The Really Big RY4 Roundup (long)

Status
Not open for further replies.

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
On June 12th, during one of KillerJuice’s weekly Blitz Sales (15ml bottles of eliquid for 99¢, with a maximum order of five bottles from that week’s selection, usually 3-5 juices from KillerJuice’s larger retail line-up), I ordered four bottles of KillerJuice RY4---one each at 6mg, 12mg, 18mg, and 24mg per ml nicotine strength. I mean, c’mon, 60ml of a good custom RY4 that uses natural ingredients for only $7.46 shipped? Despite having enough RY4s in my stash to choke the proverbial horse---more than 160 retail RY4s comprising almost three liters in all, plus another full liter of DIY RY4s from all-in-one premixes or made from scratch---I figured that seven bucks more wouldn’t make much of a difference one way or the other.

In part, I wanted to see to what extent, if any, different liquid nic concentrations might affect the taste of KJ’s retail RY4. Sure, I could do this myself with homemade DIY juices, but there was a certain “objectivity” about doing it with a retail juice.

I felt also that this was an ideal opportunity for me to see where I am regarding nicotine in my own personal vaping journey. When I began vaping in October 2010, my liquids were all 24mg nic. I needed a strong throat hit to make the transition from cigarettes to vaping. About two years ago, I went down to 18mg, and I’ve hovered between 15mg and 18mg ever since. Throat hit is not nearly as important to me as it was initially, so perhaps I could lower my nic intake even further with no loss of satisfaction.

Today I got out the 6ml and 24ml bottles of KillerJuice RY4 that have been steeping for a couple weeks and atty-dripped some of each. The results, while far from “scientific” were noteworthy.

First, my perception was that taste/flavor of the two liquids was essentially identical. No difference that I could discern. I expected the 6mg version to taste a little flat, since that has been my experience with zero nic juices, but it didn't. I wouldn't call it "bright" or "sparkling," but it tasted fine to my palate, and the 24mg version didn't taste any more flavorful.

The difference was in the impact. The 6mg RY4 had a softness accompanied by a mild but surprisingly effective throat hit. I didn't anticipate that the 6mg version would have any perceptible throat hit, since I'm accustomed to vaping at 18mg, but there it was. By contrast, the 24mg RY4 was razor sharp and kicked like a mule, with a massive throat hit. I was a little shocked to discover that the TH was way too much for me. I actively didn’t like it, as it seemed to almost overwhelm the flavor of the juice. That reaction was immediate and sustained. I actually preferred the 6mg version, and not just a little. The 6mg KillerJuice RY4 won by a mile for me, judged on the basis of enjoyment and satisfaction.

I make no bones about being a nicotine junkie. Heck, I’ve been addicted to nicotine for 45 years. Nic is my drug of choice for self-medication to keep my brain and nervous system sufficiently stimulated. Apparently, however, vaping is gradually weaning me off nicotine. Go figure. I think this test---informal and subjective though it is---implies that it’s time for me to reduce nic strength from 18mg to 12mg in the juices I make or buy. 6mg might be adequate, but I think 12mg will be more comfortable for awhile.

As a footnote, I'll re-confirm my opinion that KillerJuice makes a pleasing Custom RY4. No, it’s not spectacular and won’t ever break into the “A” graded group, but it’s a good, solid B to B+.
 

Cool_Breeze

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 10, 2011
4,118
4,296
Kentucky
Bill - Thanks for your evaluation. It seems Killer Juice RY4 has some throat hit independent of nicotine strength. I noted that 18 mg/ml that I received seemed to have more TH than I am accustomed to in juices with that level of nic. It might be that zero nic KJ RY4 might have a little TH. If so, KJ may be on to something...

Oh yes...KJ RY4 plays well with others.
 

Jerms

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 1, 2011
9,252
25,832
Fargo
On June 12th, during one of KillerJuice’s weekly Blitz Sales (15ml bottles of eliquid for 99¢, with a maximum order of five bottles from that week’s selection, usually 3-5 juices from KillerJuice’s larger retail line-up), I ordered four bottles of KillerJuice RY4---one each at 6mg, 12mg, 18mg, and 24mg per ml nicotine strength. I mean, c’mon, 60ml of a good custom RY4 that uses natural ingredients for only $7.46 shipped? Despite having enough RY4s in my stash to choke the proverbial horse---more than 160 retail RY4s comprising almost three liters in all, plus another full liter of DIY RY4s from all-in-one premixes or made from scratch---I figured that seven bucks more wouldn’t make much of a difference one way or the other.

In part, I wanted to see to what extent, if any, different liquid nic concentrations might affect the taste of KJ’s retail RY4. Sure, I could do this myself with homemade DIY juices, but there was a certain “objectivity” about doing it with a retail juice.

I felt also that this was an ideal opportunity for me to see where I am regarding nicotine in my own personal vaping journey. When I began vaping in October 2010, my liquids were all 24mg nic. I needed a strong throat hit to make the transition from cigarettes to vaping. About two years ago, I went down to 18mg, and I’ve hovered between 15mg and 18mg ever since. Throat hit is not nearly as important to me as it was initially, so perhaps I could lower my nic intake even further with no loss of satisfaction.

Today I got out the 6ml and 24ml bottles of KillerJuice RY4 that have been steeping for a couple weeks and atty-dripped some of each. The results, while far from “scientific” were noteworthy.

First, my perception was that taste/flavor of the two liquids was essentially identical. No difference that I could discern. I expected the 6mg version to taste a little flat, since that has been my experience with zero nic juices, but it didn't. I wouldn't call it "bright" or "sparkling," but it tasted fine to my palate, and the 24mg version didn't taste any more flavorful.

The difference was in the impact. The 6mg RY4 had a softness accompanied by a mild but surprisingly effective throat hit. I didn't anticipate that the 6mg version would have any perceptible throat hit, since I'm accustomed to vaping at 18mg, but there it was. By contrast, the 24mg RY4 was razor sharp and kicked like a mule, with a massive throat hit. I was a little shocked to discover that the TH was way too much for me. I actively didn’t like it, as it seemed to almost overwhelm the flavor of the juice. That reaction was immediate and sustained. I actually preferred the 6mg version, and not just a little. The 6mg KillerJuice RY4 won by a mile for me, judged on the basis of enjoyment and satisfaction.

I make no bones about being a nicotine junkie. Heck, I’ve been addicted to nicotine for 45 years. Nic is my drug of choice for self-medication to keep my brain and nervous system sufficiently stimulated. Apparently, however, vaping is gradually weaning me off nicotine. Go figure. I think this test---informal and subjective though it is---implies that it’s time for me to reduce nic strength from 18mg to 12mg in the juices I make or buy. 6mg might be adequate, but I think 12mg will be more comfortable for awhile.

As a footnote, I'll re-confirm my opinion that KillerJuice makes a pleasing Custom RY4. No, it’s not spectacular and won’t ever break into the “A” graded group, but it’s a good, solid B to B+.

Thanks for posting that info Bill, I was curious how your little experiment would turn out.

Many people have referred to nic as the salt (or spicr) of vape juice, myself included I've called it the salt that tastes like pepper lol. It's a fitting analogy, we seem to adjust what we're used to with nic levels in vape and salt levels in food, and outside our adjusted level tastes off. We can also adjust to new levels with both after getting over the initial hump. And with both, people tend to be happy with where they're at or are trying to lower their levels. I've never heard someone claim they are trying to get more salt in their diet lol.

If I always add a bunch of salt to corn, low salt or no salt corn tastes bland. If I adjust to low salt corn, I'll find I actually like it as much as high salt corn, and my when enough time has passed, my previous high salt recipe will have me say.. too salty!

So is nic as important to the flavor of juice that myself and others claim? Looks like your experience is saying.. maybe a little, but maybe not as much as thought. The impact provided by nic is obvious, not many vapers would be surprised on your results when describing the kick. You noticing no difference in flavor/taste between 6mg and 24mg is a surprise though, and has me questioning what I thought was true.

I've had zero nic before, from free samples, and like you I found it very bland. Maybe the level of nic isn't important to flavor, but having at least some nic is? Maybe there's just a mind connection between throat hit and flavor, so removing the TH breaks that connection, confuses the brain, and results in perceptively less flavor? If that's the case, after adjusting to 0 nic juice it may provide the same flavor as nic juice, just minus the physical kick. Lot's of variables to consider, so I think the theory of nic relating to flavor will remain anecdotal instead of fact for a while.
 

Lombaowski

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 22, 2013
1,156
1,400
DC via the 313
I reordered some Indigo RY4 Classic and added some of the new NET Gung-Ho for good measure today. Then I saw that Mr E Liquid was having a 15% off sale and decided it was time for a 120ml bottle.

Every time I am trying to decide what RY4 I want I always think to myself, "damn, I would take a Mr E tank right now if I had some more but I just don't want to run low." I don't think this way about any other RY4 and even though Tribeca, Indigo, Mr Vape, ECBlend, and now Volt offer what I consider a superior vape, I just feel Mr E is the top dog out there of the ones I've tried.

120ml for $43 shipped; 36 cents a ml for this stuff seems like a fine buy.

So I had my first cigarette yesterday in more than a year. It was more of a curiosity thing than a necessity, but I came away saying that vaping is just so much better. It didn't taste good when I smoked it, and about 90 minutes later I could still taste it. Terrible. I went back to vaping my trademarked frankenjuice ECBlend RY4/HHV Heavenly Tobacco hybrid and it was so much more satisfying. So basically there is no way I'm going back, I'd rather vape RY4 or NETs or some bland fruit flavor than smoke a cigarette. Find your juice, lock in the nicotine level, get some suitable delivery device and you're all set.

:thumb:
 

PRG4

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 26, 2013
122
65
Sarasota, Florida, United States
There's something strangle going on with the forum or this thread or even worse my Ipad. Every time I select a review or a vendors link I'm sent to the last page of this thread. I know crazy huh! Im researching a few new vendors so I wanted to check out their reviews but every time I want to read what was written I have to manually go back page by page to find it. Which by the way, I don't mind because I've always run into something else well worth reading but it's kind of starting to drive me crazy. Has anyone else ever had this problem?
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
There's something strangle going on with the forum or this thread or even worse my Ipad. Every time I select a review or a vendors link I'm sent to the last page of this thread. I know crazy huh! Im researching a few new vendors so I wanted to check out their reviews but every time I want to read what was written I have to manually go back page by page to find it. Which by the way, I don't mind because I've always run into something else well worth reading but it's kind of starting to drive me crazy. Has anyone else ever had this problem?

Nope, sorry. All the links work for me exactly as they should.
 

PRG4

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 26, 2013
122
65
Sarasota, Florida, United States
I'm on my IPad. And it's doing the same thing today. Oh well, I don't mind a little extra reading. Thanks guys. Oh, I do have one question, one that I never would've thought that would need an answer, what do you guys do with the eliquid that you don't like. I've been going crazy buying eliquid like its going out of style which has translated into a shoe box of juice that just isn't for me. I know this forum has a classified thread but it seems as if it's a pain to become a part of. I really don't want to sell what I have but I would like to trade for something else. Any thoughts? Thanks guys.
 

thehangdude

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 17, 2011
11,437
21,721
63
Terre Haute, IN
I'm on my IPad. And it's doing the same thing today. Oh well, I don't mind a little extra reading. Thanks guys. Oh, I do have one question, one that I never would've thought that would need an answer, what do you guys do with the eliquid that you don't like. I've been going crazy buying eliquid like its going out of style which has translated into a shoe box of juice that just isn't for me. I know this forum has a classified thread but it seems as if it's a pain to become a part of. I really don't want to sell what I have but I would like to trade for something else. Any thoughts? Thanks guys.

http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/fo...-please-read-first-post-rules-guidelines.html
This is the PIF thread for swapping ejuices. Read the rules.
 
Picked up two bottles of RY4 today from the mailbox. First, I finally get to try some Halo Tribeca and it's a keeper, as I suspected it would be. Next was kinda a gamble, RY4 from a company called Midas, and the gamble paid off! The Midas is a little caramel forward on the nose in the bottle, but not by much...it's exceptionally balanced, not overly sweet, and just a great, smooth vape. Very light, airy caramel up from on the inhale (not goopy dessert caramel), then giving way to the vanilla and tobacco, with only the slightest hint of sour that doesn't upset how smooth it is overall. Not much in the way of throat hit at 12mg. The flavor is better at lower voltages, 4.5 and below on my 2ohm HH357 (just over 10watts). If you're looking for an RY4 that's balanced, this is worth a try.

I saw a review on youtube that states it is "generic" and nothing stands out. Well, I've tried about 10-12 RY4s and when I think generic, I typically think bad or perfumey. This stuff is neither bad, nor perfumey. Balance is something hard to quantify and get right, imo. So, I think the thing that stands out is the harmony of the juice. It's not overly, "one thing". Just a nice, smooth RY4. I'd put it up there in the B+ range. Similar to a Mom and Pops RY4v1, yet a hair more refined.

The halo smells more tobacco forward in the bottle, and def. reminds me of the Chinese classics. I think mine currently would benefit from steeping.
 
Last edited:

PRG4

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 26, 2013
122
65
Sarasota, Florida, United States
Wow, thank you very much.
I didn't realize how much and how many people vape fruitytuity flavors. Some of the flavors sounded pretty ridiculous, I think I'll stay over here and vape my three favorite flavors tobacco, caramel and vanilla. I'm still waiting for my orders that I made during the 4th of July sales. I ordered the sample pack from Mountain Oak Vapor containing Rambler, Vanilla Dream, and Classic Country. My second order was NLV's new RY4, Caramel Reef, and something else that I currently forgot the name of. Then my last order from ITCvapes is made up of their new RY4 Silver, Caramel Cream, and last but not least their Turkish Blend. To top all that off I finally bought some new blue cobalt glass bottles which I got for dirt CHEAP. Come on mail man/woman I'm at home waiting.
 

Roxxette

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 4, 2012
1,535
656
Caribbean
It's been a loooooong time I don't try a new ry4, halos tribeca became my favorite but I do remember how good highbrow ry4 is the bad part is that for some reason I get tired of that liquid fast like in 2 tanks.

I'm a NET lover :) and was hoping if you guys have any recommendation for net ry4 ?

Thanks and Bill don't know if you remember but old username was Roxxette :p
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
It's been a loooooong time I don't try a new ry4, halos tribeca became my favorite but I do remember how good highbrow ry4 is the bad part is that for some reason I get tired of that liquid fast like in 2 tanks.

I'm a NET lover :) and was hoping if you guys have any recommendation for net ry4 ?

Thanks and Bill don't know if you remember but old username was Roxxette :p


from the Category Groups page of The Big RY4 List:

Natural Extract Tobacco (NET-based RY4s)
GoodEJuice GJ4 (in-house macerated NET)
HighbrowVapor Highbrowbacco RY4 (NET, source unknown)
KillerJuice RY4 (“all natural,” presumably NET, source unknown)
Mom&PopVaporShop RY4 (Tobacco Absolute)
Mom&PopVaporShop RY4v2 (Tobacco Absolute)
Mom&PopVaporShop RYO4 (Tobacco Extract, a derivative of Tobacco Absolute)
Moondrop RY4 (Tobacco Absolute)
MountainOakVapors Full Virginia Flake RY4 (in-house macerated NET)
MyVapeJuice Rogue RY4 (in-house macerated NET)
PrimeVaping PV4 (NET, unknown source)
QuickNicJuice RY4 (Tobacco Absolute, I think)
QuickNicJuice ouR whY Qu4tro (in-house macerated NET)
River Bottom Fog Sauce KillR Y4
SpringVapor Fall Harvest RY4 (Tobacco Absolute)
SpringVapor Black Label RY4 (Tobacco Absolute)
SpringVapor Black Label RY4 - Day and Night (Tobacco Absolute)
VapeRite Organic VR4 (in-house macerated NET)
VapeRite RY4 (in-house macerated NET?)
VaporStation VS4 (Tobacco Absolute/NET blend)
Want2Vape RY4 (in-house macerated NET)

My personal fave is in bold---QuickNic ouR whY Qu4tro. It's a reverse-steeper, and best vaped fresh. After about six months, it loses much of its sparkle and brilliance. Still darn good after that, but not spectacular, as it is when young.
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
Hi bill. Been keeping up with this thread for the past 15 months. Thanks for all the time put in. I remember seeing a review of ahlusion gold rising bit can't seem to find it. I know its not ranked on the big list but I thought I remembered you liking it. I'm expecting some soon and haven't heard much about it. Thanks again.

My initial response to Ahlusion Gold Rising was, "Wow, this is interesting and unique." That positive reaction didn't hold up over time, however, as the honey flavor in Gold Rising began to bother me. As you may recall, consensus of thread participants at the time was to exclude Gold Rising from The Big RY4 List, because we felt that the overall flavor profile, and particularly the honey element, were not in keeping with the nature of RY4s.

Gold Rising is very much its own juice. I hope you like it.
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
I gotta say.......for consistent quality, taste, TH, vapor production.. and a gr8 price, MR.E's RY-4 Ive tried a couple dozen from shops, websites, and home brews. You cant go wrong I order a 100 ml bottle every couple months.

Well, quality shines through. There's a reason---in fact, several reasons---why Mr.E's RY4 from Mister-E-Liquid is in the A-rated group on The Big RY4 Report Card. Fewer than 1 in 10 of the 160 RY4s reviewed in this thread end up in that A-rated group, so getting the highest grade ain't exactly chopped liver and cream cheese.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread