What is the difference....
- Thread starter WOW
- Start date
- th_trl_thread_readers 0
- Status
I've just recently gone thru a 5-pack of the Peppermint Ice Cream cartos.... they're quite good. Smooth minty inhale, soft creamy exhale. Great flavor.
I haven't tried the WOW Peppermint yet, but I'm going to go out on a limb and say it's just straight peppermint, without the ice cream flavor.
I'm sure someone else will chime in soon. I know there's a TON of people who love the Wow peppermint around here! I'd like to try it, but they need to restock the lower nic levels before I'll order it.
I haven't tried the WOW Peppermint yet, but I'm going to go out on a limb and say it's just straight peppermint, without the ice cream flavor.
I'm sure someone else will chime in soon. I know there's a TON of people who love the Wow peppermint around here! I'd like to try it, but they need to restock the lower nic levels before I'll order it. 
Peppermint Ice Cream (11mg) does have that smooth, warm, minty inhale and soft creamy exhale.
Wow Peppermint (18mg) is more like the starlight mints.. fresh minty taste but not too strong or over powering at all. Well not to me at least. I was expecting it to knock me on the floor and be over powering but it wasn't.
To me... the Watermelon (which I love too) is a stronger flavor than the Wow Peppermint.
I really like both of them... lol so if you get them and don't like them... just let me know and I am sure we can work something out!
What types of flavors do you normally like?
Wow Peppermint (18mg) is more like the starlight mints.. fresh minty taste but not too strong or over powering at all. Well not to me at least. I was expecting it to knock me on the floor and be over powering but it wasn't.
To me... the Watermelon (which I love too) is a stronger flavor than the Wow Peppermint.
I really like both of them... lol so if you get them and don't like them... just let me know and I am sure we can work something out!
What types of flavors do you normally like?
My thoughts exactly--great way to sum it all up
. However I do pick up a couple boxes of peppermint every so often, peppermint ice cream just wasn't all that great for me, I wouldn't buy it again. However, many swear by peppermint ice cream.It's all very subjective.
Last edited:
i liked them both, but if i would have to choose between the two it would be the wow peppermint. it has more of a robust flavour that i really enjoyed.
Thanks everyone!
Your descriptions really helped! Seems the WoW peppermint is the winner!
@ Rose - I like menthol and minty flavs best, followed by WoWboy and CMF.
Other than strawberry, I haven't taken a liking to the fruit flavs. I like the strawberry a lot but had a lot of probs with the carts getting too hot. (Last order I got the low mg juice, instead of prefilled, and put it in a coolcart - yumm & no burn!) I got a sample of the spiced cider...not for me....free to good home, though(I think it's 24mg). 
...wish the grape was green grape but, maybe one day....otherwise it's neck-to-neck between WoW peppermint- 24mg and SMILIN Special Menthol - high mg - as 1st 'must have' and having gone without the WoWboy for over a week, it's my 2nd fav 'must have' @ 18mg. The other ones I don't crave - just nice to have around for a change of pace.
What flav/flavs do y'all crave if they're out of stock for a while and what mg is everyone vaping on your 'must have' flav? just curious....
Again, thanks for sharing about PIC vs WP!
Your descriptions really helped! Seems the WoW peppermint is the winner!
@ Rose - I like menthol and minty flavs best, followed by WoWboy and CMF.
Other than strawberry, I haven't taken a liking to the fruit flavs. I like the strawberry a lot but had a lot of probs with the carts getting too hot. (Last order I got the low mg juice, instead of prefilled, and put it in a coolcart - yumm & no burn!
) I got a sample of the spiced cider...not for me....free to good home, though(I think it's 24mg). ...wish the grape was green grape but, maybe one day....otherwise it's neck-to-neck between WoW peppermint- 24mg and SMILIN Special Menthol - high mg - as 1st 'must have' and having gone without the WoWboy for over a week, it's my 2nd fav 'must have' @ 18mg. The other ones I don't crave - just nice to have around for a change of pace.
What flav/flavs do y'all crave if they're out of stock for a while and what mg is everyone vaping on your 'must have' flav? just curious....
Again, thanks for sharing about PIC vs WP!
Last edited:
@ WOW...
I am a minty / menthol person myself but I am still testing other flavors... I have yet to find the right menthol for me. I was very surprised that I liked the watermelon!
I have the Wow Peppermint & Menthol juice's here and just ordered the Peppermint Ice Cream & Watermelon juices. Although I am still trying to figure out if I like this menthol. I got the sampler 1 pack ... most I did not like... The cowboy menthol was ok and the menthol is ok... I refilled some other cartos I had with the menthol and wow peppermint to see if I liked it better, which I did but still think I might put the menthol out there to trade with other individual unused cartos... I had a 5ml that I used to fill some cartos and a 30 ml that I haven't opened yet. Strange thou... the colors are very different, same mg's... Anyone know why?
I am a minty / menthol person myself but I am still testing other flavors... I have yet to find the right menthol for me. I was very surprised that I liked the watermelon!
I have the Wow Peppermint & Menthol juice's here and just ordered the Peppermint Ice Cream & Watermelon juices. Although I am still trying to figure out if I like this menthol. I got the sampler 1 pack ... most I did not like... The cowboy menthol was ok and the menthol is ok... I refilled some other cartos I had with the menthol and wow peppermint to see if I liked it better, which I did but still think I might put the menthol out there to trade with other individual unused cartos... I had a 5ml that I used to fill some cartos and a 30 ml that I haven't opened yet. Strange thou... the colors are very different, same mg's... Anyone know why?
If you haven't already try Steve's SMILIN Special Menthol. The carto should be a light green unless you go with SMILIN blue, which I've never tried. It's really THE best. I didn't mind the Nuports just they have a more tobacco flav. (I also didn't like most of the menthols but, if you like the peppermint you'll like the SMILIN - I just went with the high cause it hits the spot faster, but it's great at 11mg up - the juice is better than the prefilled, also)
When I was first sampling all the mints and menthols they ended up tasting the same unless I vaped a different flav in between. Steve's blend really stands out, but that's just me.
You'll find the right one for you!
I also have some spare cartos but not enough to fill a post....getting there.
When I hit like 20 I should put them up - they just take up space and confuse me about what is in what, y'know? I hate to just toss them though!
I have no idea why your menthol colors are different. Mine were the same color w/ diff mgs.
When I was first sampling all the mints and menthols they ended up tasting the same unless I vaped a different flav in between. Steve's blend really stands out, but that's just me.
You'll find the right one for you!
I also have some spare cartos but not enough to fill a post....getting there.
When I hit like 20 I should put them up - they just take up space and confuse me about what is in what, y'know? I hate to just toss them though!
I have no idea why your menthol colors are different. Mine were the same color w/ diff mgs.
If you haven't already try Steve's SMILIN Special Menthol. The carto should be a light green unless you go with SMILIN blue, which I've never tried. It's really THE best. I didn't mind the Nuports just they have a more tobacco flav. (I also didn't like most of the menthols but, if you like the peppermint you'll like the SMILIN - I just went with the high cause it hits the spot faster, but it's great at 11mg up - the juice is better than the prefilled, also)
When I was first sampling all the mints and menthols they ended up tasting the same unless I vaped a different flav in between. Steve's blend really stands out, but that's just me.
You'll find the right one for you!
I also have some spare cartos but not enough to fill a post....getting there.
When I hit like 20 I should put them up - they just take up space and confuse me about what is in what, y'know? I hate to just toss them though!
I have no idea why your menthol colors are different. Mine were the same color w/ diff mgs.
quitting cigs was a b*tch because I figured even with an e cig it is not going to taste at all good, until someone, I think born or smilin himself, recommended the smilin menthol.
I tried kamel and loved it, but after a few cartos, I started to feel sick. Smilin is the best flavor all together.
I am new to this and have tried a number of different flavors. I LOVE the WOW peppermint. It is incredible! And I was not a menthol smoker. I believe though that as my taste buds come back I will like some of the different flavors. Initially I really couldn't "taste" anything.
- Status
