Yes.
Short version...
vape to quit 2009
Add snus and snuff to the vape, actually stopped smoking 2010
Tried a pipe and stopped vaping for the briar.
Snus added back in
Started inhaling the pipe (really wrong!)
cigarettes and......
Resumed vaping with left over gear August 2013 and it didn't work. Picked up a variety of then current gear, didn't work.
Introduced to WTA... worked.
Big plus of course to really wanting to be rid of inhaling burnt tobacco.
Today, no tobacco in any form, just vaping. It was not easy but it can be done (-:
Sounds a lot like my story... except for the pipe... and the snus... and the snuff...
Well I pretty much went right back to the cigs... old gear didn't cut it then I found the nautilus.... I am tobacco free