ECF responds to an anonymous complaint

Status
Not open for further replies.

oldsoldier

Retired ECF Forum Manager
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 17, 2010
12,503
8,000
Lurking in the shadows
www.reboot-n.com
From time to time I think it is good to let people see behind the scenes when there is a controversy going in the forum, so I decided to post my response to this "anonymous" complaint in the open forum. I quoted anonymous because I know who made the complaint based on the wording and watching the events of the last 24 hours or so.


From: Elly Oh Ell [email redacted but certainly was a fake one] -- OS
Username: notgoingttellyou [we know who you are anyhow] -- OS
Forum suggestions/troubleshooting

Message Body:
This forum is hilarious. You guy charge $100/mo so vendors can talk on the forum and have their own section.. But the section is like letting e-bay owners remove their feedback.. bad experience, it's okay the owners can remove the site. if they dont' pay up they are forced into some corner and can't. If a vendor isn't registered / paying then they are restricted to like 90% of the forum, or contribute to the discussion. but that's really not my main issue....
then please continue. We hear these complaints all the time from the vocal minority of the forum users that do not understand that ECF has to pay the bills in order that you can use this free forum. The supplier restrictions are in place to keep the forum from being flooded with spam and completely burying useful content. Oh and please, do your research its not $100 a month, but if you would like to pay ECF 100 a month for a subforum of your own that people can fill with negative posts about you whether they be true or not, I'll set up a special subscription just for you :)

THEN there's the whole ***** ***** thing. I logged in today and find that the mention of **** ***** is banned because of something a co-owner is charged with. What are you afraid of, why the censorship? Are you goign to say something like "The FDA might see this in a bad light and think badly of vaping" Why does that matter, if the FDA cared about what businesses do then they'd shut down all drugs/pharmacies because I'm sure in the history of the FDA some pharmacy owners have done some bad crap. Also if that was your concern why not ban the name before? Brad is still on probation for his 2009/20010 conviction of stealing 50k from his ailing father with the help of his mom. (6mos served, 5yr probation) Censorship makes it worse. I say Let everyone vent / opine / JV is one of my favorite stores.. but I dunno if I"m going to go there for a while until the whole mess is straightened out. Now ppl need to go to places like 4chan or that reddit place (Arent' both of those places suspect when it comes to naughty pictures of kids anyways), that have lynch mob type atmospheres to get news / information about ***** *****(There I censored it for ya North Korea / china) Just make 1 thread for everyone to ...../ vent / etc and then let them have at it.. Just like the American juice association thread. Censorship also leaves ppl out of the loop and unable to make informed opinions about what to do with their money. (isn't this the argument many of the ECF members are trying to make when it comes to the FDA, being able to make their own informed decisions) now it's just speculation and unknown information or just pure deletion of threads (Based on a search for ***** ****) there are a few threads that don't exist any more. So now ppl are oblivious to the current conviction and current charges of a co-owner of a rather popular vape shop. Seriously guys.. grow up and stop being so paranoied..

We censored it because:
1. The person has been banned from here for ages and we do not care to be associated with him or his business. We don't always stop discussion of banned or unregistered suppliers because we want people to talk openly about good and bad suppliers, we just don't want their spam...
2. We don't want Google searches for this person to come up on ECF. This decision was made for a variety of reasons, most of which have to do with the fact that ECF has a right to choose what content is allowed on our forum and who "benefits" from our Google presence.

Even if we did care to be associated with him we will not be party to attacks on someones business or reputation based on unrelated "facts". If we had information that he was for example selling counterfeit merchandise or selling 240mg/ml nicotine as 24mg/ml nicotine we would certainly be shouting it loud and clear for the community to hear (well, actually SEE). Does the fact that Sir Elton John is gay make him a bad musician, or that George Washington owned slaves make him a inconsequential President? Perhaps the fact that Andrew Luster is a convicted ...... should be a reason for women not to buy Max Factor Cosmetics and for everyone to boycott Proctor and Gamble.

We believe that completely unregulated brain dumps ( and the resulting chaos and dilution of content and search results ) adversely affect our goal of being a work safe and family friendly source of information for both the new and the experienced vaper.

We will continue to do what we feel is in ECFs best interest and what we feel best supports the community and the general "cause". Our polices are what they are -- if you don't like them, there are always other alternative venues you may like:
nu-vapor
Vapers Forum

Or perhaps you could start your own forum?
 

windozehater

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 29, 2012
177
76
Nebraska
Totally (curse bomb) agree, if big brother wasnt at the gates with orders to destroy (my theory) and no chance of it happening, shure then watching our backs would be a secondary concern, and this could become <certain forum name> and those kind of antics are not helping the cause. In my twisted view i could see that other place being referenced and or quoted in hearings or commities when the time comes, then once again in this country the most extreme or loudest (even though the minority) will be used to set the tone or have presitant. i feel it is important to conduct ouselves as if we are in church or at grandma's house (be on your best behavor) you dont want others to get a wrong opinion/impression of you. thanks from a lot of us members to the moderators for keeping their eyes on the big picture.
 

Renolizzie

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Aug 7, 2012
6,933
28,124
66
Northern Nevada, astride the "49er trail
I like ECF a lot. I went to another vape forum and it was over the top sexual. The people on this forum are nice and very helpful. I am sure that has to do with the tone set by the moderators. And of course you have to pay the bills and I think that having the suppliers who are authorized to have subforums paying you is a good way to do that. They benefit from ECF and they do make money from the ECF crowd.
 

DeathsMistress

Reviewer / Blogger
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 18, 2012
319
325
40
Chicago, IL
jeneefowler.com
This delicate issue has been handled with maturity and tact for the benefit of the future of e-cigs and vapers. Thank you for having the foresight and wisdom to take care of it. I'm glad I'm not in your shoes and I'm glad that those shoes are being filled with someone who deals with things like this so well. Thank you.
 

Scoop224

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 4, 2012
713
834
Cincinnati
Oh yeah, That thread the other day got so out of hand, I was seriously thinking I didn't want to be a part of a site that would let something like that go on unchecked. I'm glad to see that the hatefest was stopped and removed so that I didn't lose faith in this community. I'm all about joking around and hucking for a laugh or two, but stuff like what I read the other day was crossing a line that even I won't mess with. Hats off for removing the thread!
 

Kopfstimmen

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
May 12, 2012
2,732
3,025
I gotta say, I don't always agree with the censoring. I'm pretty sure I had a thread of mine deleted because someone whined about it. (This is just a suspicion, since a similar thread was allowed a few weeks before. The other thread was allowed, but another member threw a "hissy fit" on mine, and it got removed.) HOWEVER, I'm not paying anything for the pleasure of being able to post my opinion on here, so I'm pretty much always on the mods side, even when they are against me. They do a great job, and if they feel I'm out of line, then well, I guess I am. I've seen a few nasty comments from other members to innocent posts get removed quickly, much to my relief.
Regarding the ****** issue, fine. I didn't like the idea of pyramid schemes and juices named after serial killers anyway. My only regret is that I can't see the name of the vendor I'm not going to order from - to fix this, I just wrote it down.
 

oldsoldier

Retired ECF Forum Manager
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 17, 2010
12,503
8,000
Lurking in the shadows
www.reboot-n.com
@Kopfstimmen sometimes the decisions are very close and it may take only one or two posts to tip the decision one way or the other. We try to be as fair as possible in our enforcement of the rules, if you find yourself in a situation again where a thread of yours gets deleted you can always PM the mod and ask what triggered the decision. They'll do their best to explain to you where the thread crossed the line.
 

serenity21899

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 18, 2013
6,322
11,256
Antioch IL
I am generally not one to join forums due to all the troublemakers and other stupid stuff that generally occurs on them. I joined this one after lurking for a bit because the majority here are helpful and friendly and the BS is put in check right away. I do appreciate ECF more than you will ever know. :)
 

tmcase

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Apr 20, 2011
20,862
54,652
I'm all for deleting any discussion about this vendor because it could really get out of hand but doesn't the ecig community have the right to know who this vendor is if they haven't figured it out by now so they can decide whether to buy from them again or not. I think a brief post stating the facts about this vendor that have already been reported and then locking the thread would lessen the confusion of those who don't know what's going on? Just my 2 cents.

But then again if you are worried that a post like this would show up in a google search then I can see why you might not want to do this.
 

Jerms

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 1, 2011
9,252
25,832
Fargo
Thanks for explaining the decision about JV oldsoldier. Since I've never ordered from them, never planned on ordering for them, and could care less about the legal issues of a vendors owner that I don't do business with, it didn't have an effect on me. Seeing a vendor's name suddenly be censored I did find quite odd though, and you're explaination clears it up for me.

I'm still confused about the censoring of .... Van ..... Ecf hates '60s sitcomes? ;)

Sent from my LGL55C using Tapatalk 2
 

SkinniePost

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 29, 2012
275
617
Madison, WI
Nothing to do with your decision, since that is your choice and really is none of my business...

But just a heads up... If you do a search for "*name of company* reviews", ECF still comes up on the first search page? And also the discussions of said person and the current situation are cached by Google... How long before they clean their cache, since you can still read all of the comments, discussions, etc.

I honestly am not trying to cause a problem, just pointing it out in case there is a way you can get the information removed? Is it possible to ask Google to delete it from their servers?
 

Thepinfamily

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 18, 2013
515
403
Virginia
I logged on today to decide who I was going to order from next. I'm a newb of two months and I'm still searching for my ADV. I also need some more hardware. I totally understand why the ECF made the decision they did, it was the smart thing to do. I am concerned I will stumble into the wrong site and order from the wrong supplier. I have no idea what and who everyone is talking about. If there is a supplier I should stay away from I would appreciate it if someone would clue me in through a pm. Just a name would be fine. Thanks.

EDIT: Thanks. Now I understand. I definitely think more harm than good would come from future discussion.
 
Last edited:

Kari2000

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 30, 2012
75
13
Florida
Ok who and what thread are we talking about? I was beginning to think that I spent way too much time on here and now apparently not. :facepalm: I went to another forum just to see what it was like compared to ecf and it was like they let the crazy vapers have their own website. (No offense intended)

Never mind I know who we're talking about now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread