Where is your juice REALLY comming from?

Status
Not open for further replies.

UntamedRose

PV Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 23, 2010
7,427
39,123
Homeish now
That's what I think. Just like how 'omega-3 eggs' or 'free range eggs' (I never buy organic either) aren't regulated, just a label to make the consumer feel less conscious about the process.

Ruben, what are those legal requirements and why aren't they applied to the food examples I gave? You'd think it's going to be enforced with food first and it isn't.

Because the legal requirements he gave...arnt for food/consumables, they are for manufactured goods like cars, jeans, toys.
People dont bake a cake in NYC, and then say it was made in France because thats where the flour came from.


And I disagree with the premise of the OP for several reasons.
1. Being "Made in the USA" is guarantee for quality, I know we like to think so..but it really isnt. Now there is something to be said for wanting to support your local economy, but that isnt the charge of this thread.

2. Looking at my own DIY suppliers...My VG is made in made in IL, PG is manufactured in OH, Nic is from FL, and flavorings..ya thats all over, the places I use the most are two from CA, and Italy.
 

deusXmchna

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 11, 2010
238
3
TX
Even then is the nic part of the extract? For instance, TV does their own tobacco, using maceration on the leaves, but I expect they still then use a nic base to hit the final mg/ml. Self-derived organic flavoring is not the same thing as US-derived nicotine.
(There's then, of course, a whole separate question of whether something is "better" for you just because it is local, organic. What the final chemical compounds are, that you are inhaling, is what matters, no matter how those chemicals were sourced. I can extract juice from poison ivy, doesn't mean you should vape it. Organic is not magic, end of the day you are inhaling chemicals.)

Yeah, I find the VR tobacco tea-as-flavoring to be a suspect idea. It introduces a host of variables, and unless he has an analytical lab checking each batch, my guess is that the nicotine levels fluctuate considerably.
I'm not saying this is necessarily a huge danger for nicotine addicts that have a tolerance, but it may be the type of thing that gets us shut down.
"Man in basement.... (fill in the rest with the myriad of things that the media could).."
 

beetlespin

Guest
Oct 22, 2010
112
0
53
Al
Personally I believe all of this Nic is derived from China & Belgium, if not I would like for someone to tell me the place that is extracting it here in the USA. @ Stonz do you know where this place is ? I'm not talking about just buying from someone like Box Elder but an actual plant that is here in the USA extracting Nicotine ? I would love to know myself and have tried to find out before where this plant is ? anyone who knows of this plant here in the good old USA please inform me or all of us ?

I read some where that BWB extract he's own Nicotine.
 

RubenX

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 28, 2011
162
6
Longwood
...
People dont bake a cake in NYC, and then say it was made in France because thats where the flour came from.
...

No, they will say "USA Made, with gourmet French Flour!". Last time I went to Cici's Pizza they had on display all the ingredients used. You could pick up a can of tomato sauce and see who made it & where it came from. They didn't told me "just trust us and eat your pizza". And that's the way it is with most businesses, specially in the food industry. They do disclose where the ingredients come from. I do not understand why so many e-juice suppliers get all bent out of shape when I point out that their USA stuff is mostly imported nic bases, flavored on site and re-branded.

It gets better when that same supplier also tells me to "trust" him that his Ego batteries are "genuine Joye products" and not cheap knock-offs.
 

deusXmchna

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 11, 2010
238
3
TX
I read some where that BWB extract he's own Nicotine.

I'd bet my dog that he's not.
Well, I'd bet my dog that he's not doing it properly, or well.
People have been extracting "nicotine" from various tobaccos on the internet for use as poisons for their home-made dart guns, and in hopes of knocking off grandma, since the old days of 2400baud modems, BBS's, and tens of different e-versions of the Anarchist Cookbook (which was dangerous enough with its bad science & chem as it was, then when people started playing "telephone" with it and changing it.....whew).

I'm tellin' ya. It takes a _real_ lab to extract & separate nicotine (and then purify it).
Far more difficult than even most street drugs. (well, street drugs with the crud purity of street drugs).

If there is a post where BWB makes the claim that he is extracting his own nicotine, please link to it.
Otherwise you are doing him a disservice by posting rumor. Dangerous rumor for him.
 

FantWriter

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 11, 2010
601
5,429
Kentucky
If it's mixed in the US, then it fully qualifies as "Made in the USA."

If you were to require that absolutely every item in it came the US, then with today's globalism, virtually nothing made or sold would qualify.

I used to make electrical connectors. They were made from brass bars bought from an American wholesaler. The brass was made at an American foundry. The copper came from an American mine. The zinc, however, most likely came from Canada. Does that mean we shouldn't have labeled them "Made in USA" or should have put on a disclaimer that 2.4% of the value of the finished goods were imported?

Pure nic juice made in one country is identical to pure nic juice made in another. One would have to go down to parts-per-billion in order to find the slightest difference in trace elements.

If I ever get things together, I'll start DIY. If I buy nic juice from China, flavoring from France, and VG from Mexico, I'm still going to say I made it myself!
 

Stownz

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 29, 2010
2,027
563
Guthrie, OK
Extracting their own nicotine and selling it to you? WTf is wrong with yall? Why would you ever purchase anthing from some guy throwing chems at some tobaco leaves? Because it tastes more like a cig? seriously? Am I the only one completely blown away?

I pray to God, everyday that it is an actual lab extracting nicotine from tobacco. I don't care if its china, or pakistan. As long as it is a lab of some type. The idea of some guy soaking tobaco leaves in his basement is insane. 4000 chemicals we were inhaling before, then add that to some guy throwing whatever he read on ECF at some tobaco leaves then mixing it all up and selling it to you......

China nicotine is not near as much a concern as things like this. Your not just vaporising nicotine, your vaporizing what they use for flavors also, much greater concern there.

thread should be locked so another website doesn't pop up with "USA made ejuice, we extract our own Nicotine !!"
 
Last edited:

IOU

Resting In Peace
ECF Veteran
Dec 18, 2010
6,446
2,508
Laguna Beach, California
I asked one manufacturer and this is the answer I received;
"I looked for a US based supplier for nic. I didn't have any luck. By prices I assume anyone in the US is reselling.

What I did find out is that pharma companies are buying their nic from overseas. I get my nic from the same place Johnson & Johnson does for their gum and patches. All suppliers give COA's(certificate of analysis) to show the product is within spec.

Same story with PG and VG. The sellers are american but who knows the manufacturer.

Long story short, the paper trail is good but don't claim it's USA from start to finish. not much is anymore."
 

deusXmchna

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 11, 2010
238
3
TX
Extracting their own nicotine and selling it to you? WTf is wrong with yall? Why would you ever purchase anthing from some guy throwing chems at some tobaco leaves? Because it tastes more like a cig? seriously? Am I the only one completely blown away?

No. That's why I continue in this and other threads. (Despite the fact that it makes me unpopular). I don't think the average individual understands... the variables, and how those variables multiply expotentially with every new weird-ness added. How every variable adds it's own unique danger, and .... man, little device in my head that I use to visualize exponential math & variables just keeps getting larger and more complex the longer I write this paragraph. (that's probably babble to everyone but me- sorry.)


The idea of some guy soaking tobaco leaves in his basement is insane. 4000 chemicals we were inhaling before, then add that to some guy throwing whatever he read on ECF at some tobaco leaves then mixing it all up and selling it to you......

And yet it's happening. And apparently it tastes good. And I'll probably even order some since they got a good review on their RY4... but I'm rather cavalier with what I'll do with/to my body. The yardstick I use as to whether I should speak against it, is "would I let my best friend use/do this?". It's also the same yardstick I use to recommend things. While it's not nearly as low a standard as what I'll do to myself, it's also apparently not that high of a standard. I keep getting rapped on the knuckles in the chem related threads/forums for not being safe enough with my lab techniques.

So, if the actual experts think that I'm not safe enough, by transitive property- if something is making ME nervous, then people should worry.

thread should be locked so another website doesn't pop up with "USA made ejuice, we extract our own Nicotine !!"

No. This thread should keep going so it doesn't fade into obscurity, and whats here is lost. Stownz, your posts here are some of the most important. I realize that we keep repeating ourselves in this thread and similar ones, but this is info that needs repeating. Hopefully by the time our fingertips are hoarse from "screaming", someone new will pick up the mantle.

People should know that the practice of "macerating and soaking tobacco" in PG, WILL extract tobacco alkaloids, and a host of other things. Mold spores. Mildew. All sorts of things. The levels of the nic & tobacco alkaloids extracted will be different starting with the tobacco itself (meaning the time of year that batch was grown/harvested, the soil, the rain, the days of sun, etc. etc. etc.), how fine the tobacco is ground, then how long it's soaked in the PG, at what temp, how it's separated (is it squeezed?). The complexity of trying to guess an answer is... overwhelming. Then, how is it filtered? Through a coffee filter?
Hopefully though some type of μm resolution filter. I don't know what the potential microscopic "funk" is that's going to be in it (spores, bacteria, etc)- but if I was going to sell it, I'd DAMN SURE research it, find out, and mechanically filter for it if I could. 0.22μ filters catch most things, but it's probably overkill for the job, and putting PG through a 0.22μ filter would be a very time consuming endeavor, if possible at all- but again, that size might be overkill, a 50μ filter might be fine. I dunno- one would want to research it if they were selling it.
I know someone is thinking "but PG kills microscopic baddies", yes, but even dead microscopic baddies elicit a response from the immune system, sometimes an overwhelming, anaphylactic one.

If you're going to play with tobacco extractions yourself, that's one thing. It's being discussed and done almost in real-time
in some threads right now, but the standard of stuff you make yourself is a much different standard from one that should be used when selling it to people who don't know/understand the dangers.

Selling these products commercially, is the type of thing that will get us shut down even quicker. If you think I can find fault & danger, imagine the fault & dangers the FDA, with their chemists who are trained to find danger, will find.

I suggest everyone read this by DVap:
Soaking tobacco for nicotine and flavor - A chemists' perspective
 
Last edited:

DC2

Tootie Puffer
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 21, 2009
24,161
40,974
San Diego
That's why I continue in this and other threads. (Despite the fact that it makes me unpopular). I don't think the average individual understands... the variables, and how those variables multiply expotentially with every new weird-ness added. How every variable adds it's own unique danger.
If you need any encouragement to keep it up, then let me gladly supply it.

We need more people like you, talking about facts and reality.
In fact, our cause needs more people well-versed in their field of expertise from all angles.

Not just chemistry or biology or phamacology, but also law or marketing or politics, and every other discipline.
We are all in this together, and we all need each other, because no one else is going to help us.

Thanks for your diligence.
And thanks for your honesty.
 

cleolove

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 9, 2011
2,804
2,361
62
♥ Minnesota ♥
If you need any encouragement to keep it up, then let me gladly supply it.

We need more people like you, talking about facts and reality.
In fact, our cause needs more people well-versed in their field of expertise from all angles.

Not just chemistry or biology or phamacology, but also law or marketing or politics, and every other discipline.
We are all in this together, and we all need each other, because no one else is going to help us.

Thanks for your diligence.
And thanks for your honesty.

+1 I agree 100% ... Keep it up. This has been an interesting read and I intend to follow it .. there ARE so many questions that need to be asked, and answered. If you don't have the courage to do so, who will?

Thanks for being the one who asks, OP and all others willing to speak up asking unpopular questions.

Peace,
cleo
 
Last edited:

mwa102464

Resting In Peace
ECF Veteran
Oct 14, 2009
14,447
12,564
Outside of the Philadelphia Burbs, NJ & Fla
Nice Job deusXmchna, I'm glad I'm not the only one who couldn't give a hoot what others think about what I know is true in my findings with certain things and voicing those opinions, this thread does need to continue even if to just educate the people who are curious or wondering themselves about this topic.
 

deusXmchna

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 11, 2010
238
3
TX
In the post above, I mentioned Stownz name as an important poster in this thread, because he wanted to shut it down.... and one should never let their own work drift into oblivion:facepalm:

There are obviously lots of important posts, and intelligent people posting them. There's quite a bit of credit due to people here. I didn't mean to omit.

The questions, and the errors are equally important.
It's only through debate and discourse that we can distill truth :)

I wish we could find an active way to self-police this cottage industry better, in order to save it. I don't think anyone means to be doing whack-a-ding stuff (or I could be wrong.)
I just hate being a cop :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread