I didn't like the Captain. Just got an order today and mixed some FA Desert Ship.
Seems like it would work pretty good with some other tobacco types if you still have any. I was planning on making another batch of Captain and then trying a seperate batch of either Captain/FA RY4 or Captain/FA Cuban Cigar. I always put a drop or two of either tobacco extract or tobacco absolute in all of my tobacco mixes. It just seems to add a little something. I have the FA Desert Ship but havent tried it yet. I lost the dam$ bottle a while back and just happened to find it about a week ago. Not sure how it got in my sock drawer but Im going to try it this weekend.