I'm not a KR808 user and actually still have my 51 trio with a 510 kit on the way. I have done some chastising before on the avalanche of EGO/ Riva recommendations having nothing to do with the quality or suitability of the unit. I've never vaped one so I cannot comment on that.
I did hold one in my hand and I can tell you if that was my only option I would still be using analogs. I may still end up with one as I now see the utility but for me an many others smoking is more that just the inhalation experience and at least initially I needed my pv to feel close to a cigarette in my hand. Even when I do get an Ego (likely echo as I do prefer the auto still) I will continue to use and enjoy the 510 mini's and possibly the KR808's if I give them a try and like them better just because I like the feel of the scissor grip in my fingers while smoking / vaping.
But that is just me. The main reason I critiqued the get an Ego / Riva or anything else including those who swear by the KR808's and 510 that I like is they ofter don't even read the OP's post or care about their wants. It's not that I think there are paid shill hawking something it's that people seem to want to proselytize their preference regardless of what the OP is asking for. /RANT
Having said that I am not calling out all EGO/ Riva, insert brand x here users I am only trying to urge people to read and pay attention before making recommendations. And if anyone catches me doing it I hope I will be called out as well.
Edit: I was not trying to put you in this category personally Sweedishfish even though I quoted you. In fact I would say the opposite would be true of you but the yelled at part of the comment was what I was addressing.
The problem in your "theory" are several fold. First, you are assuming that a person who has never vaped really understands the differences and limitations of different PV's and how they will never be just like an analog. Of course they are going to say they want one the looks like what they have been using for years. If look/feel was the only important requirement, you could recommend buying a "fake" cigarettes that are the exact size and shape of a cigarette so you can have that "feel in the hand" and appearance experience. You might as well recommend one of these.
Second, people who recommend the tiny battery models, never tell the poor new person that these devices are not close to the "inhaled feel" of a cigarette and never will be.
Third, if you told a new person that they could have the "in the hand look" of a cigarette or the "inhaled feel" of a cigarette but not both and ask them to choose, I feel confident the vast majority would opt for the "inhaled feel" of the real thing.
Fourth, people who recommend the tiny battery models also never tell the new person that at best, under average to heavy vaping, they will only get maybe an hour of use out of those tiny batteries.
And last, you never take into account, when advising a new person, what the statistical evidence shows for those who tried both type of PV's, what the vast majority end up using - a better battery model. It makes more sense to not just blindly "listen" to what a new person with no experience think they want, but instead look at the experience of the vast majority and try to save the new person both frustration and money. They can always "downgrade" although we know that very few ever do that.