eLiquid Bans and such.

Status
Not open for further replies.

EddardinWinter

The Philosopher Who Rides
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 13, 2012
8,866
28,169
Richmond, Va
I would imagine their publicists instruct them not to get involved with electronic cigarette activism.

True, wasn't it Katherine Heigl who vaped publicly, though? I don't mind asking her to help. I do have a way with tall athletic blondes. We don't have much to lose.
 

Myk

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 1, 2009
4,889
10,658
IL, USA
They are using that argument quite frequently. Of course, the flavored cigarette market was so tiny that tobacco companies were willing to give it up and consumers really didn't care - as long as they didn't touch one popular and best-selling flavor - menthol. Notice how that one didn't get banned?

With e-cigarettes, flavors are a huge factor. It is also hard to "ban flavors" when ALL e-cigarettes are flavored. Nicotine and PG/VG are flavorless. So, even tobacco/menthol e-cigarettes are "flavored." E-cigarettes also have a very active community that cigarettes don't have. Most smokers are self-loathing and bought into the lie that flavored cigarettes targeted children (due to the ANTZ efforts) and would feel ridiculous "fighting" for them. Smoking advocates are considered at nest nuts and at worst, evil, uncaring murderers who want to kill babies with their smoke. :rolleyes: E-cigarette users don't want to lose their flavors and will fight for them and can give reasons for flavors that are hard to vilify. As with flavored cigarettes, there is absolutely no evidence that e-cigarette flavors "target children," anymore than flavored nicotine gums and lozenges (cherry, orange, fruit chill, mint, cinnamon, java) targets children. How can they claim adults don't want flavors when the drug companies couldn't sell their NRT without adding tasty flavors kids love? Other arguments e-cigarettes have for flavors is that 1) tobacco/menthol e-cigarettes don't really taste like smoking - it's more like the flavor of chew, which most smokers aren't accustomed to; and 2) for people trying to get AWAY from smoking, they want flavors that do NOT remind them of smoking, so they aren't tempted to go back to the real thing. If you want real milk chocolate, but cannot have it, eating a carob bar could just make you crave the real thing even more.

So, there are a LOT of reasonable arguments for e-cigarettes flavors that simply didn't apply to flavored cigarettes.

I was just reading they're going after menthol cigarettes again.

Yeah, with "tobacco flavored" ecigs being anywhere from tasting like coffee to tobacco that would be difficult to define. I can imagine some ANTZ at the FDA having to taste nicotine liquids to approve or deny them.
 

mkbilbo

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 4, 2013
2,294
2,874
Austin, TX
www.thesmilingwolf.com
I was just reading they're going after menthol cigarettes again.

Yeah, with "tobacco flavored" ecigs being anywhere from tasting like coffee to tobacco that would be difficult to define. I can imagine some ANTZ at the FDA having to taste nicotine liquids to approve or deny them.

Ooo but they couldn't! You know if you come within five miles of an e-liquid, you become addicted to seventeen different street drugs!
 

Myk

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jan 1, 2009
4,889
10,658
IL, USA
The European Union is phasing out the use of nicotine pesticides.

I was under the impression that the United States was doing the same, but I'm not sure, and this is all I can find...
http://www.epa.gov/oppsrrd1/REDs/nicotine_red.pdf

It doesn't matter about nicotine pesticides.
The fact that I have quarts of pesticides in other classifications that can kill anyone that are protected only by a childproof cap makes any move to do away with nicotine e-liquids sold in tiny bottles protected by childproof caps hard to justify in court.
I have pills in quantities that can kill with the option to not use a childproof cap.
Cleaners that can kill, childproof cap.
All of these are sold in large quantities.

Has there been any deaths from ingesting bottles of e-liquids in the minimum 5 years they've been in the US? No, because you would barf if you could manage to get them down. So where is the justification on requiring 1ml prefilled carts protected by cellophane?
I just don't see finding a judge that would uphold such a thing if it was challenged.

I think this kind of thing is the hold up for the FDA releasing their rules. They want to go all out but they know they can't so they're trying to figure out how far they can push and get away with without anyone challenging their rules. They know they're going to have to boil this frog slowly too, and they probably fear a slow first move will make for a rational law and they won't get to go further (like the ANTZ fear with minor bans).
 

r77r7r

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
  • Feb 15, 2011
    13,653
    22,632
    Pa,LandOfTaxes
    CASAA has contacted the staff of a few famous e-cigarette users, most notably Katherine Hiegel. We were turned down. Unfortunately, there are very few famous vapers who CASAA would want representing them. Charlie Sheen and Courtney Love? Um...no thanks. Most respectable celebrities are already involved in their own charities and don't care about protecting their "right to vape."

    What?! No love for the Sheener?!!! How about taking a vote on that?

    Epic-Win-by-Charlie-Sheen_o_95277.jpg

    Lol.

    -Darn, that was a GIF. How comes I can't load a GIF? Is there an "upload GIF" button?
     
    Last edited:

    Hotwire

    Ultra Member
    ECF Veteran
    Dec 20, 2010
    1,890
    909
    England
    510 atty's,CE4 types and even pre filled carto's are all in use as we speak.

    Vaporizing is getting big in those circles and while that tech has gone down it's own path there is still a crossover.

    The up side is that there are better options for them than using ecig hardware so it might die a natural death.

    I met a guy in a bar the other day who sells e-cigs and supplies. My friend smoked something that rhymes with 'seed' with the guy - I don't do that, hate the stuff - and he told us he has e-cig tech batteries and a high burning vaporizer they made that vaporizes the ... in the stuff that sounds like 'seed' and leaves all the tar and other stuff behind. Don't know if he was bs'ing and showing off or not, but he seemed to be pretty sure. He's from Denmark and says the tech is made there.

    If this post is against the TOS, I apologize and please delete it (but don't ban me...)
     

    evolv3

    Senior Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    May 10, 2013
    271
    265
    Orlando, FL, USA
    Please don't get Sheen involved. This would be like getting Kardashian.

    Like was said previously, we need someone a little more respectable to be respected.

    Im not knocking sheen for what he does and how he can "pull it together when necessary", it takes MAD skills.

    But the key here is to BE respected to crossover to non-vapors and people not sympathetic to the cause from my point of view at least.

    I would cringe seeing Sheen on a PSA plea. I think it would immediately turn off a lot of close-minded people which seem to be who you need get to open up to further grow the cause.

    Heigl on the other hand....
     

    kristin

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Aug 16, 2009
    10,448
    21,120
    CASAA - Wisconsin
    casaa.org
    I sent her a message. We will see if she gets it.

    Sent from my HTC6435LVW using Tapatalk 2

    If she's changed her mind since I spoke with "her people," let me know! I was told she already has her own animal charity she runs with her mother and wasn't interested in helping CASAA. Too much on her plate, I guess. That's understandable.
     

    DC2

    Tootie Puffer
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jun 21, 2009
    24,161
    40,974
    San Diego
    If she's changed her mind since I spoke with "her people," let me know! I was told she already has her own animal charity she runs with her mother and wasn't interested in helping CASAA. Too much on her plate, I guess. That's understandable.
    How did you guys even get a response?

    I've tried contacting a few celebrities that vape and never got any response.
    Not that this surprised me.
     

    stevegmu

    Moved On
    ECF Veteran
    May 10, 2013
    11,630
    12,348
    6992 kilometers from home...
    As someone that works to influence public policy against big companies (not tobacco buy the way), I find it both a good thing and a bad thing to have FDA come in and regulate certain items.

    The only positive I see is that some regulation should be welcomed to distinguish the good actors for the bad. I don't know about you, but I would feel a lot more comfortable knowing that eLiquid suppliers were held to some standard that allowed us to ensure that proper chemicals were used in there juices. Granted I don't know enough about the national trade association for eCigs or eLiquid suppliers but having the industry police itself will be tough. Even if 99% of eLiquid suppliers do what's right, there will always be that 1% of suppliers that add chemicals that prove to be toxic...Of course once something happens like that, it will be the all over a 60 minutes expose that forces congress and FDA to take action. I hate to say it, but the more this gets popular the more it becomes inevitable that some standards will be put in place.

    So with that said, I don't think the industry should run away from imposing standards. However, the problem with the FDA or any federal agency is the slippery slope once a product becomes regulated it then becomes even more regulated to the point that nobody can comply. This is especially true with this industry that has a lot of small entrepreneurs doing a great job at running a business. Politicians from both parties love to say they fight for small businesses, they use it on the campaign trail to sound good. However, what they end up doing is regulating a product or service to the point that the only ones that are able to comply are the BIG COMPANIES. In this case, big tobacco will be the only remaining companies left. I do think that once they enter the market, they won't try to kill it but realize the profit potential and hopefully make better products even.

    With all that said, my biggest fear is to ensure we fight not only for our right to continue but to do so by ensuring products remain safe, and that small companies aren't hurt with costly and too burdensome regulation. That sounds idealistic, I know but this is a common theme for every industry that is out there. Look at restaurant owners, department stores, banking, ect..They have been all left to close up, and only the big chains can survive.

    What doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me, is that if I prepare a sandwich in my kitchen and sell it on the street, I would have to have a certificate from my local health department, yet I can prepare a liquid, which contains nicotine, which people vaporize and inhale and sell it on the internet, with no form of regulation whatsoever.
    Regulation shouldn't be all or nothing.
     

    Myk

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Jan 1, 2009
    4,889
    10,658
    IL, USA
    What doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me, is that if I prepare a sandwich in my kitchen and sell it on the street, I would have to have a certificate from my local health department, yet I can prepare a liquid, which contains nicotine, which people vaporize and inhale and sell it on the internet, with no form of regulation whatsoever.
    Regulation shouldn't be all or nothing.

    Technically they are supposed to have that certification. Problem is it's a very big country.
     

    kristin

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Aug 16, 2009
    10,448
    21,120
    CASAA - Wisconsin
    casaa.org
    How did you guys even get a response?

    I've tried contacting a few celebrities that vape and never got any response.
    Not that this surprised me.

    It could be because I was calling as vice president of a national, non-profit organization maybe? She's the only one I personally thought was worth seriously contacting because of her more "wholesome" image. Smoking celebs seem to mostly be "bad boys" (Sheen, Love, etc) or just way too unreachable (Depp, Dicaprio.)

    On a positive note, one of the Deadliest Catch captains was vaping on the show last week. Of course, Elliott is also one of the more polarizing captains. People either love him or hate him, lol!

    But whether celebs become official advocates or not, just being seen and photographed using e-cigs makes them unwitting, yet extremely effective, ambassadors for our cause. :)
     
    Last edited:

    EddardinWinter

    The Philosopher Who Rides
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jun 13, 2012
    8,866
    28,169
    Richmond, Va
    It could be because I was calling as vice president of a national, non-profit organization maybe? She's the only one I personally thought was worth seriously contacting because of her more "wholesome" image. Smoking celebs seem to mostly be "bad boys" (Sheen, Love, etc) or just way too unreachable (Depp, Dicaprio.)

    On a positive note, one of the Deadliest Catch captains was vaping on the show last week. Of course, Elliott is also one of the more polarizing captains. People either love him or hate him, lol!

    But whether celebs become official advocates or not, just being seen and photographed using e-cigs makes them unwitting, yet extremely effective, ambassadors for our cause. :)

    Yeah, why couldn't it have been Sig?

    Sent from my HTC6435LVW using Tapatalk 2
     

    DC2

    Tootie Puffer
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jun 21, 2009
    24,161
    40,974
    San Diego

    kristin

    ECF Guru
    ECF Veteran
    Aug 16, 2009
    10,448
    21,120
    CASAA - Wisconsin
    casaa.org
    Yeah, why couldn't it have been Sig?

    Sent from my HTC6435LVW using Tapatalk 2

    The one that gets me is Keith's little daughter begging him to quit smoke-free tobacco in 2010, but he was still using it the 2012 season. He gets so stressed over it and ST isn't anywhere near as bad as all of the smoking on those boats. I feel bad for him because he feels so guilty when he uses ST and he shouldn't have to feel that way! He just ends up making himself more stressed - which is probably far worse for his health than the ST would be! Ironically, if more of the guys would switch to ST, they'd be better off. (E-cigarettes are impractical on deck - especially since they only seem to use the "blu" styles when they get them. Those would never last the harsh conditions, dozens of batteries would die during 18 hour shifts and weak vapor is useless in windy conditions.)
     
    Last edited:
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread