. "...don't make health claims, don't sell to minors," is separated from "...shouldn't be sold at kiosks in the mall. And just like real cigarettes, they should not sell flavors targeting children." "Should" appears in the last two statements, making them ideals, not absolutes.

...right. Carry on.
 

Turco Chips

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 29, 2009
495
16
Rowlett, TX (DFW area)
Because of these idiots in the malls, the days of us being able to buy various flavors seems like they may be numbered. We might all by DIY-ers when it comes to our juices....better to learn now, huh?

I don't get it, wine coolers some in all types of fruity flavors...then ya got the Mike's Hard Lemonade and it's sickly sweetness, and all that is perfectly fine. When are these nanny state %&#@ers going to get the hell out of our lives????


TC
 

Afubar

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 1, 2009
207
0
Oregon
I left this comment:

Let's tell the real story here. A dishonest company and a disreputable salesperson. This company uses very poor quality products and very poor sales practices to sell, period. This same approach could be the same to sell any number of products from hair care to ShamWow! Just like the TV hucksters that sell and sell, that's all this company is doing.

As for electronic cigarettes, well the FDA is backed up by Big Tobacco companies and Big Pharmaceutical companies to keep them off the market. When you have a product, like a really good e-cigarette and it helps to get people off of tobacco cigarettes, well, just think about the loss of federal and states tax revenue and the money the Pharmaceutical companies won't make and guess who will win. And the News companies like yourselves are helping them.

I smoked cigarettes for 43 years, have tried quitting a number of times, cold turkey and with medications that made me feel worse, not better. Then with the first use (yes, I said first use) of an e-cigarette I've managed to not use a tobacco cigarette in over 90 days. Wonderful, just wonderful. My blood pressure is lower, my lungs are clearer.

So do your homework, check out sites like: http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/ for the real story.
 

Angela

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Mar 20, 2009
1,219
26
58
Hertfordshire, England
I believe that this has become Mr. Salmon's viewpoint. He said in the Vaper's Place chat that he thinks that it would be a good move to stop producing non-tobacco flavored e-liquid. I do not believe that that is official ECA policy.
If you notice, the way that's worded (albeit poorly) it makes a distinction between policy and opinion. "...don't make health claims, don't sell to minors," is separated from "...shouldn't be sold at kiosks in the mall. And just like real cigarettes, they should not sell flavors targeting children." "Should" appears in the last two statements, making them ideals, not absolutes.

...right. Carry on.
Well, given the fact that Matt Salmon is the spokesperson for the ECA and was speaking as such in this interview, it would appear to be policy now..... whether the rest of the ECA like it or not! :cool: ....but thanks for trying to clarify.
 

Darmeen

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 3, 2009
297
2
TX USA
Here is the comment I just left

Soda's are sold to minors, and they have addictive chemicals (caffeine) in them as well. The FDA's report is severely limited and based only on an incredibly small sample. If you had done your due diligence you would have found that most e-cig users DO NOT use the Smoking Everywhere product.

I could sell a beverage product that promises good looks and enables you to make lots of money, in addition to being a tasty beverage...and even though it won't give you good looks or have lots of money, it is still a good product...Don't blame the manufacturer for something the salesperson said. Those kiosks are franchise situations, and as any franchise should not be a reflection on the parent company. Just because you get a bad piece of chicken from one KFC doesn't mean that all chicken at all KFC's are bad...

If you really want to get a better perspective, visit this website: http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/

Articles like this only help those in power with their scare tactics of the evil e-cigarette, and how bad it is...even though cigarettes have been fully approved by the FDA and they contains thousands of chemicals, over 60 of which have been proven to cause cancer.
What you and the government fail to realize, is that if the e-cigarette is removed from the market, you will force tens of thousands of people back onto tobacco products, because this product was the ONLY thing that allowed them to get off of tobacco products. The quit or die mentality needs to go away, because there is another way, a way that has no second-hand smoke, no ill effects to anyone other than the user, if there are any ill effects at all.

I know that I have been cigarette free for a month tomorrow, and this is the only thing that has helped me kick the habit…I am breathing better, have more energy and in general have a sense of better wellbeing…I didn’t buy into the whole e-cig product as a way to quit nicotine, but as a better alternative to nasty cigarettes.
 

Mac

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 5, 2009
2,477
15,159
All up in your grill..
There is one sentence that leapt out at me in that article:-

"Today, Salmon leads the Electronic Cigarette Association with very specific rules: they don't make health claims, don't sell to minors, and say they shouldn't be sold at kiosks in the mall. And just like real cigarettes, they should not sell flavors targeting children."

When did this turnaround happen? Is it a misquote? Or has the ECA changed it's views and are now backing the "flavours are for children" argument? :confused:
You know what. Screw the ECA. I hope they go under. I should start releasing PR articles saying how Matt Salmon should lose his job. they want me out of work. But when I called to ask them abotu their organization they were sure ready to take my money. Screw them.
 

ECGuy

Unregistered Supplier
Oct 14, 2009
61
0
New Mexico
There is one sentence that leapt out at me in that article:-

"Today, Salmon leads the Electronic Cigarette Association with very specific rules: they don't make health claims, don't sell to minors, and say they shouldn't be sold at kiosks in the mall. And just like real cigarettes, they should not sell flavors targeting children."

When did this turnaround happen? Is it a misquote? Or has the ECA changed it's views and are now backing the "flavours are for children" argument? :confused:

Yes, sadly Salmon has jumped into the "flavors are for kids" camp. Politically it's a good ploy. Its up to us to cut the legs out from under this argument. Write your representatives and tell them this is the most insane argument ever. Just because it tastes good does not mean it's for kids.

Otherwise, you won't see any politicians arguing against this. It's just too dangerous for them,I mean really,think about it,someone says "flavors target children" who wants to be the politician to come out in favor of targeting children?? Unless we stand up and say "i'm not voting for anyone who supports such an asinine and illogical argument", It's only going to get worse.

If we allow this to continue, pretty soon the temperance committees of the world are going to use it to ban everything. They already point to any advertising with "flashy colors" as being for kids and stupid people are going along with it.

"won't someone save the children??" Yes, I hope so, but let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater, adults like colors and flavor too.
 

ECGuy

Unregistered Supplier
Oct 14, 2009
61
0
New Mexico
Now wait a minute, John Wickwire?? Is this guy an activist or is the news station just lazy and decided to copy a story from Kansas and misquote him. Check this out:

John Wickwire says his 17-year-old son came home from the mall and talked all about electronic cigarettes. John says his son was with a group of teens who were all under age 18 except for one.

"He came home all excited, and I was like, freaked, and I think he was surprised by how I reacted.

"He's excited and saying, 'Oh, yeah, there's this new thing. It's so cool. They have these flavors,' and I'm like, 'What is it?'

"And then he said, 'Oh, it's this new kind of cigarette'.

"And I'm like, 'No, I don't want you doing cigarettes'," Wickwire said.

Wickwire thinks there's a better place for this product than the mall.

"It's nicotine. It's addictive. It should be in a drugstore," Wickwire said.

From a story I covered in Nov where KSHB in Kansas City did the story. Undercover Report: Selling Electronic Cigarettes to Children at the Mall | Electronic Cigarette Blog - Nov 17 09

And the quotes are almost identical in this story? They make it sound like Mr. Wickwire is a local who is concerned for his child??

That's the question John Wickwire asked when his 17-year-old son came home from the mall.

“He come (home) excited and saying, 'Oh yeah, there's this new thing. It's so cool. They have these flavors,' and I'm like, 'what is it?' Oh, it's this new kind of cigarette,” said Widkwire.

Wickwire thinks there's a better place for this product than the mall.

“It's nicotine. It's addictive. It should be in a drugstore,” said Wickwire.

I hate to sound all tin foil hat, but something isn't right here. This is a concerted effort to get bad press and the whole "selling to kids" angle is genius. And Smoking Everywhere keeps falling into their trap, as expected.

This story is just too damned identical to the Kansas City one to be coincidence. If i was a betting man, i'll bet this Wickwire is a paid hack.

When are we going to get motivated and organized like this? When is one of our "organizations" finally going to get organized enough to actually get us moving?? I keep having great hope for the ones out there, but so far all they've done is create a few pretty pictures, host a couple concerts and create a video or two.

ASH and the others are kicking our ... and are pros at this. It's time to get busy ladies and gentlemen. Or all we are going to see is more lobbying professionals in the press putting ecigs down and getting them banned to "save the children".

PS: Write the reporter and tell him what you think of his crack reporting, or rather potential plagerism of another stations story.
Reported by: Joe Ducey
Email: jducey@abc15.com
Produced by: Maria Tomasch
 
Last edited:

kristin

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Aug 16, 2009
10,448
21,120
CASAA - Wisconsin
casaa.org
If it weren't for peach, mint chocolate and french vanilla coffee, I probably wouldn't still be vaping. I really dislike the tobacco flavors.

Well, if they do ban non-tobacco flavors, smart e-cig retailers could still sell completely "unflavored" liquid and we could add our own Lorann's flavorings. Whole businesses could be built around selling pre-mixed flavorings to add to e-liquid, like those flavorings made to add to tobacco cigarettes. I have no problem adding a few drops of pre-mixed mint chocolate drops to my unflavored e-liquid, if it means keeping e-cigs available.

Maybe Matt is smart enough to know that and still look PC - and it IS important to be PC right now. We need to get legislators on our side. Not having pre-flavored, non-tobacco e-liquid flavors could help achieve that, because it takes away the "protect the children" argument of the nannies.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread