Must we call cigarettes "analogs"?

Status
Not open for further replies.

jimrug1

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 27, 2012
402
422
Peoria, IL
IMHO, a cigarette is a cigarette is a cigarette! If it makes one more likely to not smoke one by calling it different names, (stinkies, analogs, death sticks etc) so be it. Seems utterly ridiculous to me. They ARE cigarettes and you either chose to smoke them or you don't!! Sometimes people have to demonize the object of their addiction instead of enhancing their own will power to avoid it.

Cigarettes are kind of like squirrels. Both of them are harmless until you stick one in your mouth and light it on fire... ;-)~
 

HawkeyeFLA

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 2, 2012
3,699
4,791
Clermont, FL

LOL, I just watched that movie with a friend of mine a couple weeks ago.
 

tnt56

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 30, 2012
6,592
11,481
68
Tripple digits half way to home
Bah damn kids! No respect for anything.You werent here 3-4 years ago so you dont have a choice in the matter :)

Its like all your silly remakes of classics movies that shouldnt be touched :)

Now get off my damn lawn!!!!!

LOL now I know we got a lot in common. I didn't think you could hear me when I said that the other day. I fixed em though. I put a fence up so the little buggers can't get in..
 
A bunch of us at the shop I work at recently began vaping.
I was the first of this group to switch entirely to e cigs.
At break one night a few of the guys lit up and I asked what was with the "analogs" not in a disparaging manner.
They laughed at my choice of words.
Don't take the comments about analogs too seriously. With vaping just like anything else there will be those with a snobby attitude.

Just my opinion.
Steve
 

Kropotkin

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 13, 2012
795
15,303
Maine
Calling a cigarette an "analog" is completely ridiculous:

The Miriam Webster Dictionary said:
analogous a·nal·o·gous/əˈnaləgəs/
Adjective:

Comparable in certain respects, typically in a way that makes clearer the nature of the things compared.

Performing a similar function but having a different evolutionary origin, such as the wings of insects and birds.

Synonyms:
similar - like - parallel - alike - analogical

The phrase "analog clock," for instance, refers to the clock's hands moving around the face, which are seen as analogous to the movement of the sun across the sky.

So it's the cigarette that's the original item here, and the e-cig that's the analog, because it resembles or parallels the cigarette.

IOW, calling the cigarette an "analog" is just flat-out back-asswards.
 
Last edited:

Boden

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Sep 7, 2012
5,516
28,164
Lexington KY
Per the OP's question and defining analog in the sense of Analog VS. Digital which concerns signal complexity. Digital signal consists of 1 (on) and 0 (off). An analog signal is spectral. Since both cigarettes and personal vaporizers are either on or off they are both digital.
(plus, you use your digits to work them. ;))

Comparing analog to analogue is a logic error in this context.

BTW I worked as a professional sound engineer for 22 years, digital sound has much higher fidelity than analog. But hey, if you like the sound of vinyl great, but don't say vinyl is more accurate. It's not.
 
Last edited:

DaveP

PV Master & Musician
ECF Veteran
May 22, 2010
16,733
42,646
Central GA
I've always referred to cigarettes as cigarettes or tobacco. That way people understand that I'm not smoking anymore. I tell them I don't smoke tobacco anymore and they immediately ask me "Well then, what is THAT thing in your hand?". Glad you asked ... it's an electronic cigarette. After I explain how it works, their eyes light up and most make a comment about how they need to tell one of their smoking relatives about it.

Ecigs, except for the non-electronic 3.7v battery and tube types, are digital devices. Even in non-variable voltage ecigs, most use a pulse train to control a MOSFET device that sets and regulates voltage to the atomizer coil. If yours doesn't use a MOSFET, then the switch is taking all the current load being sent to the coil.

In the case of variable voltage ecigs, especially those that display voltage, resistance, and have voltage up/down features, they are digital devices and have a tiny ASIC (application specific integrated circuit) inside the tube that performs all those nifty features. If they were analog devices, there would be a variable wirewound resistor much like a volume control that adjusted and withstood the voltage and current passing through on its way to the coil. A mechanical mod is much less reliable than an electronic mod. High current switches and potentiometers have a life based on usage cycles and tend to fail from heat and contact failure.

In the interest of cost for labor and parts, almost all ecigs use electronic components that are in the digital class to lower cost and increase reliability.
 
Last edited:

Langdell

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 12, 2008
114
186
Per the OP's question and defining analog in the sense of Analog VS. Digital which concerns signal complexity. Digital signal consists of 1 (on) and 0 (off). An analog signal is spectral. Since both cigarettes and personal vaporizers are either on or off they are both digital.
(plus, you use your digits to work them. ;))

Comparing analog to analogue is a logic error in this context.

BTW I worked as a professional sound engineer for 22 years, digital sound has much higher fidelity than analog. But hey, if you like the sound of vinyl great, but don't say vinyl is more accurate. It's not.

Never said it was more accurate, just that it sounds better. ;) But that's a debate for another forum; OT here. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread