Natural Tobaccos - Part Deux

Status
Not open for further replies.

eazye99

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 26, 2014
105
82
North Carolina, United States
Just got my KGD cotton today, and wow...just wow. I honestly didn't think it would be as significant of a difference as it was, but wow...talk about flavor! Jury's still out on the Magma though. I like some aspects of it - like how much liquid it holds, and how awesome the flavor is. But it requires a bit of fiddling, and I can't seem to drip into it without getting juice into the airholes. That leads to leaking, which I do not care for at all. But that KGD...wow.
I had that problem with my magma when I was using chimney coils. Now that I use horizontal coils. I can just remove the tip and drip. Aim directly between the positive post and negative post. While dripping slowly. Also try putting your fingers over the air holes. While dripping. Keep the fingers there. At the same time take a pull on the drip tip. This should clear any juice from the air holes and stop leaking.
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
R. Oullette must think he is blending tobacco for smoking rather than for vaping. :)

We have to remember that vaping gives us a very different taste from smoking. Plus each style of smoking has it's on taste depending on the pyrolization style of the tobaccos. This is even more complicated when you get to pipes. Different shapes and volumes of pipes will all burn some what differently and taste different. Russ's blend may be an awesome smoke. That doesn't mean it is a great vape.

that is one of the things all home extractors must remember, it is aways a gamble. Hopefully, one day we'll get to the point that some blender like Russ will start studying up and blend tobaccos with us in mind. In the mean time we all cast our lot and pray for the best.

Yes, I'm well aware that smoking and vaping are very different experiences. Some elements of the smoking experience do not translate at all to vaping. Burning characteristics from cool to hot are meaningless to vapers, as are moisture of the blend and how the cut packs in a bowl. On the other hand, the basic flavor character of different kinds of tobacco seems to apply in both worlds. Differences in taste may be more about the delivery system---smoke from burning versus the ultra-fine mist from vaporizing---than the source tobacco. I mean, when we talk about Virginia's bright sweetness, the nuttiness of Burley, smokiness of Latakia, or spice of Perique, those qualities do seem to apply from one medium to the other.

Literally many hundreds of years have been devoted to refining the business and art of tobacco growing, processing, and blending---all of it exclusively for smoking. By contrast, vaping is a newborn wrapped in swaddling clothes. No flavorings of any kind yet exist that were created specifically for vaping. We're porting everything from different platforms (food and smoking), learning what works and what doesn't.

I did read many reviews from pipe smokers about Steamroller. The usual diversity of opinion applied: a few people loved it, a few hated it, but the overall sentiment was not especially positive, and for much the same reasons as my complaints: too many ingredients, not enough harmony, a vanilla flavor casing that obscured the tobacco, and a general bluntness rather than refinement.

Just recently some discussion occurred on the thread about the differences between purely personal reactions to a juice (i.e., liking it or not) and the more general perception of quality. I feel confident that my "review" of Steamroller as an NET extract was more about its unsuitability as a tobacco flavor than merely my own personal reaction of not liking it. Knowing that opinions vary, I'd still bet that most of my compatriots on this thread would share my judgment about Steamroller.
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
I have Freight Train cooking right now, and your post was rather timely Bill. If I may ask, at what percentage of flavoring did you use in your juice mix?

boomer,

I've pretty much settled on a range of 14-20% with my pipe tobacco extracts. The particular sample bottle of Steamroller I mixed used 20% extract. I don't think a lower percentage of extract would improve it, however. The extraction itself is fine---a deep caramel transparency that is well-filtered. I fear it's just not a blend that works well as an NET.
 

MikeNice81

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Feb 24, 2014
3,497
5,468
NC
Yes, I'm well aware that smoking and vaping are very different experiences. Some elements of the smoking experience do not translate at all to vaping. Burning characteristics from cool to hot are meaningless to vapers, as are moisture of the blend and how the cut packs in a bowl. On the other hand, the basic flavor character of different kinds of tobacco seems to apply in both worlds. Differences in taste may be more about the delivery system---smoke from burning versus the ultra-fine mist from vaporizing---than the source tobacco. I mean, when we talk about Virginia's bright sweetness, the nuttiness of Burley, smokiness of Latakia, or spice of Perique, those qualities do seem to apply from one medium to the other.

Literally many hundreds of years have been devoted to refining the business and art of tobacco growing, processing, and blending---all of it exclusively for smoking. By contrast, vaping is a newborn wrapped in swaddling clothes. No flavorings of any kind yet exist that were created specifically for vaping. We're porting everything from different platforms (food and smoking), learning what works and what doesn't.

I did read many reviews from pipe smokers about Steamroller. The usual diversity of opinion applied: a few people loved it, a few hated it, but the overall sentiment was not especially positive, and for much the same reasons as my complaints: too many ingredients, not enough harmony, a vanilla flavor casing that obscured the tobacco, and a general bluntness rather than refinement.

Just recently some discussion occurred on the thread about the differences between purely personal reactions to a juice (i.e., liking it or not) and the more general perception of quality. I feel confident that my "review" of Steamroller as an NET extract was more about its unsuitability as a tobacco flavor than merely my own personal reaction of not liking it. Knowing that opinions vary, I'd still bet that most of my compatriots on this thread would share my judgment about Steamroller.

My post was meant as a general addendum for the community at large. I wasn't questioning your taste buds. From my experience you seem to understand the difference quite well.
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
My post was meant as a general addendum for the community at large. I wasn't questioning your taste buds. From my experience you seem to understand the difference quite well.

Yes, I got that. My response was intended to add more, not challenge what you wrote.

If we were sitting in a bar or restaurant having this discussion, body language, verbal tone, and other nuances would make it clear if any offense were being taken. With just the written word, however, that's sometimes less than obvious.

No harm, no foul. It's all just us shootin' the breeze.
 

y cherry y

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 18, 2012
1,514
6,390
Ypsilanti, MI
Here's the verbatim skinny from the product pages on the Ahlusion web site:

"While our non-aromatic blends are based on natural tobacco extracts (mainly various blends of light and dark Cavendish), the focus is not on the tobacco itself, but a blend or flavors in this recipe. The tobacco used in our non-aromatic blends is fairly neutral compared to our aromatic blends.

Non-aromatic blends can be in anything from cigarettes, to pipes; traditionally non-aromatic blends can consist of any blend of tobaccos, but they usually lack that distinct aroma and flavor; most of the focus is on the pure natural flavors of the tobaccos used and serve as a fairly neutral base for our non-aromatic e-liquids. For our non-aromatic blends we use milder Cavendish blends which are a bit sweeter and balanced with complementary flavors."

The key word there is "mainly," which leaves the door open.

I had a conversation once with Wlad about Smooth Criminal's components that told me either something or nothing about SC, and left me feeling like I had tried to pin down a master chef about a recipe. It was a long time ago, but as I remember went like this:

Me: So, what is in Smooth Criminal?
W: Just tobacco.
Me: JUST tobacco?!
W: Basically.
Me: Basically?
W: Essentially.
Me: Essentially?
W: Yes.

Unlike most of you, I guess, I can vape SC all day for days on end. I don't -- because there are other flavors I also love -- but I could relatively painlessly become an ADV guy with this juice. Essentially.
 

johni

Extractor
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 8, 2012
2,007
5,908
Columbia, Missouri
There is a common spice flavor in Smooth Criminal and MOVs Chai Tea Latte. I don't know which spice or combination of spices it is, but it's there. It's also in the Mystic Chai Spiced Tea mix that my wife gets at Sam's Club and that has a list of ingredients on the label including cinnamon, clove, cardamon, anise, ginger, and vanilla extract from Madagascar. Well aged Smooth Criminal is good but can't hold my interest long.
 

rdsok

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 17, 2012
16,213
72,567
Norman, Ok
Anyone have a link to the original Natural Tobacco thread? I did a search for "natural tobacco" and got 3118 threads! Went through a few pages before I decided to just ask. Thought I had it bookmarked/subscribed but I guess I removed it when this one opened. Trying to do some research ....

There is a link to it in the first post of this thread
 

Dusty_D

Original Guru
Senior Moderator
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 22, 2010
16,228
47,678
53
Toronto, Canada
dustysfoodieadventures.blogspot.ca

Dusty_D

Original Guru
Senior Moderator
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 22, 2010
16,228
47,678
53
Toronto, Canada
dustysfoodieadventures.blogspot.ca
There is a common spice flavor in Smooth Criminal and MOVs Chai Tea Latte. I don't know which spice or combination of spices it is, but it's there. It's also in the Mystic Chai Spiced Tea mix that my wife gets at Sam's Club and that has a list of ingredients on the label including cinnamon, clove, cardamon, anise, ginger, and vanilla extract from Madagascar. Well aged Smooth Criminal is good but can't hold my interest long.


Scrap the Anise and Vanilla and you've got the recipe for an Indian Masala (Spiced) Chai.

Can't say that I got that from SC. I'll have to revisit it to confirm.
 

johni

Extractor
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 8, 2012
2,007
5,908
Columbia, Missouri
Scrap the Anise and Vanilla and you've got the recipe for an Indian Masala (Spiced) Chai.

Can't say that I got that from SC. I'll have to revisit it to confirm.
That drink mix tastes like a spiced hot chocolate with the spices replacing the chocolate. Nice winter, before bed drink.

Jerms cursed me previously for mentioning the spice connection I get in SC! If you have MOV's Chai Tea Latte, try em back to back and you'll see what I'm talking about.
 

Dusty_D

Original Guru
Senior Moderator
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 22, 2010
16,228
47,678
53
Toronto, Canada
dustysfoodieadventures.blogspot.ca
That drink mix tastes like a spiced hot chocolate with the spices replacing the chocolate. Nice winter, before bed drink.

Jerms cursed me previously for mentioning the spice connection I get in SC! If you have MOV's Chai Tea Latte, try em back to back and you'll see what I'm talking about.


No Chai Tea Latte. The only juices I've ordered from MOV are their NET's and I made the mistake of ordering their Silver Label Arti's last year, which was a mistake as I did not much care for them. Similar to HHV, I don't really know what else they have on their menu beyond the tobaccos because I've really not looked at any of the other offerings. :blush:
 

Dusty_D

Original Guru
Senior Moderator
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 22, 2010
16,228
47,678
53
Toronto, Canada
dustysfoodieadventures.blogspot.ca
MVJ's Sutliff Blue Danube. Another lightly flavoured juice, even after 2 months of steep time. I can't say that I dislike the lighter flavour because it does let me use it in the KFL's, but there are times when I wish it was a bit bumped up.

Blue Danube could use some bumping up in flavour. It presents itself as a mild, nutty, slightly sweet tobacco. The Burley and Virginias come through clearly but I had to turn up the heat to get them to represent themselves. I'm not getting much else out of it from a casings perspective.

Simple and clean burning.
 

MikeNice81

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Feb 24, 2014
3,497
5,468
NC
After some research and a lot of tasting I think I have uncovered which Sangria I am vaping. :lol:

Sutliff says theirs is a burley/cavendish with citrus and vintage wine. I don't really get any citrus from the vape. However, Milan says theirs has Virginia in with the b/c blend and hints of spice and cherry. I definitely get a hint of virginia body and sweetness. I also get the hint of spice from time to time. So, I'm casting my vote for MFT's Sangria being the Milan version. It only took about 30ml to get 75% certain. :laugh:
 

johni

Extractor
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 8, 2012
2,007
5,908
Columbia, Missouri
No Chai Tea Latte. The only juices I've ordered from MOV are their NET's and I made the mistake of ordering their Silver Label Arti's last year, which was a mistake as I did not much care for them. Similar to HHV, I don't really know what else they have on their menu beyond the tobaccos because I've really not looked at any of the other offerings. :blush:
I hear ya! I can count all the non-tobacco juices I've ordered on one hand. I'm sure some of the good NET vendors have some good non-tobacco offerings but you couldn't prove it by me!
 

Dusty_D

Original Guru
Senior Moderator
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 22, 2010
16,228
47,678
53
Toronto, Canada
dustysfoodieadventures.blogspot.ca
I hear ya! I can count all the non-tobacco juices I've ordered on one hand. I'm sure some of the good NET vendors have some good non-tobacco offerings but you couldn't prove it by me!


How about non-Net tobaccos? There were some vendors at VapeCan (the big meet we had recently in Toronto) that had some "Tobacco" flavoured juices. One of them was giving away free bottles, so I grabbed a Black Honey Tobacco from them, brought it home and loaded it up in a KFL. PHEEEWWWWW!! crazy floral with a seriously sour room note which could have only been the honey.

It took me 2 days of having the windows open and the fan going in my Den before I was able to walk in there and not smell it. This was from 5 minutes of vaping it. :facepalm:

The flavour has permeated the KFL and even the inside of the pipe stem I was using. Nasty.. just plan nasty!
 

MikeNice81

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Feb 24, 2014
3,497
5,468
NC
How about non-Net tobaccos? There were some vendors at VapeCan (the big meet we had recently in Toronto) that had some "Tobacco" flavoured juices. One of them was giving away free bottles, so I grabbed a Black Honey Tobacco from them, brought it home and loaded it up in a KFL. PHEEEWWWWW!! crazy floral with a seriously sour room note which could have only been the honey.

It took me 2 days of having the windows open and the fan going in my Den before I was able to walk in there and not smell it. This was from 5 minutes of vaping it. :facepalm:

The flavour has permeated the KFL and even the inside of the pipe stem I was using. Nasty.. just plan nasty!

That is one of the reasons I switched to nothing but nets. My wife was constantly complaining about the room note from every synthetic I tried. Even Mister-E-Liquid's Copper Head annoyed her. There have only been two nets that she found disagreeable. One was Boomer's Obsidian. She swore it made her clothes smell like a burnt tire. :laugh:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread