clone vs Authentic: The Real Discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.

young gotti

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 2, 2012
705
286
40
PA
i will only buy clones from here on out...i don't care if it offends ppl because it offends me that these modders think their metal tubes are worth over $100-$200, i don't think they are so i won't support you...nor do i think it's fair to charge ppl and say you put your blood, sweat, and tears into making them....get real, you grabbed a tube in your garage and got to work, probably in your underwear

as a kid and teenager I used to ride BMX, everyone always wanted bikes that were hand welded by real riders and not the big companies that mass produced products.....you know the difference? the rider owned companies charged similar prices to the big named companies that were pumpeing out 10x the product

i take pride in having ppl comment on my set up and thinking it cost over $100 and then telling them it's about $40, i actually wrote a blog about this as well
 

Cyrus Vap

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 8, 2011
4,325
3,507
Bay Area, California
My position:

1) Morality is real, e.g. choosing to support the little guy or whoever you deem needs it, choosing not to copy someone else, etc.

2) Intellectual property as such however, is unreal, despite its 'realization' by law

Choosing to buy legit gear because of number one is fine in my book, but using number two as justification is flagrant nonsense. In my opinion.
 

auxsend

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
May 6, 2014
130
105
Enola, PA
My position:

1) Morality is real, e.g. choosing to support the little guy or whoever you deem needs it, choosing not to copy someone else, etc.

My point is, the little guy does not give you the option to support him. Because the little guy's product is unavailable and comically over-priced.
 

VBdev

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 14, 2014
428
797
Virginia Beach, VA
No easy answers and everyone gets to make up there own minds. I don't judge people's budget's or buying choices but in many ways I fear the culture is turning a blind eye to the bigger picture. Cigarettes are expensive, so if you're replacing cigs, I don't buy into the "I can't afford more than a 15 dollar mechs and atty". We all have to make our choices, and buying the more expensive option means looking for other ways to fit it into the budget. My good buddy living off 10k a year, well ok buy a clone. Actually by a china branded chepo, not a clone.

When I say our culture is turning a blind eye, I'm referring to many issue's here. Qorax posted a good video on china counterfeits recently (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kiMofP9sGg). The factory counterfeiting Addidas, during it's third shut down raid, had children's music playing. No it wasn't for the daycare, the kids were the labor force. The factor was owned by the town's party official, at least none of our (USA) government official's are corrupt or swayed by industry.. Listened to a good NPR broadcast on what has happened to furniture production How A Factory Man Fought To Save His Furniture Company : NPR. China manufacturing is absolutely waging war...Well, I'm in business to make money too. Free market...but fair market. Counterfeit is wrong, cloning other people's intellectual property without agreement with the intellectual property owner is wrong. I've seen another documentary on netflix about china's unfair trade practices (may have been Death By China - the Documentary Film by Director Peter Navarro). Artificially manipulating relative currency value, stomping all over patents, intellectual property, etc. They've essentially socialised shipping. In many cases they have 30-50% price advantage before you even touch on labor costs, material cost advantages, manufacturing equipment cost advantages or big vs small product runs; no it's not all bad business plans. The netflix documentary had a great example where the china companies profit was triple, product cost half, and the US company had something like a 4% margin; the US company didn't make it. The Euro VAT's can be tough, but Germany's looks to apply it in common sense ways to level the playing field. What does it cost a German citizen with reasonable business to produce the product in Germany at a reasonable margin? That Chinese made bike is in the same price ballpark as the German bike at the store's in Munchen. If you don't have kids manufacturing your gear in sweat shops at 75 cents a day, and you want your workers to be able to see a doctor, feed their family, and not live in a hovel, yeah that costs money and everyone in the chain needs to get paid. The living conditions in those factory cities are not good. I don't exactly feel right about throwing my money at that...

Our consumer culture, even capitalism itself tends to support this, is of the mindset we need lots of everything. It's fine to break and replace. spend spend spend. Quality is not rewarded, the manufacturer wants it to break (slightly out of warranty) so we go and buy another. I'm sick of dealing with all this broken crap. Walk out of Wall Mart with your short term warranty that they wouldn't honor in the first place...but hey, saved 5 bux. When I say it's not easy, there aren't always good alternatives. So many times shopping I say OK, what does double get me, and all to often it's the same crap with a bell that rings twice and breaks and a whistle that blows outside of my hearing range. It's throw away waste. Make use of your resources, buy quality you don't have to replace and it will save you time and money in the long run.

Ack not all china goods are crap. Sure the Fogger 4 is not a clone even if the prior version was.

That being said it doesn't make it easy. Looking at a speaker mount which can hold up more than a feather, the cheap china version is $15, the "label brand" version made in china is 30, the "made in the usa option" is $100, ouch. Digging deeper into the made in the usa option because I needed more info on the mounting compatibility (threading, pattern, keyhole, etc), I randomly ended up on one of their pages that made reference to the president splitting time between USA and China manufacturing facilities. .... Does "made in the USA" mean assembled in usa, re-branded, what? Lets pay a middleman to price jack? Global economy is very complex; a higher % of the buying price of a toyota camry stays in America than buying a ford or chevy. I'm far from USA only buying, but want patents respected and a quasi level playing field; at least what the market provides and not artificial manipulation and artificial unfair advantages (the shipping thing). We exported manufacturing and it is biting us in the economy hard right now. Quick everyone go start mod companies (or other manufacturing). I'm being serious. On second thought looks like the FDA will shut you down so prolly a bad idea.

And after all that rant, I don't own a provari, neither of my two authentic mechs are US, my RTA is from Austria, one US made dripper. For me, personally, I don't like where the clones are taking us, it bothers me personally, and I'll have less and save for the authentics. Time is on my side without those stinkies. The quality difference and vape experience is a big factor for me as well. For the price of these 4 items I could have a different settup for each day of the month. They'd be low quality crap I hated though so that's not the right path, for me.

Take what you like and ignore the rest. No I don't hate, judge, or look down on clone users. Hope you all were willing to hear me out though and maybe take something from it. Yes I listen to the clone user's points. Some are very good, some not so much.
 
Last edited:

Equilibrium

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 20, 2014
2,044
3,670
Georgia
Meh… This horse has been thoroughly beaten to death over the last few months. I buy quality clones that carry no “blatant” rip-off’s (names, logos, serial #’s, etc..)
If said clone performs 95% as well as the original and cost 25% as much, I say that I came out on top. It also tells me that the original manufacture/designer is wayyyy over priced.
Not only are they over priced (IMO), they can’t even come close to keeping up with demand. And that tells me that someone is supporting them otherwise their products would be collecting dust on a shelf somewhere.

Probably the only authentic mod that I’ll ever own is a Reo Woodvil. Beautiful!
Now if someone ever makes a high quality clone of it at a reasonable price, I may entertain the idea.
 
Last edited:

sky4it

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 6, 2013
444
598
Minnesota
At some point, there will be no authentics. Then what will the Chinese clone? China has a long history of stomping all over the innovation and hard work Americans have put into developing products. There will be no incentive for the USA (or other international) modders to develop new mods when they see all their profits going to Chinese counterfeiters. This is certainly not unique to vaping mods and has been a legitimate problem for a very long time.

I'd rather cough up the cash for an authentic knowing the money will support a small business owner who has invested his time, sweat, and money into developing a high quality product. That business owner doesn't have the "luxury" of employing third world labor nor does he have access to the massive industrial manufacturing infrastructure of the Chinese conglomerates.

And China has a short history of its American Patents not being honored. aka Ruyans ecig patents

Even if you deny cost savings to the consumer under the support American products idea,you still got problems:

So you want to support American companies like Apple, who have factories in China?
Many large USA manufacturers have all kinds of manufacturing done for them overseas:
They have to, to compete for volume in sales or see shrinking market share.

Then the biggest problem,,, The Law of supply and demand. Consumers will only demand a product in quantity sufficient to support certain volume in certain price ranges.
All of which means outrageous prices may entertain a certain small clientele for some mods, but as a whole they will never rule the day.

While I realize your post is abt the small business guy, they dont get a break just because. <<< thats just the reality of it. China, Taiwan and Korea are rather interesting that way tho. Business owners here can employ third world labor, even small ones. The answer is send the idea to a factory there and have them make it, in order to compete.

the world is on its way to the globally integrated infrastructure,,, Whoooo laaaaa
 
Last edited:

dannyrl

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 6, 2014
193
131
Hillsboro, OR
I have absolutely no knowledge in anything business and economics, but from a consumer point of view, authentic mechs and RDAs are just not even close to within my budget.

Don't get me wrong, I would love to support the people that put the time and effort into designing their products, but I really don't think hundreds of dollars for a metal tube or atomizer is anywhere near a fair price. Granted, China doesn't have to go through the research and design of the clones, but if they can mass produce these products for less than a fraction of the price, something was inflated when someone priced the authentics.

For example, I own an EHpro Atomic and Hcigar Sentinel M16. Build quality of these clones is spot on - all threads are smooth, the post holes were all drilled perfectly, the tolerances *seem* fine, and the products vape well for me. I bought that whole set up for $45. Whereas if I went full authentic, I would have dumped nearly $300.

Actually, my authentic Innovape Pyrex driptip cost more than my entire M16 mod, AND the driptip broke in half because of the heat it was exposed to! Are you kidding me? The one time I bought an authentic product, it broke while doing something it was designed to do. Luckily I had a generic super glue that holds this driptip together better than Innovape's glue.

Anyway, where is that extra $255 going to? These clones are made of the same Stainless Steel and Brass as the authentics and they function the same. I couldn't tell you if they vape the same because I've never seen the real counterparts because they're always out of stock, but I bet they'd vape similarly. And even if the vaping experience with the authentics was better, I doubt it'd be worth $255.


I like to buy authentic when I can. I'd much rather spend the extra cents on a Coke than save money on an RC cola. I buy reputable brand e-liquids, and scoff at the China made juices at my local vape shop. But there's no way I can dump hundreds on a metal tube that was made the same way as its clone.
 
Last edited:

k702

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 18, 2014
760
812
lost wages, sin city, NV
There is a market for both the clone and the authentic mod..
Were the authentic makers willing to lower their price points and raise their production numbers they could probably kill the clone market, but they won't do that.

As long as so many of them try to make their mods like some "super off road Eddie Bower edition" people will look to clones that are more readily available.
As long as so many of them price their mods like their some sort of Lambo of the vaping world people will look to clones that aren't around half - a full car payment.

On the other hand as long as they keep doing these things there are those out there that will keep supporting them. The companies that limit their stock sell their 200 a month and they seem just fine with that. The companies that charge an arm, and a leg, and a kidney, and your first born seem to get what they are looking for.

So why does anyone have to complain about what someone else is buying? Ain't nobody here but us vapers right?
 

zahzoo

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2013
438
795
AR, USA
www.myretrolounge.com
But I say to you; We are told to support small business.

I have a very long history of not doing what I'm told...

A couple of points to throw out from my perspective... I seriously question if any person or company in the US has made a capital investment in purchasing, set-up and tooling a machining and fabrication shop for the sole purpose of manufacturing mechanical mods. In most cases, an enterprising individual within the metal fabrication industry saw a business opportunity and used existing available resources... tools, labor & raw materials to market a profitable product.

If I purchase a $22.95 Chinese clone of the latest Nutcracker V8 mod rather than the $249.95 authentic version made by Bubba at Leroy's Machine Shop am I stealing food from the mouths of Bubba's babies? No... he's still making an honest living fabricating custom upgrade parts for antique John Deere manure spreaders...

Intellectual Property... why a lack of patented vape gear? Most is/was invented in China they don't patent their products in the US much. Mechanical mods are basically flashlight bodies which have existing patents dating back to the 1800's. Bottom line nothing new has been invented here that is patentable.

If designers are failing to Copyright and/or Trademark their designs, logos, etc... Plus invest in the legal costs to enforce their Copyrights and Trademarks internationally... well shame on them. Is it my responsibility to assist these designers at my cost of a more expensive device rather than purchase a competing product at a far better price..? I think not... I'm all for helping another person, but not at my financial loss for their failure in poor business execution.

My bottom line... the value proposition. Price for performance over the duration of product life. Simple logic... $20 for something I'll use regularly but most likely replace or upgrade in less than a year or two -vs- $200..?

This is a simple tool no different than a spatula you use to flip flap-jacks in the kitchen... Mine taste just as good at 6am with the Made in China version... every day. But Hey... if you feel better with a platinum plated version... knock yourself out, cowboy!!
 

Equilibrium

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 20, 2014
2,044
3,670
Georgia
I have a very long history of not doing what I'm told...

A couple of points to throw out from my perspective... I seriously question if any person or company in the US has made a capital investment in purchasing, set-up and tooling a machining and fabrication shop for the sole purpose of manufacturing mechanical mods. In most cases, an enterprising individual within the metal fabrication industry saw a business opportunity and used existing available resources... tools, labor & raw materials to market a profitable product.

If I purchase a $22.95 Chinese clone of the latest Nutcracker V8 mod rather than the $249.95 authentic version made by Bubba at Leroy's Machine Shop am I stealing food from the mouths of Bubba's babies? No... he's still making an honest living fabricating custom upgrade parts for antique John Deere manure spreaders...

Intellectual Property... why a lack of patented vape gear? Most is/was invented in China they don't patent their products in the US much. Mechanical mods are basically flashlight bodies which have existing patents dating back to the 1800's. Bottom line nothing new has been invented here that is patentable.

If designers are failing to Copyright and/or Trademark their designs, logos, etc... Plus invest in the legal costs to enforce their Copyrights and Trademarks internationally... well shame on them. Is it my responsibility to assist these designers at my cost of a more expensive device rather than purchase a competing product at a far better price..? I think not... I'm all for helping another person, but not at my financial loss for their failure in poor business execution.

My bottom line... the value proposition. Price for performance over the duration of product life. Simple logic... $20 for something I'll use regularly but most likely replace or upgrade in less than a year or two -vs- $200..?

This is a simple tool no different than a spatula you use to flip flap-jacks in the kitchen... Mine taste just as good at 6am with the Made in China version... every day. But Hey... if you feel better with a platinum plated version... knock yourself out, cowboy!!


Oh NO.. not Bubba's babies!!! And his poor ol'lady, barefoot and knocked up, starving to death because you won't buy his ingenious creations.... :facepalm:

Great post!!

Woulda "liked" it twice if I could :)
 

inswva

Do you even squonk, bro?
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 19, 2014
4,728
18,512
I have a very long history of not doing what I'm told...

A couple of points to throw out from my perspective... I seriously question if any person or company in the US has made a capital investment in purchasing, set-up and tooling a machining and fabrication shop for the sole purpose of manufacturing mechanical mods. In most cases, an enterprising individual within the metal fabrication industry saw a business opportunity and used existing available resources... tools, labor & raw materials to market a profitable product.

If I purchase a $22.95 Chinese clone of the latest Nutcracker V8 mod rather than the $249.95 authentic version made by Bubba at Leroy's Machine Shop am I stealing food from the mouths of Bubba's babies? No... he's still making an honest living fabricating custom upgrade parts for antique John Deere manure spreaders...

Intellectual Property... why a lack of patented vape gear? Most is/was invented in China they don't patent their products in the US much. Mechanical mods are basically flashlight bodies which have existing patents dating back to the 1800's. Bottom line nothing new has been invented here that is patentable.

If designers are failing to Copyright and/or Trademark their designs, logos, etc... Plus invest in the legal costs to enforce their Copyrights and Trademarks internationally... well shame on them. Is it my responsibility to assist these designers at my cost of a more expensive device rather than purchase a competing product at a far better price..? I think not... I'm all for helping another person, but not at my financial loss for their failure in poor business execution.

My bottom line... the value proposition. Price for performance over the duration of product life. Simple logic... $20 for something I'll use regularly but most likely replace or upgrade in less than a year or two -vs- $200..?

This is a simple tool no different than a spatula you use to flip flap-jacks in the kitchen... Mine taste just as good at 6am with the Made in China version... every day. But Hey... if you feel better with a platinum plated version... knock yourself out, cowboy!!

All very valid points and presented with reason as were a couple of others.

I suppose I'm just fundamentally opposed to blatant forgeries and counterfeits of any product. But, I guess that is my issue to deal with. Maybe I'll soften on that stance in the face of reality or perhaps I won't. I don't have fasttech bookmarked just yet so, we'll see.
 

young gotti

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 2, 2012
705
286
40
PA
i also want to bring up the point that not all authentics charge you half of your mortgage for the product.....

puresmoker used to sell their legacy for around $80 i think

the mini ecig is $50 for stainless steel or $84ish for the titanium

so these modders don't have to rip you off at the rate of $200 per unit, they choice to
 

Tinkiegrrl

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 18, 2013
3,013
3,480
New York, NY
I have a very long history of not doing what I'm told...

A couple of points to throw out from my perspective... I seriously question if any person or company in the US has made a capital investment in purchasing, set-up and tooling a machining and fabrication shop for the sole purpose of manufacturing mechanical mods. In most cases, an enterprising individual within the metal fabrication industry saw a business opportunity and used existing available resources... tools, labor & raw materials to market a profitable product.

If I purchase a $22.95 Chinese clone of the latest Nutcracker V8 mod rather than the $249.95 authentic version made by Bubba at Leroy's Machine Shop am I stealing food from the mouths of Bubba's babies? No... he's still making an honest living fabricating custom upgrade parts for antique John Deere manure spreaders...

Intellectual Property... why a lack of patented vape gear? Most is/was invented in China they don't patent their products in the US much. Mechanical mods are basically flashlight bodies which have existing patents dating back to the 1800's. Bottom line nothing new has been invented here that is patentable.

If designers are failing to Copyright and/or Trademark their designs, logos, etc... Plus invest in the legal costs to enforce their Copyrights and Trademarks internationally... well shame on them. Is it my responsibility to assist these designers at my cost of a more expensive device rather than purchase a competing product at a far better price..? I think not... I'm all for helping another person, but not at my financial loss for their failure in poor business execution.

My bottom line... the value proposition. Price for performance over the duration of product life. Simple logic... $20 for something I'll use regularly but most likely replace or upgrade in less than a year or two -vs- $200..?

This is a simple tool no different than a spatula you use to flip flap-jacks in the kitchen... Mine taste just as good at 6am with the Made in China version... every day. But Hey... if you feel better with a platinum plated version... knock yourself out, cowboy!!

What he said more or less. I've purchased both authentic gear and clones. While I do try and find clones without a logo, if that's all there is available then I buy them. If a company isn't taking steps to protect their logo, why is it then my responsibility to do so for them?

As for working conditions in China, yes, they're terrible. Yes, it's horrible that children are working in factories. However, lets remember that our own weren't the best during our industrialization age. We had long hours, awful working conditions and child labor as well. We had workers living in hovels. China started their own after us, and as they go along, like us, theirs will improve. The families with children working in those factories aren't going to thank you for refusing to buy that factory's products. Often, that's the only available option to get any amount of food, shelter, etc.... Shutting them down doesn't help them unless your willing to aide in feeding the people who worked there. You may be helping an American business by only buying US made products, but I hate when people say they're trying to help with working conditions in China, India, etc by refusing to buy their products. No, you aren't helping them unless you are donating to charities who are over there, feeding them. My family comes from Taiwan. I may by clones, but I promise you my family and I have helped those facing those conditions far more then those who simply refuse to buy products made in China. Let's not presume to speak for those families living those lives.
 

bluecat

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jun 22, 2012
3,489
3,658
Cincy
I as a purchaser am not telling you what to buy. Feel free to buy whatever you. It is your money do what you will with it. I however don't feel a 200 mod is worth it. It is my money and I will do with as I please.

Support small business? It is a crock to use it in this aspect.

Could I purchase a few originals? Sure I could. But why? My neighbors sell cosmetics, tupperware (crap), and some other things. They all want me to pay 200% above what I can find elsewhere. So are you telling me I should support all them too? So now I should just support anyone at any cost just because? Not sure if that is what I would term smart business sense from a business standpoint. Buy Low Sell High. Why as a consumer should I bear the cost. The government already gives small business a bazillion tax credits (Federal and State). Heck move to Ohio they will give a 125k off your AGI for state taxes.

When do we support the consumer anymore? We are asked to bail out the government, the banks, the automakers and everyone else on the planet that it is decided cannot fail. When do we get some support.

It is a tube with a battery. Gimme a break.
 

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego
This "discussion" has been going on for a long time, so here is my take on it...

If you can afford to buy the real deal, and support small businesses and innovators, then please do so.
Consider it an act of charity, like giving money to the March of Dimes or Habitat for Humanity.

If you can't afford it, then don't feel bad about buying a clone.

Just realize that if you do not support the innovators, then they will stop innovating.
And then there won't be anything to clone.

This is NOT rocket science.
It's pure economics.

Do what is right for you.
That is all.
:)
 
I totally agree . I buy authentic . I just had this same conversation about knock off guitars and how they are crap this week . I buy authentic because I know if I have a problem the company I got it from will work with me on a solution to fix it and the quality of the product . Counterfeit or knock off never have the same attention to detail as the original . Think of it as a xerox copy of something , would you like the Mona Lisa or a knock off copy of it in the museum ? I know I pay more for an original but I am paying for a better product . Why would I want something 95% as good ? Doesn't anyone save their money for anything anymore ? Have we lost it? Has it gotten so bad that if we can't have it right now like a happy meal we become whining babies ? Guess I grew up in a different time when you waited , you saved , and you bought quality products because you bought them to last . Why would you want ten of something that breaks every month when you could buy something once and last a year or longer ? Idk call me old or old fashion but the world has lost it bending over for cheap , knock off crap. I'm not saying don't buy chinese for as we all know there are different factories with different grades of manufacturing but for example let's say a kanger , vision or Boge I will by but not the cheap knock off crap at a flee market or eBay .
 
Last edited:

Tinkiegrrl

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 18, 2013
3,013
3,480
New York, NY
I totally agree . I buy authentic . I just had this same conversation about knock off guitars and how they are crap this week . I buy authentic because I know if I have a problem the company I got it from will work with me on a solution to fix it and the quality of the product . Counterfeit or knock off never have the same attention to detail as the original . Think of it as a xerox copy of something , would you like the Mona Lisa or a knock off copy of it in the museum ? I know I pay more for an original but I am paying for a better product . Why would I want something 95% as good ? Doesn't anyone save their money for anything anymore ? Have we lost it? Has it gotten so bad that if we can't have it right now like a happy meal we become whining babies ? Guess I grew up in a different time when you waited , you saved , and you bought quality products because you bought them to last . Why would you want ten of something that breaks every month when you could buy something once and last a year or longer ? Idk call me old or old fashion but the world has lost it bending over for cheap , knock off crap.

I agree to a point regarding quality and repairability. I bought a Provari because I can have it repaired. It's the only regulated mod that I trust. Chinese clones can't compare to it. Sure, their DNA clones can do more, but they cost nearly the same and I can't have them repaired as easily.

It's harder to justify spending that kind of money for a metal tube with threading though. I have, and will, pay a premium for an awesome switch. Clones tend to mess those up, and a good switch is essential for me. However, for the run of the mill, Nemesis like switch, I have and will likely continue to buy clones.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread