Nicotine Comparisons

Status
Not open for further replies.

JUDGMENT AFFIRMED

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Jul 24, 2012
1,714
2,006
68
BELLE VERNON PA.
As for residual solvents, I wouldn't want either hexane or CCl4, but if I had to choose, it would be hexane. RTS seems to have less total res solvents, in addition to using an extraction solvent that won't attack the liver. Not a fan of halocarbons.

:confused:
Am I the only one, thinking we need to know more?
 

Kurt

Quantum Vapyre
ECF Veteran
Sep 16, 2009
3,433
3,607
Philadelphia
:confused:
Am I the only one, thinking we need to know more?

This is going back a few weeks I think. My recollection is that there was a confusion between solvent used in extraction, typically an alkane like hexane, and the solvent used to do the GC-MS analysis, which is either CDCl3, CHCl3 or CCl4. This is what was read in the GC-MS analysis page as the "Solvent", but that is irrelevant to us in general...just the solvent used to dilute the sample for GC-MS, not the nicotine-extraction solvent. I've not seen halocarbons used for nic extraction.
 

Bosco

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 20, 2012
702
684
San Antonio
This is going back a few weeks I think. My recollection is that there was a confusion between solvent used in extraction, typically an alkane like hexane, and the solvent used to do the GC-MS analysis, which is either CDCl3, CHCl3 or CCl4. This is what was read in the GC-MS analysis page as the "Solvent", but that is irrelevant to us in general...just the solvent used to dilute the sample for GC-MS, not the nicotine-extraction solvent. I've not seen halocarbons used for nic extraction.

yeah - that was my mistake - I don't know why I even tried to read the lab reports being that I never got more than a C in any science class, lol.

BUT - I really wish I did know more. What bugs me is . .if all these products are 99% pure . . how can they be so different. What makes one nic tasteless and another peppery? Why do some have more throat hit than others?

When you're dealing with 100mg nic that is 99% pure nic and VG . . .that 1% impurity (or water or whatever) is soooo tiny in a 12mg e-juice. .how can 1 nic make me cough and give me a sore throat but another tastes smooth and causes me no issues? What the heck is in that <1%?
 

Kurt

Quantum Vapyre
ECF Veteran
Sep 16, 2009
3,433
3,607
Philadelphia
yeah - that was my mistake - I don't know why I even tried to read the lab reports being that I never got more than a C in any science class, lol.

BUT - I really wish I did know more. What bugs me is . .if all these products are 99% pure . . how can they be so different. What makes one nic tasteless and another peppery? Why do some have more throat hit than others?

When you're dealing with 100mg nic that is 99% pure nic and VG . . .that 1% impurity (or water or whatever) is soooo tiny in a 12mg e-juice. .how can 1 nic make me cough and give me a sore throat but another tastes smooth and causes me no issues? What the heck is in that <1%?

And THAT is the $64,000 question! I do not know. I've asked many manufacturers, and they do not know either. There must be a chemical basis of some kind. The other thing is that quantitatively measuring the amount of some compound, say one of the nic-oxides, means making a standard of it to compare to. Without a standard, you cannot say other than there is trace amounts...of SOMETHING. So even GC-MS is very limited in giving full info about a particular nicotine sample.

There is much we do not know.
 

wolcen

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 9, 2011
1,182
1,302
Boston, MA
www.wolcen.com
FWIW, this is what John @ Wizard Labs told me about the Ice when he first revealed it to me back in Apr 2012:

The new 99.9% [Ice] has been refined a little more to reduce trace minor alkaloids like myosamine, which does seem to lower that strong nic hit but results in an extremely smooth and near tasteless/odorless vape.

It's been amazing to me to learn about flavorings too. We get our flavor chemicals diluted in Alcohol, PG, water, whatever, and some of them even at under %1 of these solutions in our juice are very easy to notice. Crazy how strong some chemicals are.

Too bad dogs can't "name that chemical"...I'm sure they could tell us.
 

r77r7r

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
  • Feb 15, 2011
    13,653
    22,632
    Pa,LandOfTaxes
    I've been trying to find a quality nic place with some Boges and Egos with no luck. I hardly buy anything and still can't shop at just one supplier, lol.

    So I looked at the COST OF VAPING CHART that someone put together here so I can pick some good suppliers and quickly realized that the chart is ineffective for us pre-mixed folks.

    At 6ml aday using 12mg pre-mixed 70/30, it's Very much cheaper at WL than the other places. Enough so that I can go anywheres to get my ego/boge fix and still do great.
     

    casey8579

    Senior Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jun 6, 2009
    108
    127
    Near Wilmington NC
    I've been trying to find a quality nic place with some Boges and Egos with no luck. I hardly buy anything and still can't shop at just one supplier, lol.

    So I looked at the COST OF VAPING CHART that someone put together here so I can pick some good suppliers and quickly realized that the chart is ineffective for us pre-mixed folks.



    At 6ml aday using 12mg pre-mixed 70/30, it's Very much cheaper at WL than the other places. Enough so that I can go anywheres to get my ego/boge fix and still do great.

    Not sure of exactly what products you are looking for, but ECX carries boge cartomizers and ego products and if I remember correctly their diy nic has been spoken of well here in this thread.
     

    Kurt

    Quantum Vapyre
    ECF Veteran
    Sep 16, 2009
    3,433
    3,607
    Philadelphia
    I've been trying to find a quality nic place with some Boges and Egos with no luck. I hardly buy anything and still can't shop at just one supplier, lol.

    So I looked at the COST OF VAPING CHART that someone put together here so I can pick some good suppliers and quickly realized that the chart is ineffective for us pre-mixed folks.

    At 6ml aday using 12mg pre-mixed 70/30, it's Very much cheaper at WL than the other places. Enough so that I can go anywheres to get my ego/boge fix and still do great.

    I get my Boge LR cartos from Litecig. Buy 10 boxes of 5 cartos, and it comes out to about $5.50 a box, give or take a bit. I've heard of others getting better deals, but I like giving Litecig my business. And never had a DOA. They have a bunch of Ego gear too. Prices there are average to good.
     

    JUDGMENT AFFIRMED

    Ultra Member
    ECF Veteran
    Jul 24, 2012
    1,714
    2,006
    68
    BELLE VERNON PA.
    I get my Boge LR cartos from Litecig. Buy 10 boxes of 5 cartos, and it comes out to about $5.50 a box, give or take a bit. I've heard of others getting better deals, but I like giving Litecig my business. And never had a DOA. They have a bunch of Ego gear too. Prices there are average to good.

    Joyetech, I started with two kits that I got from litecig in june. Everything still works.
     

    casey8579

    Senior Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jun 6, 2009
    108
    127
    Near Wilmington NC
    TY Casey, I hadn't tried their nic before. Have you, and how have you liked it?

    No, I haven't used their nic ( I buy from Wizard Labs), but they are one the shops I use for flavoring and other things and wouldn't hesitate to recommend them. I mentioned them because I remembered them being spoken well of for their nic, as in Kurt's post just above.
     

    Kurt

    Quantum Vapyre
    ECF Veteran
    Sep 16, 2009
    3,433
    3,607
    Philadelphia
    Started reading this thread about 2 hours ago, Just reached post 401

    the space monkeys have gone away and I'm feeling better

    will push on, supply of snacks and beer looking good

    Hope to reach end of thread some time tonight...

    Hey Boden, good to see you! PM sent about another issue we were discussing last fall.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread