I know what you mean. I'm realizing there are several (at least) different categories to "tobacco" flavors. On one end there's stuff like Boba's, which I'm starting to think of as candy store type tobaccos, pretend tobaccos so to speak (not taking away from Boba's, I still like it). Then you have your Gandalfs, which are not pretend tobacco, that have a bolder, more real tobacco flavor, but that tobacco flavor is still competing with a lot of other sweet somethings constantly peeking out at you. And then you have the "natural" (for lack of a better way to put it) tobaccos these guys in this thread are so fond of, which aren't pretending to be anything but tobacco. I'm sure there are some others that fit somewhere in between the three I listed, but that seems like the broad spectrum to me. I haven't tried Huntsman yet, for instance, but from the reviews I've seen I'm guessing it falls somewhere between a Gandalf and a Vita Bella.