That was then. This is now...
Having spent some time with a juice I hadn't yet tried, and more time with one I had only begun to vape, my answers have changed.
1. HUNTSMAN - I finally found it. My AD/EDV This is so good I almost broke out into a dance. Nice, earthy, slightly nutty. Yummmmm
2. Sludge - I very nearly made this my #1, and on certain days, it might be #1. This is my "grown up" vape. Bold, rich, flavorful. Just awesome stuff.
3. Dragon's Fire - this fell a few notches. Partly because the other 2 knocked my socks off. Partly because the bloom is off the rose. It's not as rich as I remember anymore.
4. Legend - may climb higher when I get around to trying out "Original Gandy." But Cherrydalf just isn't so mind blowing lately. Still great. But not top 3.
5a. Pirate's Booty - maybe lower than deserved. But I haven't vaped it in a long time.
5b. Serendipity - after a month steep, I couldn't figure out what this reminded me of. then it hit me: Johnson Creek's Domestic. Odd that I like this better straight away than steeped.
I still have HA steeping, so this is all prone to change again.

But one juice you can be sure will never appear here is Oompa. Blech! It's not deserving of Heather's name.