I too really like these folks, this thread sent me to their site - thank you GeeYourHairSmellsTerrific! It turns out that flavors are really very subjective, and things which appeal on paper may not in reality.
Firstly, VG is fantastic! No more soreness, less drying, and super vapor. I'll be sticking with VG from now on.
As for the flavors:
Black Clove - to me it is really more of an anise flavor, and is way too strong. Like inhaling pizelles.
Cherry Cappuccino - way more cherry than cappuccino, like cough syrup.
Cherry - again, cough syrup. Ok, maybe a cough drop.
Blackberry Champagne - this one smells in the bottle like it'll be a cough syrup, but then turns out much smoother in an atomizer. This one I'll actually use!
Keoke Coffee - great at 3.7 volts, a bit powerful at 6 volts, but an awesome flavor with a sweetish inhale, and a coffee exhale. I bought a big jug of this flavor!
Menthol - it came as some surprise to me that I love this flavor! I haven't smoked menthol since the 70's, but this brought back everything that was ever nice about it - a dead ringer! It's perfect at 3.7 and 6 volts, and I ordered more of this too.
One thing that was well appreciated was the ease of use of their website, as pointed out by a previous poster - I know that small business owners do not necessarily want to become web designers, but so many PV suppliers have atrocious and impossible websites, and if I can't find what I am looking for easily I am going to go elsewhere in a hurry. It's sort of a self respect issue too - if they can't be bothered to have an effective and attractive storefront, why would I expect their business to be well run? American E-Liquid's site is not flashy, but it is clean and simple to use.
They ship super fast, and I am really liking the company, now that I've narrowed down flavors that suit me!