not exactly... you don't go around eating or smoking band-aids do you?
anyway, the point of using organic cotton is to have as few chemicals on it as possible (or at least unharmful ones) & not have to boil & dry your cotton, possibly introducing unwanted contaminants in the process.
Apparently that's *exactly* the point of being so specific about it being organic cotton -- I taste *nothing* except, at the very start of a new wick, a very faint cotton taste, and after that wears off, clear, clean taste of the e-juice. That has not been the case for *every other* thing I've tried as a wick -- silica, ekowool, cotton yarn, or cotton from the end of a Q-tip, even after boiling -- there was *never* this clarity of taste from any of those.
Of course you don't eat cotton balls or any other sterile product; the point of sterility is that it won't introduce any micro-organisms, even when in contact with open wounds; you wouldn't eat sterile cotton balls, but you *could* use it to sop up soup or any other liquid and then drink what dripped from it; it wouldn't taste bad, and it wouldn't make you sick. So I think it's pretty safe to vaporize the liquid it sops up and inhale that vapor, provided that the liquid itself is safe to vaporize and inhale -- such as e-liquid!
And I did in fact boil one of these cotton balls, and it did NOT taste as good as straight-from-the-bag, so I think it's entirely likely that *something* was absorbed by the cotton during the drying process, odor for example, or that fungus grew in the cotton due to the moisture, before it was entirely dry.
I still won't buy "organic" vegetables, mostly because they look like crap, and because I truly believe that in most cases, it's 99.99% hype; but in this case, where the *smell* is so much a part of the entire vaping process, it's absolutely NOT hype; organic really does make a difference that you can taste and smell -- you DON'T taste or smell anything except cotton and ejuice.
But of course it's entirely up to the individual, and if you think it's BS, you won't try it, and you'll deprive yourself of an amazing vape experience. Your loss.
Andria