Why can't we have...standards?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps a discussion like this already exists, but I write this mostly because a chronic (and annoying) problem exists with many atomizers and APVs (regulated and mechanical alike) regarding the fitment of atomizers to battery mods. While we do have a standard threadings for 510, eGo, etc., there are no concrete standards for how deep connectors should be, how long center/firing pins in mods should be, how long atty bottom contacts should be, and so on.

For example, I have copper Manhattan that came with three firing pins of differing lengths. My Tobh v2 fits just fine on it (as in, perfectly flush) with two of the three pins, in fact, because it has a relatively short bottom (perhaps "medium-height") contact. The same atty will however NOT sit flush on my DNA30 box, which has a somewhat shallow 510 connection (it leaves a gap). Then, I bought a Plume Veil, which has a very long bottom contact. Even when using the shortest firing pin my Manhattan came with, the only way to get the Plume Veil to sit flush on it is to compromise by leaving a small gap where the firing button threads into the bottom. I also have an authentic black Russian 91% v2 that ends up having too short of a bottom contact for many 510 connectors, unless I loosen the tiny bottom adjustment screw, which easily falls off once it's loosened. I've lost that stupid little screw like THREE times and NO local shops carry replacements.

I also became so frustrated with my authentic copper 4Nine 18650 mod that I sold it two weeks after I bought it. Why? The hybrid connector is crap and only works correctly with a handful of atomizers (and batteries), ruling out many sub-ohmers that are already pigeonholed into buying flat tops if they want quality high-amp cells. I really wanted to like that mod, too. It had so much going for it otherwise. At least I got most of my money back on that one...

And this folks, is why I believe we need clearly defined standards for things outside of mere specifications of how a threading should be shaped. I believe it's possible to make products that adhere to simple standards, yet are still innovative.
 

WattWick

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Feb 16, 2013
3,593
5,429
Cold Norway
Can't help but think of this

standards.png


Edit: This was just for fun. No offense to OP intended. I get what you're saying :)
 
Last edited:

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
Perhaps a discussion like this already exists, but I write this mostly because a chronic (and annoying) problem exists with many atomizers and APVs (regulated and mechanical alike) regarding the fitment of atomizers to battery mods. While we do have a standard threadings for 510, eGo, etc., there are no concrete standards for how deep connectors should be, how long center/firing pins in mods should be, how long atty bottom contacts should be, and so on.

For example, I have copper Manhattan that came with three firing pins of differing lengths. My Tobh v2 fits just fine on it (as in, perfectly flush) with two of the three pins, in fact, because it has a relatively short bottom (perhaps "medium-height") contact. The same atty will however NOT sit flush on my DNA30 box, which has a somewhat shallow 510 connection (it leaves a gap). Then, I bought a Plume Veil, which has a very long bottom contact. Even when using the shortest firing pin my Manhattan came with, the only way to get the Plume Veil to sit flush on it is to compromise by leaving a small gap where the firing button threads into the bottom. I also have an authentic black Russian 91% v2 that ends up having too short of a bottom contact for many 510 connectors, unless I loosen the tiny bottom adjustment screw, which easily falls off once it's loosened. I've lost that stupid little screw like THREE times and NO local shops carry replacements.

I also became so frustrated with my authentic copper 4Nine 18650 mod that I sold it two weeks after I bought it. Why? The hybrid connector is crap and only works correctly with a handful of atomizers (and batteries), ruling out many sub-ohmers that are already pigeonholed into buying flat tops if they want quality high-amp cells. I really wanted to like that mod, too. It had so much going for it otherwise. At least I got most of my money back on that one...

And this folks, is why I believe we need clearly defined standards for things outside of mere specifications of how a threading should be shaped. I believe it's possible to make products that adhere to simple standards, yet are still innovative.

The 510 thread itself is really a cigalike thread; it is really designed to work on a short cartomizer cigarette sized thing which works for a while, maybe you refill it a few times, but eventually the coil burns out or the filler gets too black and you have to discard it anyway.

So the 510 interface itself just pure and simple was never designed to be used on 22 mm diameter tanks repeatedly.

Maybe a 22mm thread will become more standard over the next few years if hybrids become popular.
 

crxess

Grumpy Ole Man
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 20, 2012
24,438
46,126
71
Williamsport Md
China has no standards ;)

China, China, China
with you it seems to always be China.

I am 60 and a Technician most of my life. I have seen PLENTY of made in America crap that did not Match/fit. :mad:
In fact Our auto manufacturers are Known for consistent recalls for product issues.

Buck up. We are a world full of Humans and Humans screw up. It happens.
 

dopamine1

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 12, 2014
275
231
ohio
Yeah plenty of good stuff is made in China. Junk too, but if it weren't for China most of us would be vaping a blu or njoy, or more likely an analog. They did invent e-cigs.

Anyways, we could have standard 510 sizes. Or we could have standard adjustable connections on mods. I've only ever had that problem with regulated devices though. All my mechs can adjust, even to my infinite magma clone which has a super long pin.
 

dr g

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Mar 12, 2012
3,554
2,406
Paradise
China, China, China
with you it seems to always be China.

I am 60 and a Technician most of my life. I have seen PLENTY of made in America crap that did not Match/fit. :mad:
In fact Our auto manufacturers are Known for consistent recalls for product issues.

Buck up. We are a world full of Humans and Humans screw up. It happens.

Never worked with China, I see.

Yeah plenty of good stuff is made in China.

Mostly by American/western companies. No, I'm not being nationalistic.
 

Baditude

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 8, 2012
30,394
73,076
71
Ridgeway, Ohio
Yeah plenty of good stuff is made in China. Junk too, but if it weren't for China most of us would be vaping a blu or njoy, or more likely an analog. They did invent e-cigs.
I wish that I had saved a link to an article that I once read. One of the Big Tobacco companies had this invention guy do a research project on building what would have been called an electronic cigarette. He came up with a representation of what we now call a cigalike. The project was cancelled by upper management, and of course they owned the patent and manufacturing rights to the product. The guy was fired and couldn't use his invention or offer it to others.

So all of this happened way before the Chinese guy invented his so-called "first e-cigarette". Just saying, this was another example of how Big Tobacco screwed us.
 

rhelton

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 15, 2014
4,161
15,514
spokane, wa
Great discussion. IMO the 510 connection is a flawed weak point that was past down from the cigalike. It needs to be left behind for a more robust connection that will last in the real world. Provape has designed a new connection. Although I am not overly impressed by the new Provari, the new innovation in top cap and atomizer connection is spot on for what we need and where we are headed.
 
Just a little factoid, the Manhattan was designed so most atty's will not sit flush. This is so it can minimize the heat transfer from the attyto the mod. Because, you know, competition mod.

Right...but whenever I do try to leave a gap between the atty and the top cap, my Plume Veil will wiggle too much on the threads, leaving it up to the positive pin to hold the rest of the atty in place. That just doesn't seem very reassuring to me. Besides, the tubing on the Manhattan is so darned thick that heat dissipation doesn't seem to be an issue, even on sub-ohm builds. It will get warm to the touch, but never any hotter.



And to those who bring up the China thing, many of the problems I'm talking about exist even on high-dollar authentic devices. The authentic 4Nine I used to have was a beautifully crafted device that had what I consider to be a serious flaw (poorly designed hybrid connector that's really only designed to work with button-top batteries). My authentic Russian 91% v2 isn't without its own flaws, either. I really wish they would just ditch the stupid adjustable center pin design and ship the damned thing with a straight pin. If manufacturers are going to offer adjustability on anything, I believe it should happen on the mods, not on the atomizers.
 
The 510 thread itself is really a cigalike thread; it is really designed to work on a short cartomizer cigarette sized thing which works for a while, maybe you refill it a few times, but eventually the coil burns out or the filler gets too black and you have to discard it anyway.

So the 510 interface itself just pure and simple was never designed to be used on 22 mm diameter tanks repeatedly.

Maybe a 22mm thread will become more standard over the next few years if hybrids become popular.

I've always pondered this, too. It seems silly that 22 and 28 mm atomizers are held into place on a mod by such a tiny threading. Even an eGo threading is more robust...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread