The juice that got me off of the stinkies was Virginia from Backwoods Brew. It tastes exactly the same as opening a fresh pack of smokes. After 2 years of vaping, it's still one of my favorite flavors.
If you are looking for something with a little more gruff, try Adirondack from Backwoods Brew. Dry, earthy, woodsy, and dark.
If you want knock your socks off, tastes like a burning cigarette, try the Signature blends from Want2Vape, specifically Louisville, Paris, and London.
Signature Blends
You may also want to check out Sunday Morning and Southern Gentleman from Mountain Oak Vapors.
Tennessee Tobacco | USA's Best E-Liquid, What is the best E-Liquid? It starts with Mountain Oak Vapors!
Last but not least, give Serendipity from Heather's Heavenly Vapes a try.
Serendipity (Purity) - $6.00 : Heathers Heavenly Vapes, Top Quality Custom E-Liquids