in fact I believe that topic surely it has been done already deserves a new
thread. Cartotanks vs. clearomizers.
I agree with Rivernut. Try a carto first. If you like cartos, you'll probably like a carto tank. All
tanks do is keep the carto wet. They don't add anything to the quality of the carto vape. Their function is strictly convenience, so you don't have to top off a carto. They're an attempt to fix the biggest drawback of cartos, the need to top off.
They'll also work with clearomizers and correct the wicking problems that some clearomizers have. A lot of people use clearomizers in a carto tank. With the Vivi Nova working so well, there's no need to do that unless you need the larger capacity that some carto tanks can give you.
So try a Vivi Nova with the 1.8ohm head. I'm pretty sure you'll like it more than a carto. Personally, I'll never bother using a carto, in or out of a tank, again.
The carto tanks vs Clearomizers issue is pretty clear cut. Nobody seriously disputes that a properly functioning clearo has a cleaner taste. "Properly functioning" is the key phrase. There's some debate about the intensity of flavor and the throat hit of some clearos. Some clearos also have leaking and wicking issues. What complicates things is that there's a lot more difference between one clearomizer and another than there is between one carto and another.
So the topic wouldn't be about carto tanks at all. It would be about Clearos vs Cartos. And it's been debated to death.
If you find a clearo with good taste and decent throat hit and that doesn't leak or give dry hits, all the other advantages so heavily outweigh a cartomizer that many people are willing to sacrifice some small amount of TH or even flavor.
The problem is that, out of dozens of clearos, there are only a handful that don't leak or give dry hits.
IMO, the Vivi Nova and the Fluxomizers do that. I've heard the Phoenix clearos do also. Too many don't. When clearos are finally really perfected, cartomizers will go the way of the old cartridges and they'll be sticking them in every box like they do with pre-filled cartridges.