Direwolf,
I can't speak for GeJ's M type lite as I have not tried it. What I have tried though is my own DIY with M Type concentrate from Flavour apprentice which has a strong leafy flavour and quite pungent. I find it most unpleasant but then again that may have been user error in my mixture. In the bottle, the concentrate smells strongly of pungent leaf. Cigarettes never smelled like 'leaf' to me, at least not this type of pungent tart leaf. I was a benson and hedges smoker which to my understanding is mostly virginia. Vapenstein on his site says that most commercial cigarettes are a mixture of virginia and burley. Burley is grassy and virginia is what I think we mostly associate with cigarettes IMO. I think of Virginia as a medium bodied, middle spectrum tobacco.
Cigarettes are ashy, and don't have any particular flavour apart from medium bodied tobacco. There aren't, for example, cigarettes that taste like tobacco 'and' vanilla/cherry/banana and any rolled tobacco that features cavendish, perique, orientals or other tobacco blends tend to be cigars (except for camel which are more orientals) etc. Cigarettes are non-descript and ashy and lack any real singular flavour coming to the fore. I feel the same way about both of those juices.
It is more for this reason, the 'lack of' other flavours present apart from that middle spectrum, medium bodied tobacco associates Wrangler Light and Wild Turkey to the brands of cigarettes I smoked (B&H, Dunhill and Mild Seven). They don't have any real frontrunning bold flavours the way Patriot or Organic Tobacco have. They are in the middle part of the spectrum of tobacco flavours; not strong and bold like a rich cigar and not light and grassy like a pipe.
I can't speak Gej's M Lite as I have not tried it. What I can say is that a few people on Scarf-ace's Netty awards voted Wrangler Light as being the NET they thought was the closest to a cigarette. I tend to think it is as well though I also find it reminds me of a creamy cigarillo. Not quite cigarette and not quite cigar, but it definitely scratches a cigarette itch for me.
I may have to try both juices again. It's been a couple of weeks since I have vaped either and I bet they have steeped more since.