Agreed in that obviously much of that didnt meet the principle of "peaceful".
Cleanup, portajohns, extra law enforcement, etc, I can see your point. Logistically though, it could be challenging for a grass roots effort to organize that kind of funding. For example, when the FDA thing hit, there was talk of a pro-vape march on Washington, who would foot the bill if the "protesters" were responsible for the expenses? Not saying they shouldnt be, just increases the odds that a "March" wouldnt ever happen if that were required.
On the flip side, are politicians required to pay for the extra law enforcement etc when they hold rallies?
It is a common practice for party campaigns to negotiate reasonable compensation to host cities for services expenses incurred as a result of the event, often offset by an estimate of the expected boost to the economy in monies anticipated to benefit the host city spent by participants. I had heard some discussions taking place along these lines during preliminary planning walk-thrus for Clinton's DNC convention at Madison Square Garden way back when I worked there.
Regarding the FDA March on Washington, any group that expects to put forth an agenda in protest will have to decide whether or not their constituents believe in the cause enough to shoulder the expense of necessary services for that event or protest, just like you do with a coop. If your constituency is unwilling to do so, your constituency obviously are not committed to your cause. A place like Washington DC, hosts protests all the time and there is a congressional budget put forth the fund certain services as part of the applications through the Park Service and local authorities to defray costs. Events are sponsored & fundraising for them occurs because the rewards of a successful outcome justify the expense.
I also believe that a vape protest would be relatively low cost for services as violence would be unlikely & cleanup should be minimal as we aren't throwing cigarette butts & wrappers out. Event organization could also keep costs down if some jackass threw a mod through a Starbucks Window if your own community apprehended the perpetrator and turned him over to authorities. How could we expect authorities to cater to our needs if our people do not act in a manner that is a demonstration that we are deserving of what we are asking?
If the Women's march wants to discard their signs in front of Trumps Hotel in protest, they should be willing to pay to have the mess cleaned up in exchange for the right to do so. If Madonna wants to get on a microphone and tell Trump to go F-himself during a live televised speech, she charged with the crime it is & should be forced to pay the FCC fines each of the major television networks should be fined for broadcasting these vulgarities & be happy to pay those fines for the privilege of doing so. Let her take financial responsibility for her own actions or be locked up for willfully committing a crime.
Just an aside - I remember one time that they were resurfacing the Knick's Basketball Court in the Expo Center and had finished applying the third clear coat not 1hr before a Ranger's game & had it barricaded off. At half-time of the Rangers Game Madonna regularly would retreat into the Expo Center & walked right up to the court, opened the barricade, and let her kid go running all over it. When I ran up to check the surface & explain why I was concerned & the security guard escorting her was all over me because it was Madonna. I admonished the security guard for allowing it & she was apologetic as she hadn't realized it was newly resurfaced & was going to go on the court & collect the kid. I told her it looked like it had cured enough where her kid wasn't doing any damage but those 4" spiked heels she was wearing certainly would. That kid ran all over the court while I stood there twitching the whole time & it took 5 min before the kid came back to her. She was cool about it & it appeared no real harm was done, but that inherent assumption of celebrity privilege really bugged the crap out of me.
People who show up to these protests with bandanas & masks on obviously have them to hide their identity because they are planning unrest & should not be allowed to participate & should be hauled off for questioning by police. Every participant in a protest should be photographed & submit ID to participate in order to hold them accountable for their actions caught on film. That is not unreasonable and would record attendance to these events supporting the goals of the protest on record to advance the agenda of the group. None of this seems unreasonable to me, but the ACLU has gotten away with what we see today & I for one cannot understand why it is allowed to continue.
I believe we a society have forgotten all about personal responsibility and it is that refusal to accept or demand acceptance of responsibility for one's own actions that is the cornerstone of the Decay of our Country's Values and Society in General. I also believe the actions of the left after this election have been inexcusable from the DNC, Congressional Representatives, the Media, the Celebrities, and right on down to the Protestors. None of them seem to realize many of them putting forth this effort to de-legitimatize Trump are doing their cause more harm than good in the eyes of many Americans. When most Americans believe the intelligence services, government in general and the media are lying to us because it sounds so utterly absurd, it is truly a sad state of affairs indeed.
Give the guy enough rope, he'll probably de-legitimatize himself, or he may succeed beyond our expectations. I'm hoping for the latter, despite his ego, but only time will tell so I'm keeping my fingers crossed that he doesn't screw up too badly & will give Washington the wake-up call on both sides of the aisle most American would agree is needed.
I'm done now, I just had to get that out. Sorry.