I don't like Gaia, I LOVED IT!! If I buy a 100ml bottle, you can bet I love it. Glad to hear that about Dark Horse. I have such a small sample. I never hear anyone talk about it, so I didn't have high hopes for it.
I liked the Caramel Apple Tobacco. I didn't love it, but I liked it. I didn't taste hardly any caramel though. I got some for a flavor change. I love Gaia, and Legend. I liked Heavenly Tobacco, but I think I may need an extra flavor shot of it. If I chain vape it, the taste goes away rather quickly. It is much better aged, and has more flavor. Even the aged can disappear with the taste, if I vape it too long. But it does have major possibilities for me. I have not tried Heavenly Army yet. I just tried the Georgia Peach Tobacco today. I put it in the Panmag. I thought it was good. It is ten days old. This is 30/70, and I asked them to put in extra flavor. It is not what I would call sweet at all. There is something about it though, I like it. I am going to put some in the Kayfun after a while, and see what I think. I have already been through 3 full Magma runs with it. So that is a definite yes, for me.
Huntsman, I really like it when it is aged, but not as much as Gaia. Maple eh? I liked it and will buy again. Good for a flavor change. Not enough maple taste for me. I detect an earthiness about it, and it is a faint version of Huntsman...that same base taste, but a little different. For some reason I liked it better when it was more fresh.
Dragon's Fire, I don't care for it. I should love it, because what people say it tastes like. Maybe it is one of those that I love after it has aged a long time. Blend 4 was that way for me. Dragon's Fire has a weird taste and smell, and it is somewhat repelling to me. I don't know why. The Black Calico by Halo is the same way. Something weird tasting, I can't put my finger on it, not yet anyway. I may like both of these better in time.