Harvard Eliquid Study Today

Status
Not open for further replies.

officer196

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 26, 2014
160
206
Ft. Worth, TX
Wasn't referring to you specifically, but going back a page, i see your first post in response to him. Sarcastic, suspicious, accusatory even. Perhaps start the discussion with him in a different tone. Ask more detailed questions before questioning his motivation.

I don't know him personally and have no idea how true his story is and what his motivation is. I have empathy for his condition if indeed true ( and i have no reason as of yet to think he may be lying ), whatever the cause, and will like to hear more details with an open mind.

While that's true, and empathy should always be observed, too many of his answers either use qualifiers, are contradictory and intentially avoid direct responses and redirect which is usually a symptom of something else entirely....I'm out.
 

curiousJan

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 20, 2009
887
696
Central IL
Sure Mazinny, I applaud your open mind. Seriously I do. But read all the posts and see how the story changes and what his agenda has been from the beginning. I am sorry but I believe in accountability for every individual.He even admits he has not been diagnosed with this certain problem yet but, "it's looking that way" Sorry perhaps you are just a better person that I.

And I, because I have a quite similar perspective. I'm sorry that this poster is dealing with health issues. I'm also quite suspicious of the civil action $$ that are apparent in the comments that have been made.
 

sparkky1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 8, 2014
3,429
2,686
Nashville
vaping is still not well researched. Most people in the medical field know very little. And not many pulmonologists are actually familiar with flavoring related lung disease, surprisingly enough.

Maybe seek out the profound Dr. Cecile Rose, I suppose she was the only specialist to know about it in 2003 ? and now 13 years later maybe fewer know about it ?
 

Bubsmash

Full Member
Nov 22, 2015
64
31
48
Myself I hate all these studies because myself I know some governments and big name tobacco companies are pouring tons of money into getting these kind of blind eye research things to be done. Why do I say this? Well most of our governments have taxation on the selling and distribution of tobacco products. They are losing millions of dollars in due to many of us switching to vaping in general. Really you all should be asking yourselves well why are our governments and legislatures wanting vaping to fall under the tobacco laws.
*Scratches head* Lets see here so they can tax the crap out of us within the vaping community. I also seen a video of a guy that was doing some research himself on youtube on basically with what He could do. After He stated that it said in this form that He was reading out that they some how cooked E Liquid at 400 degrees C and they found that all these toxins that were oh so bad for us I literally was in tears laughing so hard. Like does anyone know what 400 degrees C is in Fahrenheit? That is 752 degrees Fahrenheit.
Like honestly does anyone here know what that would do to your insides if you COULD vape that? Most all of these studies I read about hear about are all so stupid. Oh by the way Lead will melt at 400 Degrees C so you figure it out. The only good scientific thing I have seen so far that I really like is this:
 

sparkky1

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 8, 2014
3,429
2,686
Nashville
You know, I heard Harvard released this study about vaping.. Oh, am I interrupting?

Sorry.

definite op hijack rant going on or .............. law suite in progress ?
Out of all the studies the good student / faculty at Harvard could perform why do you suppose they would choose a non conclusive / fact based ejuice study ?
 

Falconeer

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 27, 2015
2,704
8,316
75
Dunoon, West of Scotland.
Given how educational institutions are financed and sponsored these days, this Old Cynic cannot help but wonder where the finance for this is coming from...and we do know Big Tobacco ( who have a lot of holding companies/brands, not necessarily tobacco related, in their stable) and Big Pharma have a lot to gain by killing Vaping.

The "Popcorn Lung" tale went down big style in Spain last year - three years ago we had a vape shop on every corner - now you have to hunt to find one.
 

YoursTruli

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 27, 2012
4,406
14,895
Ohio
Given how educational institutions are financed and sponsored these days, this Old Cynic cannot help but wonder where the finance for this is coming from...and we do know Big Tobacco ( who have a lot of holding companies/brands, not necessarily tobacco related, in their stable) and Big Pharma have a lot to gain by killing Vaping.

The "Popcorn Lung" tale went down big style in Spain last year - three years ago we had a vape shop on every corner - now you have to hunt to find one.

this study was funded by the National Institutes of Health (as disclosed on the first page of the study...This research was supported by NIH/NIEHS Center Grant P30ES000002)
who is in partnership with the FDA (so really funded by the FDA)
and this Advanced Publication was published by Environmental Health Perspectives (a peer-reviewed journal of research and news published with support from the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, National Institutes of Health)
 

YoursTruli

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 27, 2012
4,406
14,895
Ohio
  • Like
Reactions: beckdg

Racehorse

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 12, 2012
11,230
28,254
USA midwest
You have better have lived a pristine life and be genetically sound before you will ever win. You had better not have ever smoked or even been by second hand smoke

Not at all true.

Asbestiosis victims, some were smokers, didn't matter. All that needed to be shown was "exposure" to asbestos.

Just sayin'

which brings me to:



Those numbers are completely unrelated and useless.

Understood. But we put men on the moon.

Where are the numbers that AREN'T completely unrelated and useless? (Or is the point NOT TO HAVE ANY?)



Are you saying that since 2009, with the billions this industry is generating in $$, that numbers for DAP inhalation by vapers can't be ascertained?

Where are the studies showing exactly how DAP inhalation DOES affect vapers, in 2015, with the hardware and ejuice available today? Dr. F. said reduced FEV-1 on testing, that is a measurable reading......that does imply some lung function damage. I want to know more.


Because this is like that ping pong game before graphic user interfaces on PCs......back and forth, back and forth, back and forth.

It just seems to me, in light of the concern the vaping industry has for it's livelihood ---that this isn't being put front and center. (wait, NJOY is sponsoring world wide poker games, Cutwood is sponsoring race cars)

but there is no $$ for studies and testing.

Meanwhile:

Surveys aren't studies.
Vapers' opinions on forums aren't studies.
Laypersons trying to interpret data from the food industry and applying it to vaping aren't studies.
Studies with 10 people in them......aren't real studies either. :)
Public relations for the vaping campaigns or public relations for the anti smoking campaigns or advertising copy on websites aren't studies.

Let's get the show on the road.

how about it
 
Last edited:

Bubsmash

Full Member
Nov 22, 2015
64
31
48
I actually am so against with what the FDA says as well as what they do anyways. Yes a very small tiny portion of what they have done has been right on cue but allot of the crap they pump out now is just that crap. I remember the FDA coming into one of our malls and closing down a candy making shop where they were making fresh fudge candy corn candy apples diabetic chocolates stuff like that.
The FDA findings of closing that small local candy making shop was that the vapours used in some of the candy making processes COULD potentially be dangerous to the general publics well being. They did not have to have any proof at all and just because they said that the shop had to close down.
They would not show any proof to the public of there findings and me as a kid I loved watching them make real caramel and fudge in there big copper colored wock.
Why did I bring this up well VG can be used in some candy making processes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Falconeer

WharfRat1976

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 31, 2014
4,732
5,985
Austin, Texas
So much empathy on this thread !
Correct. It is mostly dominated by BS sniffers.
ccd33f870cb3c597794b2f40fe25a58e.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: ReigntheGamer

Steamix

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 21, 2013
1,586
3,212
Vapistan
Originally, flavours weren't made to be inhaled.
There is incidential inhaltation of course. How else would be able to tell ?
Tongue can only differentiate a very few basic flavours. Rest is done by the receptors in the nasal passage.
And it gets there by inhalation. Simple.
Everyone knows that food tastes bland when one's nose is clogged up by a cold.
Difference is that vapers often use flavours in dosages way higher than food processors.

So, whenever I fire up my mod, I am my very own lab rat to some extent.

But I don't buy into this black-or-white ANTZ thingie at all.
Vaping is definitely LESS harmful than smoking.
Vaping is definetely MORE harmful than not vaping.
But there are no absolutes. Check the latest air pollution media coverage from Beijing. Just breathing is very unhealthy business over there.
And breathing is an essential activity - trust my word on that ;)

People die in car accidents by the thousands every year. Did cars get banned?
Nope.
But safety features got added to reduce - not eliminate - the risks of driving one. Seat belts, ABS, airbags, etc. etc.

So vaping ... is like smoking buckled up.

Does protect you in most - but not all cases. Sorry it didn't keep you from harm personally.

Yet nobody walks around and wants seat belts removed from all cars because they work 'only' 99% of the time...
 

beckdg

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 1, 2013
11,018
35,706
TN
I do believe running back and forth to a truck is cardiovascular. Loading a truck with 300 boxes coming from the basement is all cardio...
I do believe I've done that job... and seen hundreds do that job.

I've seen 2 people total (including myself 20+ yrs ago) who could make that job a cardio workout.

Stamina and strength? Yes.

Cardio? Highly doubtful.

FYI; this is my truck...

2e43b56e23bee9bfd01aafa270acc336.jpg


Tapatyped
 

beckdg

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 1, 2013
11,018
35,706
TN
Yet nobody walks around and wants seat belts removed from all cars because they work 'only' 99% of the time...

Remove the unrealistic statistic and I'll take that bet all day long.

Seat belts only help contain the body in majority of deadly accidents.

Better confined to the vehicle to avoid witness stresses than strewn across the highway.

Tapatyped
 

skoony

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 31, 2013
5,692
9,953
70
saint paul,mn,usa
It is extremely difficult to diagnose. As are many lung illnesses, until they are very advanced. It is not uncommon for it to take many years to diagnose certain conditions. People usually get stuck in the "adult onset asthma" diagnosis. The only true way to diagnose bo is open lung biopsy. Not sure if you are familiar with that process but I will not be participating. I am really not that bad. Otherwise, there's just certain trends that need to be watched in PFTs and HRCTs. DLCO testing, and lung volume testing. It's really a puzzle with no definitive solution.
Even if not done much any more open lung biopsy doesn't seem to bad.
How the Test is Performed
An open lung biopsy is done in the hospital using general anesthesia, which means you are asleep and pain-free. A tube will be placed through your mouth down your throat to help you breathe.

The surgery is done in the following way:

  • After cleaning the skin, the surgeon makes a small cut in the left or right side of your chest.
  • The ribs are gently separated.
  • Tissue is taken from the lung and sent to a laboratory for examination.
  • After surgery, the wound is closed with stitches.
  • Your surgeon may leave a small plastic tube in your chest to prevent air and fluid from building up.
Open lung biopsy: MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia

Originally, flavours weren't made to be inhaled.
I am wondering why we have been smelling them all our lives. Then there's Aroma Theropy.
:2c:
Regards
Mike
 

Rangertrix

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 5, 2013
3,873
15,454
Collinsville, OK
My local news agencies have picked up on this story and have been playing it non-stop.
They even coupled it with an interview of a guy who had his mod blow up in his face and caused him to have stitches on his forehead.
When they showed his device, it was a self contained ( picture a giant ego such as the Aspire) with a Derringer. Even after the device vented you could see his coil still there. Obvious that he was sub-ohm'ing, but no one bothered to ask if he was using appropriate resistance's, etc. for his device's limitations. It's this kind of "blanket" reporting for shock value that is having a detrimental affect on vaping.
Uneducated vapers and shops looking to cash in and being irresponsible certainly aren't helping either.

Edit: I am by no means blaming sub-ohm vaping. I'm blaming those that do it irresponsibly. Don't blame an industry because you didn't do your due diligence and were reckless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread