I really like Johnson Creek's juices. Their
tobacco flavors don't let me down, the quality of the
juice, the great customer service, and fast shipping makes me happy. I have tried others, and so far they haven't lived up to the hype for me. I am not saying that there may be better juices out there, but I haven't found them yet (at least for tobacco flavors). Fancy names, limited quantities or being out of stock on something for weeks, or having to order when they decide to be 'OPEN' may make them seem special or unique, but to me it's a PITA. If you are in to gummy bears, candies, cola, or really really sweet stuff then I am sure that there are other sites that will be better suited for you; but for me I am looking for an analog replacement that will satisfy my cravings and Johnson Creek fits my needs.
I have no problem firing them in the four different devices that I have (re: burnt atties) and with my VV/VW I can fine tune each one individually to bring out the taste (nuances) of each
juice just fine in my ProTanks (re: no flavor). Also, I think some people may be judging them by some of their earlier juices which have since been improved upon. For example: Rainer>Black Cherry, Tundra>Arctic Menthol, Domestic or Tennessee Cured>JC Original or Silverthorn. Hopefully they are working on an improved version of their Espresso.
In regards to personal favorites: Tennessee Cured, Domestic, and Tundra are my go-to favorites, but I like mixing up the others as well. I'll do Rainer with Swiss Dark, Vanda with Swiss Dark, Tundra with Domestic and Swiss Dark, and even Tennessee Cured with Domestic. It's kind of fun playing with the flavors and ratios.
As far as trying to re-create Blu's Flavors, I got close (at least for my tastes):
Magnificent Menthol - Four parts Tundra, One part Domestic (or try Three parts Tundra, One part Domestic, One part Swiss Dark)
Cherry Crush - Four parts Rainer, One part Domestic (or try Three parts Rainer, One part Domestic, One part Swiss Dark)
Like everybody says, 'Taste is subjective.'