L'fox -
The OP just said "I don't care what the hardware LOOKS like..at all. I just want something that works well and is reliable and economical".
I think it's indisputable that something like the Joyetech EgO-C Twist - or now, the kGo VV - fitted with a Vivi Nova, or a DCT tank with a 3 ohm carto, or one of a host of very good attachments - will blow away any of those recommendations on virtually any of his stated wants or any other criterion, with the exception of "ciggie-look-alikeness", which wasn't even one of his stated wants.
In short, I'd like to know your rationale for suggesting what you just did.
****
From a post of mine in a galaxy far, far away ....
"I think it's safe to say that the more a PV (Personal Vaporizer - as opposed to, I suppose, an impersonal vaporizer?) looks like a cigarette, the worse it performs (battery life, the ability to use attachments that will give you better flavor, more convenience (like less fiddling with cartridges and refilling thereof), and lack of variable voltage), which in my opinion is a critical part of achieving an optimum vape.
With that in mind, how important is it to you on a scale of 1-10 - with ten being of paramount importance - to have your PV look as much as possible like the things that are presently killing you?
If you can get past the look-alike thing, your vape will (IMO) be better, and (IMO) your chances of getting ciggies out of your life will improve.
I particularly like the $22 Joyetech eGo-C Twist 650mah (variable voltage eGo-class battery) fitted with a Vivi Nova tank/atomizer, which is what I'm vaping on right now.
The Volt is arguably the best of the look-alikes, and performs very well for what it is; a constant-voltage device with a relatively small battery. That said, the setup I'm using right now gives a better vape, and costs about the same, or less".
*****
So again, I'm wondering about the rationale for recommending ciggie-look-alikes to someone who doesn't care what his gear looks like. "Pointed question"? Absolutely. But this is serious business. People are dying. Over 400,000 Americans died from smoking last year. Eighty times the death rate per year of Vietnam. Beginners need the best weapons that it is feasible to equip them with, and IMO that ain't any of the things on your list. Not even close.
I've been told - no, make that admonished - not to comment on the suggestions of others, but I choose to comment on yours and ones like them, since lives are in the balance, and that IMO trumps fine sensibilities, or an unwillingness to have a civil discussion of vaping options and the rationale for one's recommendations based on science, logic, and reason. If we can't do that here, I'll accept a banning gladly, and fight the fight elsewhere.