The Really Big RY4 Roundup (long)

Status
Not open for further replies.

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
Bill.... does the MOV RY4 seem to have other flavors or does the 3 flavors just not have a even mixed taste, is one overpowering?

I don't know how many flavors CountRY4 has as components. Dude wrote that it was the classic three (tobacco, caramel, and vanilla), but I honestly can't tell. In fact, my palate couldn't discern any individual flavors in CountRY4. So, it's either very well-blended (if you like it) or puréed (if you don't). But don't take my word for it. My palate is kind of worn out these days.
 

thehangdude

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 17, 2011
11,437
21,721
63
Terre Haute, IN
LOL, that's why I took 8 days to do 8 flavors.

Here is what I put in my review of it.

"The caramel in CCRY4 is rich. It is not a milky or candy caramel. It reminds me of the caramel my favorite ice cream shop ladled onto my scoop of vanilla. I can picture the rich, caramelized, redish-brown goo as I vape this treat. The caramel lingers, forming a perfect base note to the eliquid.

"On the high side, the bright vanilla rounds out this RY4 blend. This is a light vanilla extract, not a heavy vanilla bean. It forms a great contrast to the rich caramel.

"Classic CountRY4 is well balanced. Good tobacco, rich caramel, and a bright vanilla form one of the best RY4s I have had. It is easily an all-day vape. This is yet another outstanding ejuice from Mountain Oak Vapors. They have created a fantastic tobacco blend, and continue to compliment it with quality flavorings. Classic CountRY4 easily gets an A."

I suggest you take a break bill. We don't want you to lose your taste buds! Vape some Gooey Butter Cake for a few days. We will be here.
 

passerbyeus

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 13, 2009
1,443
838
Kentucky
Bill ...I have been vaping raspberry danish from copper creek to help my burn out, I was totally not a fruit vapor but it has helped and the fruit they have is the best I have ever tried, the danish part even scratches the tobacoo itch in a way....I should be getting my mov ry4 tomorrow so hopefully ill be back with a smile on my face..:D
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
passer,

Before the mailbox gift tsunami hit on Saturday, I'd already started vaping Ecoberry from want2vape. At the time, I didn't think of it as a palate cleanser, but maybe instinct was taking over. My juice database says that I've got a 6ml bottle of Copper Creek Raspberry Danish in my stash. I can even remember seeing the label when I first got it. I'll vape some of that as soon as I can scavenge through the juice cabinets to find it. LOL.

Fruit vapes! Yeah, that's the ticket...
 

scarf-ace

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
I have spent a week wading through this thread and it is brilliant.Thanks to Billherbst, zombie, hangdude for writing such informative and funny reviews. My favorites are Pink Spot RY8 and good old DK-TAB which i have doctored with butterscotch and bavarian cream. Only problem is i now have a verrry big shopping list;)

I will chip in soon with reviews of some Australian RY4s.
 

passerbyeus

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 13, 2009
1,443
838
Kentucky
Australian RY4s :ohmy: great I still have not tried all in the US yet......




I have spent a week wading through this thread and it is brilliant.Thanks to Billherbst, zombie, hangdude for writing such informative and funny reviews. My favorites are Pink Spot RY8 and good old DK-TAB which i have doctored with butterscotch and bavarian cream. Only problem is i now have a verrry big shopping list;)

I will chip in soon with reviews of some Australian RY4s.
 

Zombitedesade

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jun 27, 2011
331
134
45
Plymouth, uk
Just goes to show though, Ry8 for example is one of my least fave Ry4 vareints! I find the over strong vanillia heavy mix completed overtakes any other flavours which might have been present! For me RY8 had an unmistakable metallic, burnt custard taste to it.

To be fair though, I have since tried other pink spot flavours and I didn't really like any of them. For me persoanly they are not a vendor I get along with. Just another example of how, after all is done, this thread is all a bit of fun and info, but ultimately, you can't really knowif you'll like a juice till you've tried it yourself.

I feel much the same about FSUSA mixes too incidentally. Looking back through juices I actually favour, it's intresting to note almost all are actually of the mass produced chinese variety! Whilst I probabley should know, I didn't actually know where Janty originates. I'm guessing it's Europe: over towards Finland, Switzerland way but I'm really not sure.
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
Funny, I made some flavors at ec blend and one was ry4 with maple.....I thought I was the only one who thought it would be interesting. Ill have to try mbv ry4 then

I'll bet that folks have tried just about everything under the sun to sweeten RY4 and other juices---from blackstrap molasses to macerated naturally-extracted stevia root. Whatever works to please your palate.
 

Roxxette

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 4, 2012
1,535
656
Caribbean
ive try a some of ikenvape ry4 (pg blend) and if people enjoy halo's tribecca they should really try ikenvape ry4 because its almost the same thing :) and the price is far better !

Flavor is very crisp and bright in these ry4 but a bit too strong almost like a 555 , myself im not a big fan of those flavors anymore wich is a surprise because i love bwb 555 wich have a very strong flavor and smell (the only juice from bwb that i have try that have a power flavor) but like like i say too much for me but maybe for others is the ry4 all day vape they looking ! :)
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
ive try a some of ikenvape ry4 (pg blend) and if people enjoy halo's tribecca they should really try ikenvape ry4 because its almost the same thing :) and the price is far better !

Flavor is very crisp and bright in these ry4 but a bit too strong almost like a 555 , myself im not a big fan of those flavors anymore wich is a surprise because i love bwb 555 wich have a very strong flavor and smell (the only juice from bwb that i have try that have a power flavor) but like like i say too much for me but maybe for others is the ry4 all day vape they looking ! :)

roxxette,

After reading your post, I wanted to see how I felt about your linkage. So, I grabbed my cartos of IKV RY4 Gold PG and Halo Tribeca, screwed the cartos onto two identical VV boxes, and had at it.

As readers of this thread may already know, I'm not a big fan of Halo's signature "purity" base undertone (understatement), since to my palate it tastes unpleasantly antiseptic, like the smell of a hospital room. My initial review of Tribeca (post #157) reflected that bias, and its ranking never got very high in the Big List. But many months of steeping has dissipated that undertone, and now, on those occasions when I comparison-test Tribeca against other RY4s, I'm very impressed. The component flavors (tobacco, caramel, and vanilla) and their mix ratios in Tribeca were always great, and since that's all I taste now (no more medicinal disinfectant undertone), I hold Tribeca in high esteem as one of the very best RY4s I've ever had.

OK, with that recanting established, do I think that IKV RY4 Gold tastes like Tribeca? No, I don't. For one thing, IKV Gold has a pronounced nuttiness that carries the other flavors in its mix. Tribeca, on the other hand, has no nuttiness at all. Zero.

Second, while I agree that Tribeca has a classic RY4 brightness---in part, because of the remnants of Halo's "purity" base---I don't find IKV Gold to be bright at all. It's not dark, really, but it's certainly not "bright." I guess I'd call it mid-range or medium on the bass-treble scale (the audio term would be "flat," but that conveys the wrong impression with a juice, so I won't use it). What I get from IKV Gold is a happy medium, even though the caramel and tobacco predominate, with only a hint of vanilla. And all wrapped in pleasing nuttiness (which, I agree, leans in the direction of 555, but stops short, staying in RY4 Land).

Finally, Tribeca has a kick of sweetness that IKV doesn't. Tribeca isn't cloyingly sweet (as some dessert RY4s can be), but it carries a slightly sharp sweet sensation on my tongue, like a punctuation mark of sweetness. By contrast, IKV Gold is rich but not particularly sweet.

Please understand, I'm not challenging your post. Taste is subjective, and we taste what we taste. So, thanks for contributing to the thread. I'm just chiming in with an alternate perception. I find both these juices to be superlative RY4s, each in its own way. If I want a great nutty tobacco-caramel RY4, I'd reach for Ikenvape Gold any day. If I want a bright, clean RY4 with no nuts, Tribeca (after lengthy stepping) will fill the bill happily---forgive my bad double entendre, LOL.

If I were looking for an RY4 as an all-day vape, however, I probably wouldn't turn to either of these. Instead, I'd consider slightly more laid back custom RY4s, such as Spring Vapor Black Label Day and Night, and especially Mountain Oak Vapor CountRY4, both of which seem to me specifically formulated to be smoother all-day vapes.
 

Roxxette

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 4, 2012
1,535
656
Caribbean
love your post Bill and always , you mention tribeca change after a big steep ? i might have to give that a try (i always give to friends lol) maybe thats why feel the taste the same ? nah dont think so like you say its all about the taste buds !

Im with you on the "laid back/customs" ry4 , for some reason i just dont enjoy overpowering flavors....
 

passerbyeus

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 13, 2009
1,443
838
Kentucky
Have you tried Heather's Heavenly Vape RY4 , its overpowering and has that chesty you may like.


Also :p...There is a new juice from the makers of the Juice of the year 2011.. Copper Creek .......here is the description ....A decadent blend of tobaccos with tones of rich cream, and just a hint of caramel......... So tobacco .., tones of cream hmmm would that be vanilla? , and caramel......sounds like the holy trilogy to me :D

http://www.shopcoppercreek.com/Voos-Broo_p_186.html


love your post Bill and always , you mention tribeca change after a big steep ? i might have to give that a try (i always give to friends lol) maybe thats why feel the taste the same ? nah dont think so like you say its all about the taste buds !

Im with you on the "laid back/customs" ry4 , for some reason i just dont enjoy overpowering flavors....
 
Last edited:

wigglr

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 23, 2011
1,472
383
Massachusetts
That's interesting to hear Bill in regard to the change in Halo's base to your palate. I have had the same issues with all the Halo juices I have tried. As you said, there is some "antiseptic" tone to it; however, if that changes after steeping maybe I should give it a try...?

roxxette,

After reading your post, I wanted to see how I felt about your linkage. So, I grabbed my cartos of IKV RY4 Gold PG and Halo Tribeca, screwed the cartos onto two identical VV boxes, and had at it.

As readers of this thread may already know, I'm not a big fan of Halo's signature "purity" base undertone (understatement), since to my palate it tastes unpleasantly antiseptic, like the smell of a hospital room. My initial review of Tribeca (post #157) reflected that bias, and its ranking never got very high in the Big List. But many months of steeping has dissipated that undertone, and now, on those occasions when I comparison-test Tribeca against other RY4s, I'm very impressed. The component flavors (tobacco, caramel, and vanilla) and their mix ratios in Tribeca were always great, and since that's all I taste now (no more medicinal disinfectant undertone), I hold Tribeca in high esteem as one of the very best RY4s I've ever had.

OK, with that recanting established, do I think that IKV RY4 Gold tastes like Tribeca? No, I don't. For one thing, IKV Gold has a pronounced nuttiness that carries the other flavors in its mix. Tribeca, on the other hand, has no nuttiness at all. Zero.

Second, while I agree that Tribeca has a classic RY4 brightness---in part, because of the remnants of Halo's "purity" base---I don't find IKV Gold to be bright at all. It's not dark, really, but it's certainly not "bright." I guess I'd call it mid-range or medium on the bass-treble scale (the audio term would be "flat," but that conveys the wrong impression with a juice, so I won't use it). What I get from IKV Gold is a happy medium, even though the caramel and tobacco predominate, with only a hint of vanilla. And all wrapped in pleasing nuttiness (which, I agree, leans in the direction of 555, but stops short, staying in RY4 Land).

Finally, Tribeca has a kick of sweetness that IKV doesn't. Tribeca isn't cloyingly sweet (as some dessert RY4s can be), but it carries a slightly sharp sweet sensation on my tongue, like a punctuation mark of sweetness. By contrast, IKV Gold is rich but not particularly sweet.

Please understand, I'm not challenging your post. Taste is subjective, and we taste what we taste. So, thanks for contributing to the thread. I'm just chiming in with an alternate perception. I find both these juices to be superlative RY4s, each in its own way. If I want a great nutty tobacco-caramel RY4, I'd reach for Ikenvape Gold any day. If I want a bright, clean RY4 with no nuts, Tribeca (after lengthy stepping) will fill the bill happily---forgive my bad double entendre, LOL.

If I were looking for an RY4 as an all-day vape, however, I probably wouldn't turn to either of these. Instead, I'd consider slightly more laid back custom RY4s, such as Spring Vapor Black Label Day and Night, and especially Mountain Oak Vapor CountRY4, both of which seem to me specifically formulated to be smoother all-day vapes.
 

billherbst

Vaping Master
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2010
4,239
9,486
Columbia, Missouri
www.billherbst.com
That's interesting to hear Bill in regard to the change in Halo's base to your palate. I have had the same issues with all the Halo juices I have tried. As you said, there is some "antiseptic" tone to it; however, if that changes after steeping maybe I should give it a try...?

Yeah, and it took only six months of steeping for the undertone to diminish! LOL.
 

midficollege

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 8, 2011
156
90
Texas
Apparently, SweeneyTodd of Stealth Vapors (stvapor.com) is developing an RY4 now based on his Tobacco Midnight tobacco flavor which has been getting lots of love on another forum.

I've been only impressed with what I've tried of his (though I haven't yet had the chance to try the Midnight, I'm certainly going to put in a 30ml*24mg order with him the next time I get around to buying juices). Very keen palate with his Samoa Cookie flavor having just the right amount of coconut to make the whole thing work.

This "RY4 Midnight" (my name, not his) is very likely to be the first "boutique" RY4 I order.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread