I got my "blemished" tubes today (but no complete unit) sigh... So I borrowed a Top cap and a button from another simplicity. The only "flaws" I could find were a few bits of metal shavings on the
threads. Came off with a little Noalox and a Q-tip.
I think the satin finish is very nice, very light, compact etc. (what every one else has been saying)
If you didn't go with the whole enchilada, and still wish you had, I checked the website and I think there are 7 of the "blemished " tubes left. Are they worth $50.00? That's up to you...I do know that 30 of us paid $400 for the complete package, and no complaints... yet.
They won't do you much good without another "donor body". but once they're gone, it's just a story.