So, I've been thinking about this quite a bit.
Home Slice is growing on me quite a bit, it's still only been two days, and I've no idea where it will end up after a steep. I am scared it will lose some of the peanut flavor, the same as PBC. When I first vaped HS, I immediately knew that it was maybe the most realistic flavor I had ever tasted, but maybe not something I would necessarily vape frequently. Like I said though, it's growing on me.
With PBC for me, if there was a way to keep the flavor from that golden period (3rd week though 2 months) it would be my hands down winner. I've never had a vape experience like that. Impossible to put into words. The PBC still tastes good and I vape it everyday, but there definitely was a golden period. Interesting note: My near zero PBC still tastes pretty darn fresh. I wonder if it is actually the nicotine that degrades it and if it would be possible to mix up a big batch with no nicotine and then add nicotine right before shipping orders.
I just took another vape off of HS, and it really is amazing. All three flavors are present and distinct, and all three are such high quality. The bread taste is the real shocker, the "how in the $!%^ did he do that flavor. I think HS would be a good candidate for the top 10, if not only for the reason that you mentioned that you can't find anything like it anywhere else. Right now for me though, it's not something I couldn't live without, not something that I vape so hard that it's coming out of the pores on my skin. Only vaping it for 2 days is a little early for me to make a comment like this, I usually wait a few weeks. I could easily see my opinion changing.
I do notice that it is more set-up dependent than some other juices. Out of my Reo at 1.2 I get mainly peanuts, but with my Taifun GT at 1.2 and 4 volts, I am getting the 3 different flavors balanced perfectly.
HS is definitely a flavor that I will use to showcase Nicoticket to friends, I think I got you another order today from a guy named Dale, although he only ordered RBF and GCD.