@ canzz
Forget about finding that perfect tobacco flavor that you are use to. It's not going to be there. I've tried about 15 different kinds. The only thing you can possibly do is to get something close To what your use to. And remember that when someone gives you their favorite juice to get, that may not appeal to you, because everybody's taste buds are different. You just have to buy the smallest bottles you can get and try for yourself.
Now that being said VictorC has started this thread with a good review on Flavour Crafters juice. Some of them I had already tried, but one he did not have in his review was Flavour Crafters Navy Cut Tobacco. It has a slight vanilla and nutty taste. (most tobacco juice will have some slight taste like that). Me and the wife love this one and it tasted close to the cigs we were use to. I started Jan 4 2014 with this one being my first try and after about 2 hours I knew that I was done with cigs. (at least I hoped so). Fast forward to today I have not touched a cig since Jan 4 2014. We had 4 other flavors to try that were OK but we liked the Navy Cut Tobacco the best. I'm getting in to DIY right now but if that don't work out for me I will be back to Navy Cut Tobacco. Could give them a try and maybe you can get some free samples also like VictorC did.
And yes VG will have a sweet taste to it so I would say to stick with 70/30 PG/VG for now unless you are allergic to PG. I started with 70/30 18mg and that is where I have stayed so far. 18mg is like a mild cig. 24mg is like smoking Export A with no filter. I tried Flavour Crafters Export Tobacco in 24mg and found it to harsh and strong for me, but you may like it.
Hope this helps you a bit and stay of the stinkies.
I should just add that if I could not get Flavour Crafters Navy Cut Tobacco any more for some reason I would switch over to Vapen Juice
Play Hers--- 18mg or Vapen Juice 555--- 18mg. Both can be bought a lot cheaper at Canvape.com
Thank you for your informative answer Bobx. I agree with you, all of the tobacco flavors i have tried before were sweet. Im not looking for a perfect flavor anymore. I just want a decent flavor which has a strong throat hit that doesnt cause scratchiness on my throat. Until now BOBAS BOUNTY 100VG 12mg and BEETLE JOOSE 50PG/50VG 12mg havent worked. I will go to a store in downtown now to see what i can find. Im going to order some Flavor Crafters tonight. Im not giving up yet, I really want to quit smoking