Classified Suggestions & Questions

Status
Not open for further replies.

ChellyNelly

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 26, 2011
2,155
1,331
Dartmouth, NS
Rating - 100%
23   0   0
You may want to check the USPS website STANDARD PROHIBITED AND RESTRICTED ITEMS
as well as
Canada making e-cigarette nicotine juice illegalWhy does Canada not legalize E-Cigarettes | The big deal with e-cigarettes in CanadaCanadians

As for allowing other countries to participate - our members are GIVING away stuff. Don't you think it's asking a lot to have them pay international shipping rates too? How much would it cost them to ship to Australia? Many of our members have limited funds - yet they offer what they can to help others. What more can anyone ask of them?

That "article" you posted is not a source. It's a website that nobody has ever heard of, a blog, the worst source that's possible to provide. Hearsay, as I said. If you look at the ACTUAL LAWS you will see that it is NOT illegal, and that there are in fact NO laws yet on the matter. Last time I checked no laws did not mean illegal (actually, kind of the opposite LOL). I don't know why you're still trying to prove me wrong. I've been to this rodeo before, I live in Canada, I know these things like the back of my hand. I think Bamrz (thanks, Bam!) has been clear about the other link you posted and why it does not apply to what we are talking about. A single quick Google search in order to find a link that supports your point of view doesn't mean that that is the facts. I could search Google for proof that the sky is purple and find it. You see the issue here?

It costs me $7.61 to ship something to the US. It also costs me $7.61 to ship something of the same size and weight to Singapore. I'm assuming it's not that much different in America where shipping domestically and internationally is a hell of a lot cheaper than it is in Canada. Many members everywhere have limited funds, including, and ESPECIALLY, internationally. But of course, exclude them because they're too far away and even though you don't know how much it costs to ship something to one of these countries you will not consider it:blink:. This new idea is a LOT more far-reaching than any PIF has ever attempted (or in this case, not attempted) to be. It's really so far off base to even be talking about PIF in relation to this idea that it's foolish to be wasting my finger strength to type these words right now. And thus I am done with my rebuttals on this topic, I think I've made my point, and the facts of the matter, quite clear.

Now, if we could, anyone have anything thought-provoking to say on the idea that Projectguy has proposed?
 
Last edited:

Qcaj

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 8, 2012
192
118
Calgary
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
It's easy to be critical it's another to volunteer your time and work to make it happen.
I would love it if the Canada forum could have its own PIF and classified section. I'm sure others would too. Unfortunately, as far as I'm aware that's against the rules and any thread that I've seen along those lines in the Canada forum is closed/deleted within a few hours. :(
 

Huffelpuff

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 27, 2011
3,760
3,153
Philadelphia Burbs
Rating - 100%
36   0   0
Posted by Joker:

As far as PIF goes, take this discussion elsewhere. This is the Classified section and we won't be discussing the PIF operation here because I get paged every time someone post something in this thread.


Maybe a new thread would be in order here?
 

Projectguy

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 9, 2012
3,557
4,838
Oakville, ON
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
Posted by Joker:

As far as PIF goes, take this discussion elsewhere. This is the Classified section and we won't be discussing the PIF operation here because I get paged every time someone post something in this thread.


Maybe a new thread would be in order here?

This is not a "PIF" discussion as there is no concept of payment here.

I am sincerely interested in all input so would ask where would you suggest this thread be transferred to?
 

j0ker

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 24, 2009
10,558
5,557
MS Gulf Coast
Rating - 100%
4   0   0
Apologies for coming in late I have been flying cross country and the Internet connection at the Holiday Inn where I am now is terrible. In any case I'm disappointed that this discussion has gone south.

It shouldn't be this difficult. The "thing" where ever its located on the ECF can and will match Pledging Individuals with Sponsors and Applicants on any planet, continent, country or even City of their choice. So boarders should never ever be an impediment to getting people in need Kit to help them stay away from the stinkies.

Sir: With respect; the definition / understanding of a brokered transaction is only correct if there is payment for the services rendered by in this case, the Sponsor. If we consider a warm and fuzzy feeling for doing the right thing as payment then we have broken the rules. If anything the Sponsor would be required to cover shipping costs - negative compensation....... sounds more like volunteerism / activism.

I understand Chelly's frustration not because of the other members but because of system that keeps backing us into each other and we end up being frustrated with each other because we're the only ones in the conversation and sometime there is no progress.

SO let me design a page / thread / sub-forum have it reviewed by members who have expressed an interest in making this happen and we will revert.

Tobacco is for prayer not recreation

Many words have more than one meaning. As you can see below, there's no mention of monetary gain.

Broker: a person who functions as an intermediary between two or more parties in negotiating agreements, bargains, or the like.
Broker | Define Broker at Dictionary.com definition #2

So brokering in the Classifieds will not be allowed for any reason. Not allowing brokers resolves 2 issues, 1. People can't bypass the Verified Member process we work so hard to develop and enforce, and 2. It prevents members from coming in and buying up all the items posted for people they have on a list that want a certain item (this happened and was the catalyst for the rule).

As I said before, the treasure chest idea you have will not be in the Classifieds. The Classifieds is for buying/selling/trading, surely you must see that "giving" doesn't fit within this theme. So feel free to create a Social Group as PIF has done. The instructions are here http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/fo...groups-plus-social-groups-now-functional.html

Keep in mind, how you aquire the items for the treasure chest can be considered unwanted solicitation either by the member or a supplier. So you should be careful how you acquire the items.

the meaning of my speech is a little more complicated, i do not speak of juice, i'm talking about people who buy in european forums - where you can not sell used price higher than new - and then resells on ecf at outrageous prices. the practice is somewhat shabby and relying irrationality of compulsive buying should be removed, if really vaping is designed to defeat a dangerous drug and not to give people other addictions.

So you are saying we should protect the "irrational compulsive" buyer from themselves? So what responsibility should be buyer have or should we assume all responsibility? The Classifieds is buyer beware, meaning you need to do your own reasearch and make purchases with an educated decision and if you don't, you might not be pleased with your purchase.

We've discussed this pricing issue to no end. Everything so far that has been suggested either won't work or it would consume so much time we would have to quit our jobs just to keep up with it. So, I'm not quitting my job, the pay here sucks :) Trust me, something will come soon for the profiteers but patience will be required, it won't happen overnight.

This is not a "PIF" discussion as there is no concept of payment here.

I am sincerely interested in all input so would ask where would you suggest this thread be transferred to?

The member was reiterating what I said earlier, this isn't PIF nor does this suggestion thread have anything to do with PIF but the subject keeps coming up and I wanted it stopped. I don't apprecite loading the thread to find that the post has nothing to do with the Classifieds.

This thread won't be transferred, it's my thread and I use it for Classified feedback. So you'll have to move your discussion elsewhere because I'm keeping my thread, I'm stingy like that :)

See the link above and create a social group and start your own discussion regarding your idea.....Thank you
 

Dusty_D

Original Guru
Senior Moderator
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 22, 2010
16,228
47,678
53
Toronto, Canada
dustysfoodieadventures.blogspot.ca
Rating - 100%
2   0   0
To the Canadians here, we've hashed and re-hashed the PIF for Canada a couple times before in the Canadian forum, and I had responded to the thread there about why it had failed. The topic keeps coming up every few months. Here's the link to the last few threads:

http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/canada-forum/290715-no-canadian-pif-cant-find.html

http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/canada-forum/304141-pif.html

There are no restrictions on us having a PIF section in the Canadian forum as long as it stays what it's supposed to be. PIF.. plain and simple. For any buying/selling, we have the classifieds section. There will not be a separate classified section for Canada only. That has also been covered a number of times. Some of you guys know this, while others may need to perform a search of the Canadian forum regarding this information. It is there.. just go find it. ;)

The US PIF is HUGE, and has attracted a lot of attention over time. There is no reason the Canucks can't have the same. We have a lot more vapers with a LOT more stuff compared to two years ago and it may just be time to give this thing another shot.

Projectguy, you seem have some nice ideas but I would caution you to start slow, and take things one step at a time. You stand the risk to open yourself up to scammers and scalpers with an open mind/open heart policy. Ask the PIF veterans, they've been burnt a few times too but individuals not toeing the line. Why don't you take charge of the Canadian PIF and get a thread started? We'll see how it holds up this time around. Go build it, they will come.
 

Qcaj

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 8, 2012
192
118
Calgary
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
For any buying/selling, we have the classifieds section. There will not be a separate classified section for Canada only. That has also been covered a number of times. Some of you guys know this, while others may need to perform a search of the Canadian forum regarding this information. It is there.. just go find it. ;)

Sorry to clutter up this thread again, but I did a search and all I found was
1. There used to be a Canadian Classified forum
2. It got shut down.
3. It's not going to reopen because... ???

All I found was about how easy it is to search/sort posts in the new classifieds (which it's not), nothing about the reasoning behind it. And something about it being not-very active because you needed 300 posts or to be a member for a year (I assume before verification).

I also found a buttload of broken links. None of those really explained anything.

I'm really not trying to be a jerk here, but I haven't seen a reason why the classifieds can't be subdivided by how useful they are to a given user. We have a separate area for Canadian Users, Canadian Meet & Greets, and Canadian Suppliers.

I won't bring it up again, but I'd also like to reiterate that there's no effective way to search the classifieds for Canadians right now. I can find items located in Canada, yes, but I can't find items that are available to Canada - this goes for any person that will ship outside of their home country, btw. If a seller is willing to ship outside of the USA, it seems a disadvantage for both buyers and sellers to not have an easy way to know that.
 

j0ker

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 24, 2009
10,558
5,557
MS Gulf Coast
Rating - 100%
4   0   0
Sorry to clutter up this thread again, but I did a search and all I found was
1. There used to be a Canadian Classified forum
2. It got shut down.
3. It's not going to reopen because... ???

All I found was about how easy it is to search/sort posts in the new classifieds (which it's not), nothing about the reasoning behind it. And something about it being not-very active because you needed 300 posts or to be a member for a year (I assume before verification).

I also found a buttload of broken links. None of those really explained anything.

I'm really not trying to be a jerk here, but I haven't seen a reason why the classifieds can't be subdivided by how useful they are to a given user. We have a separate area for Canadian Users, Canadian Meet & Greets, and Canadian Suppliers.

I won't bring it up again, but I'd also like to reiterate that there's no effective way to search the classifieds for Canadians right now. I can find items located in Canada, yes, but I can't find items that are available to Canada - this goes for any person that will ship outside of their home country, btw. If a seller is willing to ship outside of the USA, it seems a disadvantage for both buyers and sellers to not have an easy way to know that.

The reason why there won't be a separation of Classifieds for the various locations is for a couple reason. It's a moderator's nightmare to manage. Having everything is on place makes it easier for us to manage. If someone in Canada wants to sell to US and Canada, where would they post? Double posting isn't allowed. So having it on one place resolve this issue.

I have been considering the way things are designed now and I understand the problem. The way it is now, the title includes "Where the member resides" this was designed this way becuase many people prefer not to order from international locations, it can be a PITA. So having the resident country in the title is easy because it's just 2 letters and members who don't want to have something shippied internationally can ignore those ads. Then we have members on the otherhand that want to know where the member is willing to ship. So here's the breakdown on this:

We have these selections currently (which is slowly growing)
US= United States
CA = Canada
UK = United Kingdom
SG = Singapore
PT = Portugal
NL = Netherlands
GR = Greece
DE = Germany
TH = Thailand

I know someone may ship globally and this option would be fine. So the title might look like this:

(US) (Global) - FS - My Special PV

But, what if they were more selective, which would have to be an option:

(US) (US, CA, UK, GR, NL)- FS - Mod Garage Sale

As you can see, the title grows longer as more selections are made. Short titles was a big plus in our new design, basically "short and sweet" was the thought.

My idea is to have these ship to options but to not include them in the title but to have a search function that will sort the ads per your request. So basically you would select "Willing to ship to: CA" and all ads that fit this criteria would be displayed for you. Unfortunately this has been presented to our design team but due to it's low priority, it can't be configured just yet.

I know this isn't the best answer you could have received but I hope you understand the situation a little better.....
 

j0ker

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 24, 2009
10,558
5,557
MS Gulf Coast
Rating - 100%
4   0   0
Is there a way to sort the classie based on the location of the seller, buyer, & trade?

We have these selections currently
US= United States
CA = Canada
UK = United Kingdom
SG = Singapore
PT = Portugal
NL = Netherlands
GR = Greece
DE = Germany
TH = Thailand

Sorry I just noticed your post.

I have these so far but I'll add the others as well as soon as I can get around to it.

http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/member-classifieds-swaps/272397-temporary-search-links.html
 

proggieus

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2011
190
60
53
minneapolis
Rating - 100%
9   0   0
J0ker is open to constructive comments on how this can be improved. Rather than just complain it is better to offer alternatives and suggestions for improvement.

Don't part part of the problem, be part of the solution.

solution to what? A free market?

In a free market you can put any price you want on something you own, you will either find someone willing to pay it or you won't.
so just because some members feel the prices for some of these items is too much for them to spend you are trying to make a rule about how everyone can price their items?


If they feel the price is to high then they don't have to buy the item. problem solved.


I guess then they will have to resort to the old ebay trick of marking shipping and handling way up.
or are you going to make a rule about how much the handling charge can be too?

For the record i have never profiteered. but it is not your responsibility to dictate who can sell what or for how much.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread