Mech Mod advantages?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ladiekali

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 1, 2013
5,631
9,207
Florida
I nelieve that the battery at full charge is at 4.2 volts then it drops down to 3.7 then it drops again, this last drop is when you dont want to be sub ohming, and that is why you monitor your battery's output to learn when it drops. Also the more you charge a battery the quicker or sooner it will drop.

This is my current understanding so i could be wrong
 

Alexander Mundy

Ribbon Twister
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 1, 2013
4,408
26,100
Springfield, MO
Ok, here you go

Great!!! I am so glad you are going 'back to basics' with this, because these are the parts I don't understand, in red.



So would you say that Volts is actually the equivalent of Volume? That is, the amount of power stored in a given physical space? Or put another way, the VOLUME of POWER contained in that battery? So a 9 volt battery holds nearly 3x the volume of power as a 3.7 volt battery?

The Power is Watts = Amperage times Voltage P = ( I X E )
The energy stored is Watt-Hours.
10 Watt-Hours can be 10 Watts for 1 hour or 1 Watt for 10 hours etc.


If that's the case, what is happening when I set my PV to 4.8 volts on a 3.7 volt battery? This part is where I get lost.... it makes no sense. If an 18650 battery is 3.7 volts, I can't take more than 3.7 volts from it if that's the POTENTIAL power it contains. Can you please explain this??


Magic of electronics.

I wrote this some time ago and it is a little more involved than what you are looking for:

Basic tutorial on current with DC-DC buck and boost converters

I will not go into the internal circuit design itself here as it requires advanced knowledge of power electronics and a little black magic as many have found out during implementaion of a design in the real world. I will however attempt to explain the basics necessary to understand the relationships between input voltage and amperage and output voltage and amperage which is hidden behind a lot of equations that look like alien writings. Bear in mind this is simplified and there are many things I am leaving out about the actual internal workings. Also I will assume the external circuit is properly designed for the application.

To understand these relationships we need to briefly look at how the converters work.

A DC-DC buck converter, also called a down converter, will always have the output voltage lower than the input voltage.

(A linear regulator is a form of down converter but is less efficient as it has to waste all the power in conversion since it does not store energy)

A DC-DC boost converter, also called an up converter, is very similar to a buck except the output voltage will always be higher than the input.

There are various other converters (buck-boost, flyback, SEPIC, Cuk, and variations) that will provide both lower and higher output voltages than the input voltage but are normally found in complete end user devices.

The following will apply to all modern DC-DC converters.

A DC-DC converter briefly stores energy from the input in either a magnetic field or a capacitor. In most all converters it is in a magnetic field so we will look at them. A magnetic field is built up in what is called an inductor that is a coil or that block looking thing with a coil inside it that is normally the largest component in a converter. Once that energy is stored in the magnetic field there is no longer voltage or current, just the magnetic field strength. It then releases that energy to the output. During this release the design of the converter and possibly external components determines what average voltage is present at the output.

What about current? Since voltage and current "disappear" inside the inductor when they create the magnetic field, input current has no direct bearing on output current.

To determine the output current is simple. Divide the output voltage by the load resistance. I.E. if the output voltage is 4 volts and the output resistance is 2 ohms then the output current is 2 amps. (4V/2O=2A)

To determine the input current however you must know the input or output wattage, converter efficiency at the working parameters, and the input voltage. Since we will normally know the output wattage we take output voltage times output current. Using the above example 4V X 2A = 8W of output wattage. Converters do not have the same efficiency through their range so normally you will have to look at charts provided by the manufacturer in the data sheet to determine the efficiency at the input and output we want to figure it for. For simplicity we will say that in this case the converter is working at 90% efficiency. So if we are getting 8W out of it there must be 8.9W going into it. 8W / 90% = 8.9W (rounded up to the 1/10th watt). To figure the current input we take the input wattage divided by the input voltage. Lets say we have 8.2V input (2 cells at 4.1V each). 8.9W / 8.2V = 1.1A (again rounded up)

So you can see that while we are getting 2A out of the converter we are only drawing 1.1A from the batteries. However the input current will rise as the batteries discharge. Lets say our batteries have fallen from 8.2V total to 6.4V total. Thanks to the converter we still have 8 watts of output which means we still have 8.9 watts of input (assuming efficiency has not changed). But for the converter to get that 8.9 watts from the batteries it has to draw more current since we are giving it a lower voltage. 8.9W / 6.4V =1.4A. In both cases our batteries are seeing a lower amperage than the output is providing.

Now lets look at a boost converter. The math is the same. Lets say we still have 8W output at 4V and our input voltage is now 3.2V (1 cell) and our efficiency is the same at 90%. So the input wattage will still be 8.9W but the input current will not be the same. 8.9W / 3.2V = 2.8A. Now our battery is seeing more amperage than the output is providing.

As a general rule of thumb a buck converter will always draw less amperage from the batteries than the output is providing and a boost converter will always draw more amperage than the output is providing. A converter that will do both more and less voltage out than in will as a rule of thumb do the same as a buck if it is giving less voltage out than in and the same as a boost if it is giving more voltage out than in.

You should always look at the lowest battery voltage the converter will see when determining what the maximum amperage the draw will be on the batteries.

Most all modern DC-DC converters will have a thermal shut down mode. Internal components will determine if the converter is getting too hot and will shut the converter down. Converters need to shed heat. This heat build up is determined by load, duty cycle (how long they are on compared to off), and how much they can shed this heat. If driven hard and a long it is important to not keep air from being able to convey this heat away or thermal shut down may occur.

Most all modern DC-DC converters also incorporate what is normally called the "hiccup" mode. This is incorporated into most all modern DC-DC converters. When a set point is reached (determined by the manufacturer) where the electronics inside the converter are not able to provide the current out that you are trying to draw from it, the converter will go into hiccup mode. The converter will output the most it can for a very brief time then output nothing for a longer period of time (a short duty cycle) then start over again. You can see where the name hiccup came from. This is to prevent damage to the internal components. The point this happens is normally refereed to as the "inception point". The inception point will always be higher than manufacturers rated amperage for the converter. If not the converter could never reach the rated amperage without cycling into and out of hiccup mode. Normally a manufacturer will set that point at 110% to 140% of rated amperage. This is determined by the manufacturer and will be below what destructive testing has shown will damage the internal components. The inception point will normally be included in the manufactures data sheet.

Most manufacturers will also include a warning that a fuse should be used to protect the converter and power supply. This is because hiccup mode will only protect the conveter for a short period of time against a dead short. In some cases 1 second or less. If the converter fails in a short mode instead of open mode the batteries will be directly connected to the load since the majority of converters are "non isolated" and the ground for the input is also the ground for the output.


Ok, this is pretty straightforward, and this is what is measured by Watts right? How much is flowing at a time, VOLUME of electricity flowing, or the SPEED of the electrical flow? These are 2 different things... which is it?

Speed is measured by the electromagnetic wave and not the movement of electrons and is dependent on the speed of light times the dielectric constant of the medium the wave is moving through and is not at all pertinent to what we are discussing and would take a long time to explain.

How much is flowing is Amperage.

How much is flowing (Amperage) times the pressure (Voltage) is Wattage.


Ok, this makes sense... it's the amount of RESTRICTION you are placing on the flow. Ie, a 1mm opening, 5 mm opening, etc, affects the SPEED you are releasing the electricity from the supply, or the voltage pool.

Not speed but how much is flowing (Amperage)

I have never seen the term 'conductance' used in vaping. Where is it used, and what is it relevant to, when we use primarily resistance for gauging coil size/length? Is this applied to the battery itself? Perhaps the meaning of the C designation (below)?

I've never seen it used in vaping either, but was just mentioning it is the reciprocal of resistance and is equivalent to opening up the faucet.

Ok, I got this, with above caveats and request for further information.



Ok, this is also straightforward.



Ok... I will study this, as it's the meat of the matter. I really appreciate your explaining it yet again (because this probably comes up constantly in newbie discussions). Could you help answer some of my questions above tho? Thank you very much:)!!

Wow, don't use the green.
I had to change to blue because it was almost unreadable.
 

Alexander Mundy

Ribbon Twister
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 1, 2013
4,408
26,100
Springfield, MO
The other way around, you don't want to be vaping because of the vape, not because of any problem with the battery.
(As long as you don't go below the rated lowest voltage for the battery, which you won't because by then you will be puffing basically air)
Most change at around 3.7V because that is when the voltage is low enough to be very noticeable in the vape compared to 4.2V.
The voltage will drop in a curve and is dependant on the battery and the amperage being drawn.
This is a constant draw curve and will give you an Idea what I am talking about, but only use these to compare batteries as we don't constantly draw from the battery.

AW%20IMR%2018650%201600mAh%20%28Red%29-CapacityTime.png


They ask to reference the page when using their charts so here it is:

Test of AW IMR 18650 1600mAh (Red)

The total amount of time you have used the battery under load has more to do with it's lifespan than the number of times charged.
Most will recommend frequent charging and not draining the battery battery to its lowest allowed voltages to prolong life.

I nelieve that the battery at full charge is at 4.2 volts then it drops down to 3.7 then it drops again, this last drop is when you dont want to be sub ohming, and that is why you monitor your battery's output to learn when it drops. Also the more you charge a battery the quicker or sooner it will drop.

This is my current understanding so i could be wrong
 

Alexander Mundy

Ribbon Twister
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 1, 2013
4,408
26,100
Springfield, MO
LOL! Sok, I'm interested, and am going to try to absorb this... you have NOOOO idea how hard that is for me, because like physics, electricity defies the laws of logic. um. (I didn't like calculus either... for me, 2+2 should always equal 4, not 7).

But I'll get there:).

But to me physics, math, and electricity is completely logical and cannot be any other way.
A "set in stone" set of equations that don't vary.
BTW if someone is telling you 2 + 2 = 7 then ask them what the square root of -1 is.
If the answer isn't immediately " i " then ignore them.

Social interaction and Art (the missing side of my brain) is what defies logic.
 

Alexander Mundy

Ribbon Twister
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 1, 2013
4,408
26,100
Springfield, MO
glassgal- there will be a test on all of the above which you need to pass before getting your dibi...

:)

I bet your like my dad aren't you?

He gave a 50 question true / false pop quiz to his advanced accounting class with all true questions.

No one got 100% :facepalm:
 

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
I'm trying to review what I know about mech mods, and try to fill in the blanks... would appreciate any help:).


Ohms Law - where it would apply to mech mods, it's that your battery basically drops off of the amount of voltage delivered over a period of time, so that your vape is going to diminish in quality and quantity over the life of the battery in it. What else about ohms law applies?


battery safety- don't overcharge, tear it out of the unit as soon as it starts feeling hot and get it away from yourself and your unit (but don't throw it out a closed window because that can get expensive).


proper cleaning and care of contacts - swish all contacts down with 99% alcohol once a week or so, and maybe once a month, use a nice spray electronic cleaner on it if you have any juice leaks. If not, squirt with canned air.


That's the only thing to know about mech mods? Nothing else?


How about the advantages of sub-ohm? If sub-ohm vaping requires a power draw as high as 30 watts... isn't that a super short battery life, requiring more frequent battery purchases and more frequent battery changes/charging? What are the vaping advantages for doing it then, besides the need to spend more money, buy/make more juice, and do more busy work (recoiling, recharging batteries, refilling with juice).


Given the above, would it not be more practical to build over .8 ohm coils at all times? What is the taste difference for sub-ohm coils that people would sacrifice battery life for? Thank you!!

Ohm's Law: V=IR.
The battery does lose voltage as it loses charge, but that has nothing to do with ohm's law; it just means the current will reduce as the voltage reduces; your coil will run cooler and cooler as the battery looses charge; you don't need ohms law to tell you that.

People go sub ohm so that you can get more power from a low voltage.
If you are using a mech mod, you are not stepping up the voltage, hence you need lower resistance coils such as less than 1 ohm.
The electronic supplies such as the itaste provari vamo zmax , raise the voltage, and also detect low resistances, and actually REFUSE to use low resistance coils such as 1 ohm or less; hence if you WANT to do sub ohm, you have to use a mech.
 

glassgal

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 7, 2013
4,126
10,613
Central Florida
www.azenglass.com
You see the golden ratio, I see binary numbers without consecutive 1's 00000, 00001, 00010, 00100, 00101, 01000, 01001, 01010, 10000, etc.

Isn't that interesting how people can see the same thing so very differently? The same meaning in a different and seemingly unlearnable language:).
 

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
I wish i had answers for you lol. I am going to follow this post.

I dont sub ohm so i dont understand why its better other than bigger clouds.
I would love to do a dual coil build but cant get mine higher than .8, doesnt seem to matter my wraps. And quite frankly im afraid to go below 1.3.

I hear conflicting info on a lot of stuff. I was told at the shop to vape till my battery dies, here i read to know and monitor your battery's drop off points.

So yeah, im just gonna be lurking this thread to see where it goes !

I think you have a HEALTHY fear of danger :)
 

BlaseWithVicarious

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 21, 2013
130
39
Conroe texas
I used to vape regulated they were good when I first started but then I brought a just GG and recoiled and everything I have 4+ batteries aw. I use maybe two a day. 18650. Dual super nano coil .3 ohms it's a very nice warm vape. Really fast vapor almost instantly in my first inhale. I went back to regulated and was displeased with It. My personal vape is a mech over my previous regulated vape... So it's all personal. Id choose a .5 coil then a 1.5 coil. It's really hard to explain it untill you've felt it yourself. I was skeptical but after all the work and building and the results. It's got you hooked allready... Just my 2 cents


Sent from my Just GG using Tapatalk
 

glassgal

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 7, 2013
4,126
10,613
Central Florida
www.azenglass.com
Ohm's Law: V=IR.
The battery does lose voltage as it loses charge, but that has nothing to do with ohm's law; it just means the current will reduce as the voltage reduces; your coil will run cooler and cooler as the battery looses charge; you don't need ohms law to tell you that.

People go sub ohm so that you can get more power from a low voltage.
If you are using a mech mod, you are not stepping up the voltage, hence you need lower resistance coils such as less than 1 ohm.
The electronic supplies such as the itaste provari vamo zmax , raise the voltage, and also detect low resistances, and actually REFUSE to use low resistance coils such as 1 ohm or less; hence if you WANT to do sub ohm, you have to use a mech.

Thanks! But... why do you WANT to do sub-ohm? That's the big question... what's the upside, when there are so many downsides? (power drain, safety, faster juice consumption being the biggest ones) ?
 

glassgal

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 7, 2013
4,126
10,613
Central Florida
www.azenglass.com
I used to vape regulated they were good when I first started but then I brought a just GG and recoiled and everything I have 4+ batteries aw. I use maybe two a day. 18650. Dual super nano coil .3 ohms it's a very nice warm vape. Really fast vapor almost instantly in my first inhale. I went back to regulated and was displeased with It. My personal vape is a mech over my previous regulated vape... So it's all personal. Id choose a .5 coil then a 1.5 coil. It's really hard to explain it untill you've felt it yourself. I was skeptical but after all the work and building and the results. It's got you hooked allready... Just my 2 cents


Sent from my Just GG using Tapatalk

So it's the SPEED of the draw that is most appealing about sub-ohm?
 

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
Hi Ladie... that's exactly it. I can find info on ohms law... the whats and how's are easily answered. It's the WHY's that I can't seem to find a straight answer for.

Something that says: At .5 ohms, my juice tastes better because I get a stronger concentration of flavors and larger clouds of them than at .8 ohms or 1.2 ohms. For this, I am willing to recharge my battery 3x more often, replace them 3x more often, and buy 3x more juice. Also, I am willing to risk blowing my face off (Provari goes down to 1.1 ohms, so we are only talking about below 1.1). Please note that these are ASSUMPTIONS, based on what little I've read about ohms law and batteries. It can be completely wrong. If so, can someone correct me?

I don't see that anywhere...

Don't get me wrong, I will buy a mech mod because it is beautiful, novel, and rare ANYWAY. I'm just asking about functional advantages too.

I have a genesis style tank; its an I-atty from ft; it has a mesh wick;; that's steel mesh; the coil wraps on the wick; my multimeter reads about 2 ohms on the coil; when I put the thing on my zmax, it doesnt work to good; when I checked the resistance using the zmax, it seems the zmax was registering widely fluctuating resistances; I suppose theres some degree of shorting going off and on that varies with temperature of the coil too;

basically the electronics doesnt like that kind of build- or maybe my build is just bad. But I can use the tank on my ego type battery; I assume the ego type battery electronics is just more tolerant of the resistance.

As for a mech mod, the mech mod doesn't care what you put on it; give it a full short, it will discharge even if that means explosion, fried face or whatever;
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread