Ithaka official

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jojobo

Ultra Member
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 10, 2012
1,246
3,845
Northeast USA
they have...and getting worse...it's to the point where I have only one that I use because I just can't have multiples running at the same time. it's too frustrating and too messy. My mistake in buying 8 of them without testing them first...I figured it would be like the iatty..get them now or never get them again or pay thru the nose on classifieds...:(
 
Last edited:

Jojobo

Ultra Member
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 10, 2012
1,246
3,845
Northeast USA
I have the orings that were provided with the ithaka...and recommended for the ithaka...I always take good care of them and they dont even have a chance to dry out because of the "moisture"...I have tried other orings but they are either too small (thin) or too fat...there isn't one that I have found that is just right and the top cap seam leaking? im not going to stuff an oring where it doesn't belong...
 

Shaketuga

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 22, 2013
786
935
Casper, Wyoming
Okay so I know I said I was gonna leave for a few days but that was before I got home and saw a parcel from Greece sitting on my dresser :D. And so I present to you......Ithaka in Colossus Mode
8yje6aha.jpg



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free
 

imeothanasis

Unregistered Supplier
ECF Veteran
Feb 13, 2009
47,882
34,510
Athens, Hellas
gg-goldengreek.com
yankee, Ithaka has the 16x1 o-ring everywhere. If you put a 17x1 o-ring your problems will be solved
I've replaced with same size, tried different sizs, etc. It's bugging the hell out of me. All my ithakas do this randomly. This one is from top seal. Sometimes bottom near cut outs on base. Only orings that seal it off actually show when closed. .5 fatter. I never know which seam it'll bead up on. Sometimes no leak, other times I can't stop it. Always scratching my head. :confused:
 

imeothanasis

Unregistered Supplier
ECF Veteran
Feb 13, 2009
47,882
34,510
Athens, Hellas
gg-goldengreek.com
17x1 o-ring is the size you need and I have send those o-rings to my sellers in case of someone like you had a problem jojo. I told to my sellers to send them for free to my customers. So you could try to contact e-smoke guru about this issue
I have the orings that were provided with the ithaka...and recommended for the ithaka...I always take good care of them and they dont even have a chance to dry out because of the "moisture"...I have tried other orings but they are either too small (thin) or too fat...there isn't one that I have found that is just right and the top cap seam leaking? im not going to stuff an oring where it doesn't belong...
 

imeothanasis

Unregistered Supplier
ECF Veteran
Feb 13, 2009
47,882
34,510
Athens, Hellas
gg-goldengreek.com
you did very well by buying the number of Ithakas you needed Jojo. Your problem is not a problem, I ensure you!
they have...and getting worse...it's to the point where I have only one that I use because I just can't have multiples running at the same time. it's too frustrating and too messy. My mistake in buying 8 of them without testing them first...I figured it would be like the iatty..get them now or never get them again or pay thru the nose on classifieds...:(
 

Shaketuga

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 22, 2013
786
935
Casper, Wyoming
Okay so I know I said I was gonna leave for a few days but that was before I got home and saw a parcel from Greece sitting on my dresser :D. And so I present to you......Ithaka in Colossus Mode
8yje6aha.jpg



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free

I may have to get a couple 18500 batteries to stack like Steliosss so it can be Just GG in Collosus mode oh what a site that shall be.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free
 

thedrpepperdude

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 17, 2012
256
193
TEXAS
I use Dow Corning DC4 to lube O-rings and have never had a leak. I have low and high s/n ( from 0075-6118 ). here is a link to some for sale at amazon.

Dow Corning 4 Electrical Insulating Compound - Amazon.com

I use thick Vg mostly and am still on original set of O-rings in all of mine. Just a tip, lube and install all O-rings, then wash hands very good before handling wick.
 

yankeebobo

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 23, 2012
7,046
21,034
Western MA
I am going to create one post. I don't mean to offend anyone with all the advice, but I'm too tired, too cranky, and done trying to explain all this over again. I'm also too damn tired to go and multiple quote anything. I'm sorry.

There have been some good tips, but here is where I'm at. I have had this problem - correction - WE have had this problem from the beginning. We read, closed our mouths and read some more. By now, I think everyone knows that we have had our share of GGTSs, Penelopes, Odysseus, and lord knows we could play chess with iAtty vs Ithaka. The care given to these have been top quality..... Ithaka changed.

The leak progressed, we continued to read, we posted. It can't leak. All of a sudden, we both felt like we were "rookie GG users" all over again. We would scratch our heads, look at each other, get aggravated. I would sit up until 4AM, building and rebuilding. Playing with different configurations. Single, Dual, parallel, cross, etc. Of course the problem is that you can't tell immediately if it will leak. There's no way. It could be 5 minutes, it could be 5 hours. I wish I had taken more photos along the way. But I posted one earlier in this thread. I have included a couple photos below of the ONLY solution that seems will work. The ONLY one that I have in my arsenal of parts. Yes. Bruce is sending me some 17x1 orings. Frankly yes, I hope it works. Because if it does, I can certainly go purchase a 50 pack of that size.

BUT... The quality is different with Ithaka. I'm sorry, but it is. We can't be the only ones. Actually if I remember others even recently posted (I know who, but am not throwing anyone under a bus) regarding this mysterious random acts of moisture affect. Was it a small series that was run that has this problem? Maybe SN won't help because the CNC was run for a certain number with a slight variance to measurement? But then they are sent to engraver and mixed up? I don't know. BUT... the Ithaka is a thinner material. Imeo you can say that it's more expensive because you're removing more metal...but. I can see on one hand you being right. On the other, the less the material the cheaper the price. You know I'm not complaining about price. We have 8. I can hold in my hands right now the weight and feel the walls of the penelope, iatty, etc. It's a heavier walled atomizer.

There is one GG loyal vaper that uses Odysseus. They swear by the Ody. And believe me, the weight (both in grams AND solid contraction) helps me understand why. I know part of the goal here was to reduce the weight so we made it thinner. Another part was to increase an extra .5ml of juice. Fighting for a little extra here or there WILL cut down the end result. It's either that or it becomes taller.

I'm beginning to feel that with the thinner ss, the variance in depth of the oring slot can be passed a little too easy. It's less forgiving. I've worked in a factory before I went to work in Systems and Networks. I know that there is a degree of variance allowed in rubber, plastic, and other soft material. There is LESS forgiving of variance on harder material such as metal. Why does one ithaka leak, dribble, spit, or droll and another one doesn't, I don't know.

I believe those that say they DO NOT leak. But believe us when we say ours do. We don't create stories here. I will wait for the 17x1 oring. And please don't tell me it's a preference if some want 16x1 and others want 17x1. That tells me some want leaks and others don't. A "preference" is some want satin brushed, and others want polished shiny.

The first picture: The Ithaka. It's 1.5mm thick. Obviously too thick. But I'm NOT buying 3 different sizes and guessing which oring will fit. It's still a 1mm thickness.
The second picture: My oring collection. I have EVERY size oring you mention for all of your products Imeo that I use. I see I will have to add a collection of about 4 orings that JGG uses that I don't have. I've tried everything in that box. I have yet ANOTHER box that is fractions instead of mm. I have already taken more tries at guessing and I am guessed out. I hope the 17x1 resolves this problem.

Imeo - Jojo and I are tired. This has been mentioned before. We took a break from ECF for a little bit and did NOT go trolling through older posts to see if there was a solution. We didn't hunt it down. But we also have mentioned this a few times. For a long time, before we took a break, you stated that it's impossible to leak. There was no way. This can't leak. Do you understand where it got tiring to repeat it over and over? The oring solution you gave was last week. I PMd Bruce and am expecting it. But how many weeks and months went by before we got this solution. And to be honest, it's not a solution until is solves OUR issue. If it helps somebody else, great. But if it doesn't help us, then we have lots of dirty laundry or expensive paper weights.


 
Last edited:

jjkanto

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 26, 2013
718
440
45
Patterson, CA
Okay so I know I said I was gonna leave for a few days but that was before I got home and saw a parcel from Greece sitting on my dresser :D. And so I present to you......Ithaka in Colossus Mode
8yje6aha.jpg




Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free

Awesome Shaketuga! I want to do that too!
 

imeothanasis

Unregistered Supplier
ECF Veteran
Feb 13, 2009
47,882
34,510
Athens, Hellas
gg-goldengreek.com
Yankee, first of all I dont understand what's the issue is with thinner walls on Ithaka. Its lighter, and all the unnessesary metal is removed. Maybe you would prefere a heavy atomizer with no reason to be like this? I can make it real heavy for sure but in our days we are looking for something light and small. I dont think that anyone will agree that we need fat and heavy constructions

Quality on Ithaka is different on what level comparing to other GG consttuctions? On walls? But its made like this to improve quality, height, weight and capacity as you said. If quality was not there then you would have broken parts on Ithaka. So if your Ithaka is robost and works as we all expect then why do we need fat walls and heavy constructions?

And because we are talking about thinner walls, I have to tell you that the lower body of Ithaka has the same width as Ody's body, so o-rings fit there exactly as they fit on Ithaka. Ithaka just use thinner o-rings only and not thinner walls in that part.

If one Ithaka leaks and the other doesnt leak is because o-rings have a tolerance. We cant make o-rings with the same tolerance as metals. So the simple solution is to use bigger o-rings. O-rings are not a problem when you have a serious device like Ithaka. If for example your "Μiele" washer leaks, you just change the o-rings inside, not your Μiele

I never said that it's a preference if some want 16x1 and others want 17x1. I said that I always leave room for bigger o-rings if thats needed. I think that I have said it not once but more than 3-4 times.

Lets discuss the width of your Ithakas walls. You say that your one Ithaka has 1,5mm fat wall and your other Ithaka has 1mm wall? Or maybe I didnt understand something here?

Of course I stated that its impossible to leak. If you put the right o-rings there then its really impossible to leak. And if you ask me why I put o-rings that allow Ithaka to leak, its because mine didnt leak when I put those o-rings there. But as I said before, I always leave room for bigger o-rings in case someone has a problem. I am trying to avoid future problems like yours because I look further than myself. I am trying to cover all possible situations when I make a GG construction.

I didnt gave my o-ring solution last week! My solution was posted before months. Maybe you missed it and thats why you are tired trying to solve your problem. I am sure that other people here will be able to find the post about it. I will too try to find it.
 
Last edited:

yankeebobo

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 23, 2012
7,046
21,034
Western MA
I honestly don't have a problem with thinner walls. It's lighter. What I'm trying to say is the thinner walls seem to indicate to me that if you machine out a slot, it seems that the tolerance is not as tight. The oring "option" thing I don't think you and I will agree on. Honestly, I don't understand why the need to give an option for oring. If a 17x1 fits, and guarantees leaks to stop, then we use a 17x1 oring. If Ithaka went out to test with some people, I can't believe after a little time some juice wouldn't show for anyone. I guess my point here is if my mechanic says I need a 16x1 oring, then a 16x1 oring will be what I go and get. He won't tell me "Well, you can use a 17x1 if you prefer, because we left a gap there on purpose for your liking." You could tell all of us that it's a 10x1 and you know what? We'd have to believe you. Of course, I'd love to be a fly on the wall watching all of us stretch out a 10x1 at the windows.

Honestly I'm not going to keep beating the oring subject. I've voiced my opinions on it. You mentioned to me the oring 17x1 in post #6062. But if you look at the date of that post, it was exactly 2 weeks and 2 days ago. I PMd Bruce to include some per your suggestion. I just am waiting now. Believe me, if the 17x1 solves this problem, I will HAPPILY go to my oring supplier and order 100 of this size.

I will admit this much. I probably should have done a search on the thread for orings and seen this. I never said you didn't SAY it until 2 weeks ago. I said that's when you said it to ME. I took a break of ECF for a few weeks after another issue that I don't feel the need to mention. When I came back, I didn't read all posts. I just started reading again.

Imeo, you know what I have, you know what I write. You know that I jump in to help out where I can because I've made my own mistakes. Sure, there are those that jump in more, that have been around longer than I, that have been around since rev 1 of your TS, but I do what I can when I can. Do you honestly believe inside you that I'd mention these concerns without cause? I use your products DAILY.

Maybe I just need to take another break. What I am saying is getting taken out of context and my points are being missed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread