Jefsview,
Chimps describes it well. I would also say it has a slightly spicy flavour, fairly sweet like Dragon's Fire. I actually think it tastes a bit like Dragon's Fire or Shadow only bolder in its flavour. Pirates Booty is one of my favourite NETS from all vendors.
I am surprised Pirate's Booty is described as Carribean. i can kind of see that but there is definitely none of the what would traditionally be considered Carribean. No pineapple or coconut. I don't like coconut in juices and not fond of pineapple either but this is one of my favorite juices.
If you are sitting on the fence about PB I would say get off it and make sure you fall head deep in a well of Pirates Booty. My only regret with Pirates Booty was not ordering a full size bottle.
Let us know your thoughts if you do order it, after you have tried it.
I was hopelessly hooked on Pirate's Booty for quite awhile. It was nearly identical to the second iteration of Gandalf. Then the batch ran out and a new extraction was made (somewhere around Xmas). It was not the same. It became grassier and lost its charm for me. I moved on to Dragon's Fire which is also near-identical to Gandy 2 and PB1. Adam just made a new batch of DF and it is very close to the previous version.